3 ms·
> You can never feel like you are somewhere else - or something immaterial is with you - until a full sensory experience coalesces, even if it's "low resolution
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> You can never feel like you are somewhere else - or something immaterial is with you - until a full sensory experience coalesces, even if it's "low resolution."
I'm not sure I agree with that. Games like Beat Saber and the old demo of Budget Cuts have really made me feel like I'm inside another world, particularly when I was newer to VR.
I say "not sure" because we're not necessarily talking about the same thing—the above are "games" or at least "experiences", not "interfaces. You don't really touch anything in Beat Saber, except for the blocks where a strong rumble is sufficient. Harder to do that in a UI.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIn a fitness experience, you can imagine the resistance at least, which is what I wind up doing in beat saber to increase my heart rate and calorie burn. It is actually an interesting problem: can the mind imagine the feedback that really isn’t there, causing muscles to work harder even if they don’t have to? For some people at least, the answer is yes, though I bet it would be hard for others. But shadow boxing, katas, and so on, have shown that imagining resistance has been around for awhile. We can kind of imagine tactile feedback already in a UI, and vibration is effective in reinforcing that illusion. Perhaps the way forward is to further play around with fooling the brain (via some kind of cognitive interface) rather than somehow reproducing real feedback.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoVibration is key in current VR experience, IMO. Having spent many hours on Beat Saber over the past few weeks, I can say that the only reason my brain recognizes that I hit something with the blade is the little controller buzz that activates at the right moment. As for adapting yourself to the game, I keep having to focus on preventing myself from using my wrists too much when playing. Given that my goal is calorie burn, I do my best to use my whole arm (as if wielding a real blade). I've noticed that I do create "impact resistance" myself too.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIt took awhile to stop us g wrists, but now I imagine it as some immensely satisfying glaive work. BoxVR is another game where imagining feedback is crucial, more so actually with their fitness focus. Their inaccurate calorie counter is completely motion base, so wider faster movements will drive that up as well. Honestly, BoxVR (custom with lots of fast songs) is now more important than BeatSaber to my daily workout, because I’m able to get a lot more effective motions in. On the other hand, I can’t play it with the toddler around (if he got in my way, he could really be hurt by the gestures I’m doing).