4 ms·
It will interesting to see what happens to Manhattan. In the last decade or so, many local restaurants and shops have closed, only to be replaced by a seemingly
by keiferski 7y ago
It will interesting to see what happens to Manhattan. In the last decade or so, many local restaurants and shops have closed, only to be replaced by a seemingly endless stream of bank branches. Ideally, the loss of bank tenants with deep pockets will force landlords to lower prices enough to bring back some more traditional establishments.
- chrisseaton 7y agoBanks have been opening more physical locations? In the last decade, in Manhattan? What on Earth for?
- matwood 7y agoEven in my medium sized city I see banks opening all the time. I can only assume they are for older people who have not moved to online banking. I think there is also this outdated thought that banks project stability with a lot of branches.
- ghaff 7y agoIt's really not that older people can't figure out how to use an ATM. It's that people especially those with more money--many of whom are indeed older--sometimes need other services like notaries or non-standard things that you want to discuss with a person. These are often easier to handle when you can walk into a branch in person. I just had something semi-complicated I needed to do with my brokerage a few months ago and it was very nice to walk into an office and get it taken care of in 10 minutes. (That said, a lot of the real estate is rather unnecessary. I do have other financial folks who I deal with regularly who I have never met in person.)
- tcbawo 7y agoI think banks make a lot of money off private wealth management. It's probably worth their while from a visibility and convenience perspective to have many locations available to gain/poach clients.
- ghaff 7y agoThe overall trend is slightly down for bank branches [1] but only slightly. I expect that a lot of banks (and this probably applies to things like cellular phones as well) find that having retail visibility that seems, from a strictly utilitarian aspect, almost comically oversized compared to the actual need to still be a win. I get it to some degree. I very rarely need a physical bank/brokerage branch but it's handy now and then so my choice of vendor for a largely commodity service is at least somewhat biased by retail availability. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DDAI02USA643NWDB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DDAI02USA643NWDB
- coredog64 7y agoMany of the locations are a block of ATMs secured behind a door. Your ATM card is required for entry, and occasionally there’s a security guard who looks like he could be a bouncer at a club. Or, at least, that’s the majority of the Chase locations near me. TD Bank appears to actually have people working in customer facing roles.
- bluGill 7y agoMy credit union is an bunch of ATMs for most things. However those "bouncers" are notary publics (as I discovered when I needed that service a few months ago), can answer deep questions about various things, and help with loan applications. Need to get cash - the ATM is better at counting than the humans ever were.
- saiya-jin 7y agoCould be catering to powerful and wealthy (private banking) or mixing with investment banking advisory activities (not native to NY so just guessing). Not all banking is equal, when enough money is in stake personal touch is still seen as an advantage from both sides
- H8crilA 7y agoFeels like a natural part of the late stage of the credit cycle (FOMO). Read this somewhere: in 1999 risk meant bumping into someone and finding out he/she makes more money daytrading stocks. In 2002 it meant owning stocks.
- goatinaboat 7y agoIn the last decade, in Manhattan? What on Earth for? Partly to upsell more complex products like investments and mortgages, but mainly because surveys have shown that wealthier demographics will only use online banking if there is a branch nearby “in case”. The cost of a branch is dwarfed by the additional revenue from those customers. Source: used to work for a bank that did this, and those were the reasons.
- imglorp 7y agoUntil those people--the ones who won't manage their investments on a web page--start to die off. Then maybe all those branches will start to die back for fewer rare services that truly need in person presence.
- RHSeeger 7y agoI'm one of those people that require an "in case" bank nearby. I've had to visit the bank in person multiple times in the past year because they kept screwing up paperwork. In my experience, trying to deal with those situations on the phone has a high likelihood of both taking a long time and not actually resolving it. Plus I have a safety deposit box at my bank for important documents.
- exhilaration 7y agoPlus I have a safety deposit box at my bank for important documents. Did you see this article and discussion about safe deposit boxes? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545276 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545276
- RHSeeger 7y agoI hadn't seen it. I'll go read it. Thanks
- BlameKaneda 7y agoThere's a joke in my Tri-State area hometown that whenever a restaurant or store closes it's replaced by a bank. Glancing at my town via Google Maps I can see 14 banks (not including ATMs).
- thrower123 7y agoBank branches have been popping up like mushrooms, it is a considerable fraction of all the commercial construction around me. I don't know who these bank branches serve, as they are not ever open during hours that anyone with a job could get in to them.