10 ms·
As a side note I use Schwab as a checking account and it’s incredible. Zero fees. Reimbursement of ATM fees. Easy overdraft protection from the brokerage accoun
by whalesalad 7y ago
As a side note I use Schwab as a checking account and it’s incredible. Zero fees. Reimbursement of ATM fees. Easy overdraft protection from the brokerage account. I love them as a bank.
This is even more reason to love them.
I’ve used Chase, Citi, was a Simple customer for a long time... and Schwab blows all of them out of the water.
- ndaiger 7y agoGreat customer service, too. Punch in your account number and you get a smart human immediately. No scripts.
- Consultant32452 7y agoI will second Schwab as an amazing bank. I would also add Fidelity as a great option in this same space. I use them now, only because my employer 401k is there and it keeps everything in one place.
- axaxs 7y agoImportant to note: they are one of the very few banks who do reimbursement of ATM fees not just in the USA, but worldwide!
- mlthoughts2018 7y agoIs it really few? I’ve never had a bank that didn’t. Three university federal credit unions, then later TD Bank.
- loeg 7y agoCredit unions are usually more consumer friendly than for-profit banks.
- an_account 7y agoLots of smaller regional banks pay ATM fees, as they don’t want to run their own fleet of ATMs. And they have local branches when you need it, like for a cashiers check.
- mnky9800n 7y agoWorldwide? I find that difficult to believe.
- hawaiianbrah 7y agoTD requires a minimum balance to refund fees, don’t they?
- arcticbull 7y agoHSBC premier does too.
- whitepoplar 7y agoStory time: when I was fresh out of college, I deposited a check to my Schwab bank account via mobile deposit, but realized that I wasn't going to have enough time for the funds to clear before I needed to write a check from my account to my new landlord. I called Schwab customer service, not really thinking that they would do anything, but to my surprise, the banker said "Let's fix this for you!" and suggested that we conference call the counterparty check's bank to verbally confirm the funds, at which point he manually cleared the funds into my account and told me "You're good to go!" Schwab has some of the best customer service I've ever experienced, even for new (i.e. poor) grads ;)
- drevil-v2 7y agoThat sounds pretty dubious to me. Either you deposited a check from your account held at a different bank or a check someone else gave you drawn on their account. If it was your own account, then during the conference call you had to give out your personal information to identify yourself as the account holder at the other bank, all while the Schwab agent is listening in.. Or if it was someone else's account then that other bank's agent should never have discussed anything to do with that account with you and certainly not with some random other person (the Schwab agent) listening in.
- FakeComments 7y agoWhat are you talking about? The drafting bank always tells the depositing bank if those funds are available, which is what they did here: it’s how checks work. You would discover the same information yourself, when it cleared or didn’t. If you take a check to the drafting bank, they’ll check the funds in the account right then and there and either pay you or tell you there are insufficient funds. All that happened is they did it on the phone rather than through a clearing house or in person, but the exact same information was exchanged: 1. The account number and amount on the check was reported to the drafting bank, which both the depositor and his bank knew from the check already. 2. The drafting bank confirmed those funds were available, which would have been revealed when the check cleared or didn’t through other means. Having a bank call another bank to clear a check isn’t uncommon — I’ve had it done with payroll checks for the same reason, that I needed to pay rent.
- numbers 7y agoSeriously considering switching to Schwab from US Bank and USAA
- loeg 7y agoUSBank is awful, dump that shit. I don't have any quelms with USAA, but I happened to luck into their 2.5% everything credit card while it was still being offered and will stick with them as long as they don't discontinue that.
- JoBrad 7y agoMy experience with US Bank is similar. Horrible service. I’ve been a USAA customer for a while. I get all the benefits OP stated. Would recommend them anytime.
- whalesalad 7y agoI have them for my business account because I couldn’t find anything better for a small business. The experience sucked from day one going to the branch but at this point I don’t want to waste time setting up an account elsewhere. I also receive wire transfers for most of my consulting work so going back and bothering all my customers to change routing numbers is a burden I don’t want to put on them unnecessarily.
- RandomBacon 7y agoI would keep USAA, I've always had good experiences with them. They've even implemented a suggestion I had into their app (talked with customer service who said they would forward it to the appropriate team). Also one time when I had an issue with MobileDeposit, the first person I spoke with immediately forwarded me to the right person who could see the image of the check I tried to submit and suggested I turn the check upside down and take the picture (that worked btw, the routing and account numbers were printed on the page border). They also had Coinbase integration for several years now (fwiw).
- tempsy 7y agoAs far as challenger banks go I’ve found SoFi Money to be really good. 1.8% APY and unlimited ATM fee rebates worldwide as well. I haven’t found anything more generous, Schwab included given the APY.
- SteveNuts 7y agoI'm curious, do they have an option for automated/recurring investments? Like can I set an account to purchase an ETF on a schedule?
