10 ms·
Robots to Cut 200k U.S. Bank Jobs in Next Decade, Study Says
- Bogan 7y agoAnd as usual the political elite just will say "Fuck you poor people, the jobs aren't coming back you should learn to code" while they get richer
- Quarrelsome 7y agoso this remains the threat of several decades ago (i.e. chatbots are not new) of losing customer services jobs to human pastiches? Is this something new or just a continuation of self-service checkouts and automated payment options? I still feel like there are many human-contact roles where an AI isn't going to cut it.
- dajohnson89 7y agoyou're already seeing a pushback against "telemedicine", with services promising a real human doctor/pharmacist to help you.
- thrower123 7y agoChatbots are almost universally subpar; there's been a lot of work at trying to marry them up with natural language processing and other whizz-bang AI techniques, but still, you get down to the nitty gritty that it's a lot of work to design and implement something that's more than just a glorified IVR tree. Very few organizations will have the time and resources to make a decent experience.
- romdev 7y agoI frankly prefer a chat(bot or not) because I have a transcript of what has been discussed. Also, it's kinda fun to guess if it's a bot without offending. This is a real excerpt at the end of a helpful chat with Comcast: guest_ > You seem really nice. I've read about computer programs that can simulate nice people. Are you really a person? Cecilia > yes, i am guest_ > Who won the superbowl? Cecilia > i'm not familiar with it , im sorry
- drcode 7y agoOr, maybe there are just lots of inefficiencies in the banking sector, and more efficient/affordable banking is good for almost everybody, especially for the demographics of people who are currently underbanked.
- redwood 7y agoMaybe it can be both that and another road to the middle class closing off for young people aiming to get a job in the services sector.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jamisteven 7y agoYea, I am working in this sector at the moment (banking and automation) and I can tell you compared to say, a tech company, they are very very far behind. Although some banks like Goldman and JPMogran, are lightyears ahead of the competition in this space. This is the consequence of having non-technologist in tech management roles for the past 50 years, and typically no technologists on the exec. boards either.
- wickedsickeune 7y agoYou honestly believe that lower banking costs will transfer to clients?
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoIf the costs of servicing the unbanked can be reduced to be less than the expected revenue, why wouldn't someone serve that market? Maybe Chase Bank doesn't want them but if they can be made profitable, some bank will want that money.
- SonOfKyuss 7y agoYes. We’re all used to free checking now, but it wasn’t always that way. No fee credit cards with cash back are also a result of competition and lower costs.
- anteatersa 7y agoThere were probably articles very similar to this written when ATM's first bengan rolling out in the 60/70s.
- RivieraKid 7y agoAnd maybe they were correct.
- prepend 7y agoAnd they were right. ATMs displaced tons of jobs. Banks used humans for other jobs and that’s why banking industry employment kept going up even with all these robots doing, better, the job previously done by humans.
- tyingq 7y agoAnd not minimum wage jobs. Tellers aren't at the high end of the pay scale, but not at the bottom either. I imagine it's hitting the jobs a step or two above the tellers as well.
- tyri_kai_psomi 7y ago> all these robots doing, better, the job previously done by humans. I don't know if you use ATM's a ton, but when it's the only option you have for interacting with your bank, it's pretty terrible, because your options for if something goes wrong is to call a number and get redirected to some general call center in probably some other country and wait while some minimally paid chap who couldn't care less about your problems follows a script and then when they can't figure it out, tell you they will file a ticket and get back to you in 3-7 business days. I agree software and robots can do the job better with the caveat that you are using the well trodden majority use case. The moment something goes wrong (software bug, does the wrong thing, etc), or you are trying to do something slightly different, good luck.
- tialaramex 7y agoGet a better bank. This comes up too often on HN. Prioritise customer service. Don't pick the bank that offers slightly better rates but gives you the run around on every little thing, especially for day-to-day services. My bank (First Direct) picks up only barely after the ringing tone starts, and the person you're talking to is an expert. They have no branches, so everything must be solved on a phone call (or you can use their web site of course). Nobody needs or wants branches, especially branches that are only open when you've got better things to do.
