11 ms·
Belgian startup Magnax has found a way to mass-produce the axial-flux motor
- FlynnLivesMattr 7y ago> "One of our designs has a peak power density of around 15 kilowatts per kilogram. Compare that with today’s motors, such as the one in the all-electric BMW i3, which delivers a peak power density of 3 kW/kg—or just one-fifth as much. And the Magnax machine is also more efficient." It will be interesting to see how Moore's law will materialize in EVs. Understanding that the majority of time and effort spent in the automobile industry has been aimed towards combustion engine design as opposed to electric motors, it will be equally interesting to follow the efficiencies to be discovered in the imminent future, taking into consideration how blazing quick they already are today.
- Gibbon1 7y ago15kw is about 9hp/lb. If you can get that maybe you can design a wheel motor that doesn't suck. Two 75 hp motors would weigh about 8 lbs each. No gear box, differential or CV joints. Potentially really cheep.
- zamalek 7y agoThe most I understand about motors is how they typically work and that innovations are possibly more lucrative than battery innovations; this seems like a major innovation. I must be missing something? What's the healthy skepticism here?
- emmelaich 7y agoI don't see anything to be skeptical about; they seem to have done a lot of work and research. One curiosity for me is whether putting the motor in the wheel will work well. It's important to keep sprung weight as low as possible for suspension reasons. Then again, many (most?) electrical vehicles will be run on smooth roads.
- namibj 7y agoThese motors are light. If you integrate them with the wheel to the point where you mount the tire to it instead of to the rim, you should be close to current mass, possibly breaking even (depending on how much of the axle/differential is unsprung mass, and how heavy the flexible torque transmission ends up being).
- checker 7y agoI already have potholes destroying my rims, I'm not looking forward to the day a pothole wrecks one of my engines!
- rossdavidh 7y ago1) you're right, for every "revolutionary" technology innovation we hear about that actually turns out being important, there are several that don't, but... 2) automobiles were not, until recently, an area that received a lot of effort at major innovation. Credit electric (and hybrid electric) cars with redefining the amount of change that seemed practical to consider.
- namibj 7y agoEmrax sells this technology for years now. This isn't new, and I couldn't find a datasheet to meaningfully compare them with what else is available on the market. I do know of axial flux motors that couldn't have had iron teeth, but I think it was a single-side design with a metal backplate to support the resin-soaked stator windings. I recall a nice discussion about them using GaN power electronics to reach very high efficiencies. Those machines were still hand made last year, however...
- Robotbeat 7y agoYou can, of course, make an ironless axial flux motor with the resin and wire itself acting as a structural composite. Two-sided. I think commonly were used for solar cars (i.e. for student competitions).
- namibj 7y agoThe prototype I touched was for/part of a 200kW pair (I don't recall if each or total) for a demonstrator plane...
- kemiller 7y agoEven if it does what it says, it’s a minor improvement over existing motors once you factor in the rest of the car. The mass of the motor matters but much less than the mass of the batteries.
- Robotbeat 7y agoRadial flux motors also work great. Whether one or the other is better depends on your application. 1) I don't consider this a breakthrough. 2) Magnax's motors are a really sensible design (like Emrax's) and I think they'll do very well. Radial flux motors can achieve just as high of specific power and are already pretty cheap and available. I think it has taken a while for BLDC motors to become cheaply available at high specific powers except for R/C applications, and there wasn't really any fundamental reason why, but it's better late than never. (I make high performance electric motors, including both radial and axial flux ones)
- oblio 7y agoAs far as I know electric motors have very high theoretical and also practical efficiencies. Something like 95%+ theoretically, not sure about the practical value, but it's most likely higher than diesel (~40%) or gasoline (less than 40%, probably a bit higher than 35%?). The batteries are the big pain point. A battery that's 50% lighter, has 50% more capacity and costs the same would trigger a technological revolution.
- longjowl 7y agoLooks lovely for drones.
- namibj 7y agoYou get by without the fancy iron teeth mechanical support they invented as long as you remain small enough. The main issue is miniaturizing magnet manufacture without per-magnet costs staying fixed. I judge by COTS pricing, but the $/kW falling on magnets increases a lot below 5~15kW electrical.
- Robotbeat 7y agoYeah, if you have really tiny rare earth magnets, their cost-per-weight (for a given magnetic energy product) goes up a lot. Just finicky to deal with sintering a bunch of small things, I suppose.