- hughes 7y agoShort answer: Yes. Long answer: You can set up automated transfers to your investing account. In order to set up automated investments, you must submit a paper form, which can trigger recurring purchases from your account's cash balance, or from direct deposit.
- hrez 7y agoPeper form, really. Is there anybody else from big boys that would allow to define a basket of ETF's and auto-invest deposited money to it fee free? I know only of m1finance.com For some reason nobody does that. Vanguard can sort of do it with mutual funds only.
- Spooky23 7y agoAgree Schwab is an awesome bank account. Their one and only flaw that is a killer for some is the ACH hold policy — they hold all incoming transfers for at least 4 business days in many cases. You can get in a pickle if you don’t realize it and have a tight timeline to transfer funds at tax time or whatever.
- cortesoft 7y agoAs others have pointed out, you can call customer service and they can often get the hold cleared while you are on the phone. They will conference in the other bank to verify.
- financethrwway 7y agoThere is no hold period for funds pushed to Schwab (aside from the ACH delay from the bank that is the source of the funds).
- xycodex 7y agoSchwab gives you a few free domestic wires a quarter I think, I ran into this situation as well which got me out of such a pickle
- mountainofdeath 7y agoI only think that applies for accounts opened in the last 90 days and/or with limited assets. I have been a customer for years and have a substantial amount in my brokerage accounts with them and all my ACH transactions clear the next business day; rarely two business days.
- Spooky23 7y agoI was imprecise in my writing. The specific circumstance was that I initiated an external ACH transfer from a Schwab Bank Checking account, which pulled funds from a remote bank, there was a default 4 day hold. See: https://client.schwab.com/secure/file/P-7111230/Deposit_holdsrev.pdf https://client.schwab.com/secure/file/P-7111230/Deposit_hold... I don't keep alot of money in the bank accounts, but have a non-trivial relationship on the brokerage side. Other banks (Credit Union, Capital One) typically clear these in 24-48 hours. It's not a "deal breaker" for me, and Schwab is an awesome bank, it's just a gotcha that can be problematic in some circumstances. If you have a business and pull money from one account to another, etc your process needs to keep it in mind!
- maximente 7y agohow was schwab better than simple? simple offers better checking interest by a lot, as far as i can tell; i'm tempted to switch because of that, keeping schwab for foreign ATM usage
- whalesalad 7y agoI don’t use my checking account as an investment account. Yes Simple has a higher interest rate but my checking account only ever has whatever it needs to fulfill rent and bills. Everything else gets allocated elsewhere. I’m also married so this is a joint account. Last time I checked Simple doesn’t provide joint accounts. That might have changed.
- windexh8er 7y agoWhile I will agree that Schwab is decent I, personally, would rate them about equal with Fidelity. That being said Schwab didn't want to be in this spot, they were forced. Robinhood, Webull, etc have pushed all of them to this end game. And now ETrade and the rest are stuck with slumped stocks and have no choice but to follow suit.
- mountainofdeath 7y agoRobinhood et. al. can't hold a candle to the breadth and depth of what the others offer. I will concede the simple interface is very easy for complete amateurs to get started.
- windexh8er 7y agoAgreed. I didn't say they were comparative products. But if you're trading and all you want is the execution Robinhood is worth the price.
- StevePerkins 7y agoSimilar story with Fidelity. Honestly, I just don't understand why people bother with traditional banks at this point. Pretty much all of the major brokers offer cash management accounts that are equivalent of online banking. Pretty much all with standard: - No fees - No minimum balance - Free checkwriting (usually free physical checks for that matter!) - ATM fee reimbursement (at least anywhere in the U.S., if not internationally too) - Free debit cards - Direct deposit - Deposit paper checks by taking a picture with a phone app, etc etc etc. The only possible downside that I can think of is that I'd have to deal with a little extra hassle if I wanted a cashier's check. But even then, it would simply take an extra day or two. And it's not like I'm closing on a new home purchase all that frequently. Nevertheless, people that I talk to get weird and SCARED when I talk about it. Even my wife keeps a separate checking account at a physical bank, because she just likes knowing that a brick-and-mortar building is there. I don't get it myself, but human nature can be odd when it comes to money.
- loeg 7y agoTypically, brokerages don't give you any interest on checking. Now, banks haven't really either since 2008, but prior to that you could make a few dollars a year on checking interest. https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/6/26/how-brokerages-make-money/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/6/26/how-brokerages-make-mone... is fascinating if you enjoy this kind of stuff.
- StevePerkins 7y agoNot sure where you're getting that from. My Fidelity cash management account sweeps any idle balance into a money-market fund. I don't have any first-hand experience with Charles Schwab, but their website indicates that their checking accounts likewise accrue interest with no minimum balance. Of course, interest rates are currently so low that it's basically a moot point. And I hardly ever have let any idle cash sit around without sweeping it into a short-term bond fund, or something better than the money market default.
