3 ms·
Given what people pay RH for, this makes sense. Given why people like me no longer choose to run RH, this makes perfect sense, as a reason why we don't run RH:
by ggm 7y ago
Given what people pay RH for, this makes sense. Given why people like me no longer choose to run RH, this makes perfect sense, as a reason why we don't run RH: The money we pay RH to maintain support for old code can be better invested in converting old code to run on new platforms.
There is a class of client who needs what RH is selling and I am glad they sell it, and that people like my bank can invest in that, because longterm stability of fintech cores for a banking product is very important: People ran applications developed for LEO, in emulation under GEORGE and then subsequently re-emulated on later operating systems because ICL committed to that to meet customer needs. People emulated PDP-11 RSTS inside Vax/VMS for the same reason. People emulate OS360 inside RS6000 based machines..
TL;DR RH supporting Python2 makes perfect sense. If you don't use RH, then this doesn't have to matter to you.
- colechristensen 7y agoOpposite position: The money you pay supporting security and new/broken features of fast moving upstream targets could be mostly saved with a small portion paid to RH freeing you up to improve your product instead of supporting ever-changing/insecure upstreams. I have experienced far too many emergencies and worried about relying on far too much insecure old code in environments without RH support. With RH I could always trust that packages wouldn't disappear overnight, if I built something against RH it would actually still be there in 6m or 6y and that I could really trust that if a security hole was discovered I would be notified and it would be fixed in a way that wouldn't break my stack. All of that is super valuable compared to moving fast and breaking things myself while dealing with upstreams that move fast and break things too. In many many circumstances, it is really expensive to stay on the bleeding edge of everything and does not add business value, other than pleasing and attracting magpie programmers.
- takeda 7y agoI worked for a company which paid for RH licenses (they don't do it anymore). Being conservative is nice, if it comes with stability, but during RHEL6, 6.4 was the first version that was actually stable. As for breaking your stack, this actually is not that hard. All you have to do is not tie your application to the system. Since we're talking about Python, if you use RedHat or CentOS, I highly recommend IUS repo[1] in there you can pick which version of Python you want to use (older if you want to ensure stability, newer if you need cutting edge), you also can install multiple versions side by side, and your application is no longer tied to the OS, that means switching underlying OS or upgrading to next major version (for example to RHEL8) is no longer that should affect your application. [1] https://ius.io https://ius.io
- colechristensen 7y ago>As for breaking your stack, this actually is not that hard. All you have to do is not tie your application to the system. My point is the opposite, I want to tie my application to a reliable system so I don't have to deal with something else (pip, gem, npm, mvn, etc.) because those things break, I can't rely on them being available, I can't rely on packages always being there, I can't rely on the security of what is out there. I can rely on the system python and associated packages, I can trust that security issues will be patched, and I can trust that compatibility will be maintained. Doing that I would be stuck with an aged and aging upstream perhaps blocking adoption of new technologies, but it buys me stability and peace of mind. There are tradeoffs, for sure.
- rjsw 7y agoI don't think people emulate OS360 on RS6000 machines, I'm sure they are emulating OS360 on the latest IBM System z mainframes.
- ggm 7y agoyea, you're probably right, I let the rhetoric run a bit rich there.