- keiferski 7y agoIt will interesting to see what happens to Manhattan. In the last decade or so, many local restaurants and shops have closed, only to be replaced by a seemingly endless stream of bank branches. Ideally, the loss of bank tenants with deep pockets will force landlords to lower prices enough to bring back some more traditional establishments.
- chrisseaton 7y agoBanks have been opening more physical locations? In the last decade, in Manhattan? What on Earth for?
- matwood 7y agoEven in my medium sized city I see banks opening all the time. I can only assume they are for older people who have not moved to online banking. I think there is also this outdated thought that banks project stability with a lot of branches.
- ghaff 7y agoIt's really not that older people can't figure out how to use an ATM. It's that people especially those with more money--many of whom are indeed older--sometimes need other services like notaries or non-standard things that you want to discuss with a person. These are often easier to handle when you can walk into a branch in person. I just had something semi-complicated I needed to do with my brokerage a few months ago and it was very nice to walk into an office and get it taken care of in 10 minutes. (That said, a lot of the real estate is rather unnecessary. I do have other financial folks who I deal with regularly who I have never met in person.)
- tcbawo 7y agoI think banks make a lot of money off private wealth management. It's probably worth their while from a visibility and convenience perspective to have many locations available to gain/poach clients.
- gadders 7y agoI wish they'd stop calling computer programs "robots". If it doesn't go "clang" when I hit it with a spanner it's not a robot.
- Traubenfuchs 7y agoI am surprised they don't just call it AI.
- edejong 7y agoAlso, the 'clang' robots that come to mind have a certain amount of self-reliance. The 'non-clang' robots (which are basically macro's running in VMs), stop working as soon as an unexpected popup appears, the software is upgraded or the products on one page are suddenly on two. No, the 'non-clang' robots are an indication of the software engineers' gross failure to properly integrate and standardize data exchange between solutions.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe article is referring to contact center (support) automation with this kind of thing, which is a pretty far cry from Selenium scripts. https://cloud.google.com/solutions/contact-center/ https://cloud.google.com/solutions/contact-center/
- edejong 7y agoI didn't read the article but skimmed. Guilty as charged <blush-emoji> Thought it was about RPA (Robotic Process Automation).
- marvin 7y agoSpeaking from knowledge of the rhetoric in the Norwegian banking sector of the last few years (which is very automated), "robots" in the banking sector has referred to three things: Chatbots that don't work, macros that click around in a user interface to perform repetitive backoffice or customer support tasks, or plain old software that automates business processes in a scalable manner. Not surprisingly, only the last of these stand the test of time, and most organizations that jump on the bandwagon will realize that they need to hire more software engineers and automate their business processes at the root. For some, this is a long and painful realization. I spent six months trying to convince the appointed leader of a "robotization" initiative that what they were doing is actually software engineering, and that involving developers at an early point would be a better use of their money. They eventually made the mistake themselves, and got their own developers 18 months later. Maybe 20 years from now, we will have technologists on the board and in executive positions at these companies, and these decisions can be made in an adult manner.
- blatchcorn 7y agoTime to go back to subsistence farming. Heck I should create a start up for subsistence farming as a service
- Traubenfuchs 7y agoBefore you thought it up, 5 people already did it: https://yourstory.com/2019/03/faas-agritech-startup-farmers-profitable-6zmc83lyci https://yourstory.com/2019/03/faas-agritech-startup-farmers-...
- dawg- 7y agoI don't understand, it seems like these are just rental services for expensive farming equipment? Are we just calling rentals [Blank] as a Service now? Maybe Enterprise should change their business model to Cars as a Service.
- luc4sdreyer 7y agoSouth Africa recently avoided a country-wide banking sector labour strike [1]. The reason for the strike would have been to protest against retrenchments in the industry [2]. I suspect that we'll see an increase in white-collar workers striking in the future. [1] https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-09-26-protests-wont-solve-issues-banks-say-as-they-welcome-order-banning-strike/ https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-09-26-pro... [2] https://ewn.co.za/2019/09/25/busa-banking-sector-mass-action-a-protest-and-not-a-strike https://ewn.co.za/2019/09/25/busa-banking-sector-mass-action...