- trimbo 7y ago
- loeg 7y agoYou've described any bank worth being a customer of. Monthly fees are a huge red flag (even if you can avoid them with hoop-jumping). USAA (just for ex.) also reimburses ATM fees. I'm not a fan of "overdraft protection" in general, but maybe Schwab provides a relatively non-predatory version of it. Citi's nickname is "shitty." I forget what put me off about Simple but in general debit cards don't enjoy the strong consumer protections that credit cards do in the US.
- cortesoft 7y agoWhile you are technically correct, I don't think you should be so dismissive... a majority of Americans are using banks that DONT offer those things, so pointing them out is a good thing for people to hear, and to demand of the bank they use.
- loeg 7y agoI didn't intend to come across as dismissive; apologies. I understand how it reads that way. I intended to make a more general statement about relatively good banking products, while GP's note only talks about Schwab in particular. I.e., yes, Schwab is a good option, and there are lots of other good options. (Lots of bad ones too.) I totally agree that a lot of people don't know these things or have good personal finance knowledge in general, and agree that raising awareness of what constitutes a reasonable banking product is a good thing.
- ac29 7y agoAgreed, my credit union does all those things and pays 10x more interest than Schwab (2% vs 0.20%). That being said, its easy enough to get ~2% in a money market as well, so there's no compelling reason to keep more than a few months expenses in a checking account. If you're with one of America's 4 largest banks (Chase, Bank of America, Citigroup, Wells Fargo), expect a bad time.
- aditya 7y agoWhat credit union is this? Didn’t realize there were any that reimburse worldwide ATM fees...
- cortesoft 7y agoSame experience for me, with some additional positive experiences when we bought our house. Had to go into a branch to wire money for escrow. Was pretty empty, and the person there was super helpful, walking me through everything and making sure I triple checked I was wiring the money to the correct place. Great experience so far!
- rcpt 7y agoOne thing I love about Simple that I've never been able to do with Schwab is get notifications on every transaction in my checking account. With Simple that helped me catch some fraud immediately
- whalesalad 7y agoMy strong opinion is that you should not be using your debit card for anything at all whatsoever except for cash withdrawls from the ATM. I use credit for 100% of all transactions so that there is an abstraction between my money and where I use it.
- arcticbull 7y agoThis is the right answer. Credit cards offer much more protection than debit do. Much safer to use, and in the event of fraud you are out the money on debit until resolution but on credit you’re not.
- Karunamon 7y agoThat’s good advice if you have the credit to get a balance large enough to cover a month’s worth of spending, but not everyone does. Also it really depends on your bank. I had my debit card details stolen on Simple, had my money back the next day and a new card overnighted.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIf you don’t have the credit you can just keep paying the balance as quickly as you need to from your cash accounts (once a week or once every few days). If you have the cash to pay for things, then you have the cash to pay for the credit used to pay for things.
- whalesalad 7y agoTotally. To put it in programmer terms a credit card is really just a queue that has a penalty for keeping items in the queue too long. You can pay it off as often as you want. The size of the queue in that case isn’t as important. But once you have a larger queue, you have more time/convenience to pay it down.
- balls187 7y agoSounds like pretty much every credit union out there.
- vinay427 7y agoThat's simply not true. Find a credit union, for starters, that has unlimited no-fee and fee-reimbursed withdrawals from any ATM worldwide. This is better than any bank I've found in other countries I've been to or lived in. Then find one that also has no-fee overdrafting on margin, etc.
- breakerbox 7y agoI can confirm Schwab banking is the real deal! No fees ever. Reimburse ALL atm fees (even those pesky international scammy ones that are like $10 a pop). Effectively wherever you are in the world, you are in network with Schwab ATM's. Used them as an exchange student all over the place. The biggest plus IMO is if you travel a lot. You get, from what I have experienced, no currency conversion fees, and no mark up on the exchange rate. They basically give you the Visa official exchange rate which is very good!
- dillondoyle 7y agoCan confirm, highly recommend! I spend a few months abroad a year and get hundreds in ATM rebates and even more in forex/transaction fee value. Though I wish I got more interest on cash balances. EDIT: the biggest benefit though is the customer service. A US based person answers with no wait time and they deal with VISA for me. So much better and I'm not even high net worth by their standards! However I also have a 'play' Robinhood account and if Schwab can roll out a better mobile app I would 100% move those equities over.
- gubby 7y agoThe Schwab mobile app has recently been updated (unsure exactly how recently), and it has got substantially better since I first tried it a couple years ago.
- avainlakech 7y agoI agree. Have been using them for years. Excellent customer service too.
- MiscIdeaMaker99 7y agoI've been using Charles Schwab Bank now for about 10 years, and I love it, as well. They had the reimbursement of ATM fees back then and still do, which is amazing.