- hristov 7y agoThis is very interesting. And it is very good news that companies are finding higher efficiencies in mass produce-able electric motors. It means that electric cars will become more affordable and practical quicker. But I do hope they do not proceed with the in wheel concept. In wheel motors make the ride not only bumpier but more dangerous. This is because the wheel with more un-sprung weight bounces more and tends to lose contact with the road more, which in turn makes the car more likely to spin out of control, miss a turn, etc. Electric cars, being still relatively new, cannot afford to get a reputation for danger.
- hinkley 7y agoMight work out if it’s paired with active suspension. The idea with motors at the wheel seems to be that the moving parts are all concentrated there. No mechanical distribution. Compartmentalization. But that is not incompatible with active suspension systems.
- adrianmonk 7y agoWhat would be the advantage of doing it that way instead of just putting the motor on the car frame and connecting it to the wheel with a CV axle? From what I could dig up, mechanical losses in a CV axle are on the order of 1%. An active suspension requires power, too. And a heavier wheel would presumably require a more power-hungry active suspension than a lighter wheel, so you're not getting something for nothing in terms of efficiency. I guess it is a matter of numbers, though. A CV axle also gives a wheel inertia, as it has mass and moves when the wheel does (partially). If you can make an insanely light motor, maybe you could make it so light that it's actually contributes less inertia than a CV axle would, in which case go ahead.
- davidgould 7y agoThe small diameter of the CV axle makes the inertia small compared to the rest of the wheel, tire, brake assembly.
- b0rsuk 7y ago
- DJBunnies 7y agoSmells fishy.
- tararaboomdier 7y agoWhat happens when it reaches 88mph?
- mkoryak 7y agoHere is a video of one in operation with some techno music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGu7XDapR58 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGu7XDapR58
- alanbernstein 7y agoThat's cool, but I was hoping to find a video detailing the difference in design between axial and radial motors. You know, with exploded 3d models and such. And also with techno music.
- wideasleep1 7y agohttps://youtu.be/BTuCshX5bc0?t=36 https://youtu.be/BTuCshX5bc0?t=36
- mkoryak 7y agoThat techno music makes me feel very empowered.
- alanbernstein 7y agoThanks for an actual answer to my flippant comment. Actually, I was hoping to see an explanation of why the different design leads to smaller, more efficient motors. I understand that the flux direction is different, but I don't understand how that enables the improvements.
- siliconviking 7y agoWho is John Galt?
- mr_woozy 7y agoAnyone else just impressed by the writing of the article itself? They made a very good effort of providing benefits over traditional radial flux electric motors and how theirs was difference as well as measurable improvement numbers. I hope they succeed.
- ridaj 7y agoIt reads like an ad to me. It's hard to figure out what the catch is, if any (and in this world of tradeoffs, there usually is a catch).
- teraflop 7y agoYes, you could call it an ad, but it reads as much more down-to-earth and straightforward than what most people think of when they think of advertising. They're simply describing what they built, why it was difficult, and why they think it's important, with a minimum of marketing fluff.
- pinkfoot 7y agoHeat dissipation.
- VLM 7y agoBingo... Of course there's plenty of apps where that doesn't matter... we'll see them implemented in "bursty" automobiles a long time before we see them implemented in "continuous" railroad traction motors, for example. Its an interesting time to be alive. I'm not THAT old and when I was a kid a generic NEMA 50 HP industrial electric motor took a crane or at least a large engine hoist to lift, more than 500 pounds for sure, but now there are high end automotive motors that I can easily do bicep curls with (like 40 pounds) VFDs are kinda like that too. What used to be a large rack is now a little tiny DIN unit that handles 10x the power.
- quotemstr 7y agoOh, it's definitely an ad. But it's the good kind of ad, the one that informs you about the existence and advantages of a product that you hadn't heard about. Contrast this throwback style of ad with the modern style of ad, which emotionally engineers you into subconsciously wanting a product that you don't actually need. I would love it if more ads looked like Magnax's.
- ridaj 7y agoHow much does motor weight matter in a modern long-range EV, vs battery weight?