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoFinancial instruments (including money) is fundamentally just data. There is no reason to keep maintaining a large labor force in the sector. The first wave of labor downsizing in banking came from the closure of retail branches. The second wave of downsizing, I suspect will come projects like Libra or CBDCs [1] where issuers bypass banks (now reduced to a redundant middleman) and reach users themselves. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-10/why-china-s-rushing-to-mint-its-own-digital-currency-quicktake https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-10/why-china...
- Merrill 7y agoIt's an ongoing process. 10s of thousands of jobs were taken out the last two decades by changes to check processing. Check imaging and clearing by image transmission or conversion to ACH, along with more payments being made by credit cards, resulted in shutting down rather large back end operations that were coding, sorting, repairing, transporting, returning, re-presenting, and including paper checks in customer's statements. A check that processed without any irregularities didn't cost much. However, any errors or unusual processing that a check required cost a lot. What is needed to really reduce costs is a payment system that eliminates error and irregularities, or which uses AI to handle them.
- larzang 7y ago> What is needed to really reduce costs is a payment system that eliminates error and irregularities, or which uses AI to handle them. Perhaps some kind of... clearing house, which could be automated? In the US we have a dozen startups for you to send money to your friends. In most of the world you just do a bank transfer. I pay my rent and utilities with ACH, but I know people who still don't have that option and are stuck in the dark ages of checks or credit cards with processing fees. I have accounts with multiple credit unions, and one doesn't permit online ACH transfers and another takes 3+ days to do it. I'm currently trying to consolidate those accounts but even that's a huge hassle. It's nearly 2020 and the form the payroll company my employer uses wants a voided check from me to change where my direct deposits go! I don't have checks and haven't written a personal check in probably 15 years. We keep scratching our heads looking for that magic future tech solution to our problems (AI! AI for everything!) when we actually just need to fix adoption of the freaking 45 year old standardized solutions right in front of us. Checks have always been an almost entirely American aberration and a bad solution on all sides. It took us almost 15 years after Europe to adopt chip cards, and we're still swiping in places and almost nobody requires a pin for security. NFC adoption isn't great either outside affluent areas. We're not lacking new financial solutions, we're lacking proper adoption of the solutions we already have and the rest of the world is happy to use.
- Merrill 7y agoUS payments is a very complex system - there are around 4900 banks and a similarly large number of non-bank players. Managing change is really hard. Not everyone wants a change. One person's costs are another person's revenues. There are also a lot of managers managing organizations that process fraud, errors, and other irregularities. Costs don't matter if you can charge enough in fees and interest. In the case of chip cards, the US wasn't about to pay for the French smartcard patents. In general, financial technology is a patent thicket and its best to wait 20 years before implementing new ideas unless you have really positive financial case and can be sure you have the IP locked down.
- SteveSmith16384 7y agoAnd I bet most of us will still be working a 5 day week, despite all the savings from automation.
- sak5sk 7y agoThis doesn't have to be the case. It is up to new business owners to decide how much their employees should work, what they should make and how often they should take vacations. Anyone can set an example at any time. As far as I know there is nothing to stop anyone from setting their own standards for fewer working days, shorter days, better pay, more vacations.
- adamsea 7y agoIt’s also up to the law
- sak5sk 7y agoIs there a law that says I can't pay you a full time's salary for 20 hours a week instead of 40?
- bluGill 7y agoThe law of competition. Assuming that your employees are less productive overall on a 20 hour week, the competition paying get a 40 hour week gets more done for their money and thus are cheaper for their customers. There are a lot of assumptions in there. Getting everybody to work 168 hour weeks (24x7) seems like it should be even better, but it turns out that as you get close to that workload your employees are less productive. Fatigue will ensure your useful productivity is less than someone working somewhat lesser hours who is allowed to sleep. (I'm going to assume you require your people eat at their desk, otherwise starvation will kill them) You also lose because if there is even a rumor that other companies allow their people who have a life they will quit, and replacing people cost productivity. We can take the opposite extreme: you work 1 hour per week. At this point your productivity is very low because you can never get "in the zone", and in fact your entire hour at work is spend just trying to remember what you do. Someplace in the middle is the sweet spot. 20 hour weeks may be worth it - perhaps you can pay your people half as much and still give them as much income as they want, and still get the productivity you need to compete. Perhaps you can justify paying as much for 20 hours as your competitors pay for 40 hours because you employees enjoy that extra time and so they don't quit - you get better productivity because you don't have to teach them new things. Each company needs to figure it out. in general society has settled on 40 hour weeks as a good number. There is no legal law making it best, but considering the compromises it isn't a bad number.