- elihu 7y agoAn AC motor for a car might be in the 100-200 pound range or so. DC motors tend to be a little heavier. Along with the motor, you'd need a motor controller and cabling. Example conversion motors: https://www.evwest.com/catalog/index.php?cPath=8 https://www.evwest.com/catalog/index.php?cPath=8 A general rule-of-thumb is that it takes about 100 watt-hours to move a thousand pounds of car one mile. I just started on a project to convert a Mazda RX-8 to electric. That's a 3,000 pound car (before the conversion), and I'm planning to use a Netgain Hyper9 AC motor, which is 120 pounds, which is pretty small compared to the rest of the car (or compared to the original rotary engine). Battery weight is the bigger concern; if I can keep the pack under 400 pounds I'm doing pretty good, and I'll be lucky if that gets me 100 miles of range.
- nabla9 7y agoAccording to Magnax no-load losses reduce the effective range of the vehicle by 10% to 20% (iron close to rotating permanent magnets equals braking when there is no load) Magnax claims 85% less iron losses due to the low amount of iron.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- elihu 7y ago> "Motors and motor systems account for approximately 53 percent of global electricity consumption. We estimate that improving the efficiency of all the world’s motors by just 1 percent would reduce the motors’ power consumption by 94.5 terawatt-hours and shrink their carbon dioxide footprint by the equivalent of 60 million metric tons." I find this surprising. Perhaps a big chunk of this is air conditioning, which is technically using a motor to run a compressor?
- bboreham 7y agoAnd refrigerators?
- basicplus2 7y agoslight tangent... Interesting thing to consider is that reverse cycle airconditioners are notoriously inefficient compared to dedicated cooling or heating units.. Reverse cycle units can use anything from 2 times to 5 times the power of a dedicated unit on cooling
- matthiasl 7y agoAt least 2 times and as much as 5 times seems surprisingly bad. Do you have a source or a concrete example for that? The most plausible explanation I can think of for what you're saying is that you're comparing an evaporative cooling system to a heat pump based one, in which case the 'reverse cycle' aspect is not the thing causing the inefficiency.
- 08-15 7y agoImagine a factory. All those moving things, power tools, conveyor belts, cranes, pumps, etc. are driven by electric motors.
- quotemstr 7y agoBut when will we see a motor powered by magneto-reluctance and capacitive diractance instead of the relative motions of conductors and fluxes? Seriously, though, this article is clear and well-written. I love it when I see people solve problems we didn't know we had. I'd figured we'd basically found the global optimum on electrical motors decades ago and were basically stuck there by physics now, with advances happening elsewhere in the powertrain. This development is like CPU vendors figuring out how to write 3x more single-core performance out of the same thermal budget after our own decade of stagnation in this area.
- extropy 7y agoA concise and technical summary from their blog: https://www.magnax.com/magnax-blog/axial-flux-vs-radial-flux.-4-reasons-why-does-axial-flux-machines-deliver-a-higher-power-density https://www.magnax.com/magnax-blog/axial-flux-vs-radial-flux...
- abyssin 7y ago> "If yokeless axial-flux machines replaced only a fraction of the older machines, we would save our customers some money and make the planet more livable while we’re at it." The engineering feat is impressive and exciting, but this conclusion doesn't account for the Jevons paradox. In itself, a technical progress that improves the efficiency with which a resource is used doesn't lower the demand for this resource, but instead increases it. The solution to a more livable planet is political, and this is why it's so difficult to find.
- iguy 7y agoI don't think they're trying to reduce the amount of electricity generated/used. Rather, they're trying to help electrical out-compete fossil fuels.
- drewbt 7y agoOff topic. Perhaps if every person embraces the politician within themselves.
- jessriedel 7y agoIf you make it cheaper to use a less polluting resource than a more polluting one, this can still work. Improved solar technology, for instance.
- vanderZwan 7y agoYes, but the point GP makes is that you need carrots and sticks. One or the other alone will not be enough.
- jessriedel 7y agoHe's claiming that, I guess, but he doesn't actually provide any support. It seems totally possible, depending on the technological specifics, to require zero political coordination.
- ncmncm 7y agoJevons is not universal. Power expended on illumination has been decreasing as people switch to LED lighting. Enough light is enough.
- tyfon 7y agoThere was a lot of ifs, mays and hopefullys in that article, but maybe it's just written in a strange way since it does say they have actually found a way to mass produce this thing. It would be great if true. One of the first questions that popped into my mind was how would this motor with less mass (less structure) handle 5 times the power/mass of traditional electric motors which are already pretty power full and sometimes break from strain.