- pnongrata 7y agoI think a more accurate headline would be "Banks to cut 200k jobs over Robots". Robots don't take jobs. Managers replace workers.
- mac01021 7y agoThat's already how everyone is reading the existing headline, though. It's not like anyone is being misled (I don't think)
- Frost1x 7y agoThose robots can be quite the opportunists with their consciousness and all.
- jermaustin1 7y agoI'm tired of all these robots coming to this country and taking our jobs!
- pnongrata 7y agoIt's important to say it as it is. People tend to treat it as a 'natural' thing, instead of a business decision to cut costs.
- dragonsky 7y agoAnd in the remainder of the world this has already happened. In Australia you are lucky to find a bank with real people working in it, they have mostly been replaced by Automatic Teller Machines (ATM's) and if you do, they will normally be working at selling you insurance or investments.
- visarga 7y agoI assumed it would be about RPA - robotic process automation. It reduces time spent in repetitive desktop activities.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dawg- 7y agoA few years ago my bank had a mini-branch in my local chain grocery store. They had a counter and some tellers working behind it. I went to it really often because I was being paid in cash at the time waiting tables. The employees were super nice, they all seemed like they were friends, and I kind of became buddies with them over my time of being a regular customer. Not all bank tellers are pleasant customer service people, but this group just had a good vibe I guess. One day I try go to the bank and the counter was ripped out and drywalled over, and in its place is a giant ATM machine. It's like an ATM machine on steroids that can do anything with your account. And if you had issues there was a screen on it that would connect you to a call center in Bangladesh or wherever. Some corporate bank employee was posted next to the machine to explain the change to people who had questions. When I walked up a group of people were standing around listening to him talk, they looked ready to pull out the pitchforks. He assured us that all of the tellers were still employed, they were just working "behind the scenes". I didn't buy that at all, and neither did anyone else. I continued to use the machine to deposit my cash, but it really sucked. I mean the machine worked absolutely fine. But it sucked to imagine how those tellers felt to be replaced by it. Now that I don't get paid in cash, I don't even go to a physical bank at all. I deposit checks on my phone in the rare occasion I need to do that. I'm still not sure how to feel about this. I want to hate it but it feels a little irrational. Maybe all of those tellers went to a coding bootcamp and now make triple their salary designing the ATM machines? Seems like that's how the story is supposed to go. But probably not. Nothing I can do about it anyway.
- softwaredoug 7y agoHonestly if simple banking is handled by automation, isn’t there room for differentiation for more “human” banking that empowers people to understand and use more complex financial instruments?
- dawg- 7y agoI don't know. Maybe. I am just talking about the experience of seeing a person's face every day, looking them in the eye, making small talk, interacting with other customers in the bank. That kind of every day stuff has value. I think we can mourn our losses while also looking forward to the new opportunities created. It doesn't have to be all good or all bad. Anyway, I'm not sure I completely understand your comment. Are human bank tellers impeding people from using "more complex financial instruments"?
- antisthenes 7y agoI'm surprised this hasn't happened sooner. Banking as a profession relies on a fairly strict set of rules , most of which can be automated. Thus, the leftover role of the banker is to navigate the regulatory requirements within the the scope of the automated task. As well as the programmers to automate it.
- ParkerContent 7y agoWrote this as part of a recent article, "The World Economic Forum predicts that by 2022, 75 million roles may be eliminated due to technological changes, including automation. However, other advances may result in the development of 133 million new roles requiring new skills." Source: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/04/skills-jobs-investing-in-people-inclusive-growth/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/04/skills-jobs-investing...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoIt would if it could, no doubt about it. Who knows what kind of technological advancements we will see. I will tell you what I see today. Salesmen selling 'culturally aware fuzzy logic' that promises to automate just about anything and let leadership just read beautiful dashboards. Depressing stuff. And it sells too. And 200k over a decade? Wake me up when AI replaces CEOs.