- ppf 7y ago> One of our designs has a peak power density of around 15 kilowatts per kilogram. Compare that with today’s motors, such as the one in the all-electric BMW i3, which delivers a peak power density of 3 kW/kg—or just one-fifth as much. And the Magnax machine is also more efficient. >We believe that we can scale the design to whatever size carmakers (and other customers) may demand. Count the weasel words. I'm at 5.
- AdrianB1 7y agoI am very eager to find out what the price will be for these motors, this will have a huge impact in General Aviation. A banal 4 cylinder 100 HP petrol engine is ~$20,000 ("aviation price") and the weight is a bit over 60 kg, if my math is right a Magnax motor can be as light as 5 kg (even 10 kg is fabulous) but the cost needs to balance the huge price of batteries: the $20,000 petrol engine with 140 liter fuel tanks gives a flight time of almost 10 hours, batteries for that flight time would be insanely expensive and possibly quite heavy. But most people don't fly more than 5-6 hours, so a reduction to 6 hours would be acceptable for 95% of the people. Another positive impact to GA is you don't need to adjust for mass and balance that much, batteries have a fixed center of gravity that does not change while discharging, while fuel tanks impact the plane's center of gravity as they go from full to empty. Less trimming, simpler flying. And not the last, it is eliminating any problems with carburetors, mixture, air density or inverted flight: none of these affect an electrical motor, but it needs to be considered for the likes of Cessna where you need to adjust the (fuel/air) mixture depending on the altitude. And it improves propeller efficiency, simplifying constant speed propeller operation. It can be easily fully automated. All good news, but seeing it happen is a different story: it can take 3 to 5 years, more that a decade or never to reach mass availability and adoption in general aviation. It has the potential to make the market explode (in the positive way), but there is so much politics involved there are chances the status quo will be maintained. Let's see.
- anovikov 7y agoExcept right at this time, it will be a reduction to about 1 hour actually...
- AdrianB1 7y ago100 kg of fuel and 50 kg less on the engine weight allows for a lot of batteries. Not sure what is the flight time, but if someone can help with energy density we can calculate the exact number. I wildly guess it is more than 1 hours, but definitely less than 6 hours. Later edit: I did some calculations, the result is less than 30 minutes.
- 7y ago
- rpmisms 7y agoMy first thought is that Toyota needs to license this for their hybrids, and mount it on/as the flywheel. Using something like this as either MG1 or both MG1 and MG2 would seriously minify their hybrid drivetrain.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoWhy hybrids, Why not just go for full electric?
- rpmisms 7y agoBecause hybrids are the next step until EVs reach the junction of affordable and practical for the average household. Toyota knows this, and is playing it safe until there's a mass-market demand, when they'll step in with the most practical and boring EV possible.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoComplex issue. With this innovation they can rethink the whole axel/brakes/rims/hub motor system and perhaps come up with more novel solutions. E.g. Brakes/hubmotor integration to remove the unsprung weight penalty? Rim/hubmotor integration? It's an exciting time.
- mark-r 7y ago> In tests at the University of Ghent on the first prototype, our yokeless axial-flux motor reached efficiencies from 91 to 96 percent. And that was just the prototype. Wouldn't one expect a prototype to be better than a mass produced unit? It gets individual care and can be optimized for the test.
- dhagz 7y agoIt will probably undergo several revisions and optimizations before mass production. Prototyping is usually pretty early in the process.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNah. Prototypes have lots of compromises - wrong materials, crude circuits etc. Maybe bolted to a plywood table top etc. The purpose of a prototype is proof-of-concept and measurement/recording. Not a simulation of real deployment.
- avmich 7y agoAn electric plane with a motor like this, fueled with hydrogen like Toyota Mirai... seems like it can improve the situation with range?
- DrJosiah 7y agoAwesome design, makes me want to put one together just to see it work. :) One concern: I saw some designs with the rotor outside the stator, physically mounted to a wheel. I'm not a mechanical engineer, but as a guy who considers himself not quite dumb enough to fail at everything... I hope they build those motors tough. Typical electric motor mounts create a situation where the only real stresses on the motor are rotational, along the axis of rotation, or in the case of a pulley / gear-mount setup, you are usually limited to 1-2 additional push/pull axis. But on a wheel? That wheel is going to want to rotate and move on all axis, which now needs to be supported by a motor, which also includes permanent electric magnets. Awesome lighter motor, awesome that we can sandwich the rotor between stators (more layers more torque!).