10 ms·
The NCAA has an interesting choice to make here. Option 1, they remove the California teams from the NCAA. The Power 5 have been talking about a "division 0"
by jedberg 7y ago
The NCAA has an interesting choice to make here.
Option 1, they remove the California teams from the NCAA. The Power 5 have been talking about a "division 0" league for a long time. Chances are that would push them all to leave the NCAA and create their own organization.
Option 2, allow California to be the exception. This would be great for California, because if you're a top high school athlete, would you rather play in California where you could potentially make millions, or anywhere else? Presumably a bunch of other states would pass similar laws and demand the same exception, until the NCAA was forced to allow paid players everywhere.
Or Option 3, just change the NCAA rules to match California, and let players get paid.
If sounds like the only winning move here is for the NCAA to allow paying players. I think California just forced their hand.
- balozi 7y agoNCAA should be counting on the fact that more states will adopt California's stance on this issue.
- r00fus 7y agoYes. This decision will most definitely cause a land-grab rush, unless the NCAA overwhelmingly punishes CA, other states will just do the same thing. It's a pretty big change - my guess is CA's stance will win, because the alternative is massive disruption of the NCAA.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoYes, if auto emissions, minimum wage, contractor laws, and many other progressive policies are any example: blue states often pile on to each others' policies to spread them widely. NCAA shouldn't count on NY, IL, WA, MA, or other big blue states not doing this.
- rconti 7y agoRight, but this CA change is (probably) an unalloyed good for CA, which gives other states even larger incentive to copy it -- whereas the incentives to copy minimum wage or auto emissions or other 'progressive' policies may be non-obvious or nonexistent.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoOption 4: you're a member of a voluntary organization, and your state can't change our bylaws. Which is what's probably gonna happen.
- Judgmentality 7y agoThat's the same as Option 1.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 7y agoThe state can change the bylaws. Or at least make the bylaws unenforceable within state boundaries, which has the same effect. I believe that is what California has done here. For another example, suppose there were some chemical company organization that had a bylaw like, "You cannot print information about carcinogenic ingredients in your products." But then California passes prop 65. The bylaws are now moot -- if you have to choose whether to comply with bylaws or state law, you either have to take your ball and go home, or the bylaws have to change.
- wmurmann 7y agoWouldn't this make it illegal to prevent players from profiting from endorsements ? Voluntary organizations can't break the law.
- lacker 7y agoI think the state can change the bylaws of a voluntary organization, or at least make them illegal. From the official digest of the bill at https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201920200SB206 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm... : The bill also would prohibit an athletic association, conference, or other group or organization with authority over intercollegiate athletics from preventing a postsecondary educational institution other than a community college from participating in intercollegiate athletics as a result of the compensation of a student athlete for the use of the student’s name, image, or likeness. AFAICT this law would make the current NCAA bylaws illegal in California. Any California player who accepted an endorsement and was subsequently prevented from playing would be able to sue.
- brudgers 7y agoIn Mexico, there is a simpler option: universities affiliated with professional teams. Tigres UANL and UNAM Pumas in Liga MX are examples. Leones Negros UdeG in the Ascenso. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tigres_UANL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tigres_UANL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_Universidad_Nacional https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_Universidad_Nacional https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leones_Negros_UdeG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leones_Negros_UdeG
- rosybox 7y agoUniversity teams in the US have a storied history. The University of Alabama isn't going to shutdown Crimson Tide so that they can work with out of state NFL teams.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI'd bet the Crimson Tide is likely even worth a bit more than some low level NFL teams.
- TylerE 7y agoAccording to a recent Forbes article, the least valuable NFL team is worth over $2B.
- mburns 7y ago> The Crimson Tide's football program reported $103.9 million in revenue for 2016 and posted a $47 million profit. That's up 3.6% from last year. According to a CNN Money article.
- TylerE 7y agoThe least valuable NFL team had profits of $126M on revenue of over $400m. So I suspect the answer is a strong "no", but they're at least in the same zipcode if not the same ballpark.
- vkou 7y agoI find it mind-boggling that of all the millions of dollars that middle-men in this industry make, the players - the whole point of the industry - were the only ones not getting paid.
- maxerickson 7y agoIt's rather simple, the assumption that the industry is for the players is incorrect. The industry will loudly tell you it's about the athletes. That's bullshit.
- berbec 7y agoSorry, I need to correct your post to use correct NCAA-approved groupspeak. "The industry will loudly tell you it's about the student-athletes."
- pitt1980 7y agoThe economics surrounding most minor league sports suggest that the level of skill demonstrated by the players is not, in fact, the economic driver behind the revenues generated in college athletics. If you want to see athletic accomplishments done at a high level... Your typical D League basketball game, Arena League football game, or triple A baseball game features higher skilled athletic performance. To me, this suggests that it's the tribal/communal aspect of college athletics which drive the interest and revenues.
- abtinf 7y agoAnother option: CA universities become the least desirable place for the very best high school athletes. The objective of the very best players is not to merely pay for college, but maximize their chance to join professional teams. Those odds are maximized by access to world class facilities, equipment, trainers, coaches, medical care, and more. Winning helps too. If some schools have less money because sponsorships are going to specific players instead of the school/league, they will be able to provide fewer top-tier resources to players. Consequently, those schools will be less attractive in the areas of essential importance to the very best players. If the very best athletes gravitate toward non-player-sponsorship schools, it will create a self-reinforcing cycle to get other top athletes, because they want the best teams to maximize their chances of winning.
- Retric 7y agoThe overwhelming majority of top college players have negligible chances of playing in the NFL. The potential rewards for a high school player getting paid ASP generally dwarfs any long term career prospects.
- lloyddobbler 7y agoAsk any 18 year-old 3-star high school senior football recruit whether he's going to play in the NFL. Let me know how many of them tell you "maybe, but I'm not sure I'll get there." Then ask the 4- and 5-stars.
- Lukeas14 7y agoThe players who have a good change of playing in the NFL likely heavily overlaps the players who will be offered endorsements. 99% of college athletes simply aren't good enough for either and will probably be unaffected by this.
- crooked-v 7y agoAt the very least it means being able to do things like offer coaching or training services or even just run a lawnmowing business under their own name, which is prohibited by NCAA rules.
- wtvanhest 7y agoThe 4th option is to disallow teams who are in states that violate the bylaws from joining post season play at NCAA events (basketball), and to lobby CFP committee to do the same. I believe the NCAA will go with option 4, then once more states pass the same laws, eventually go to option 3.* D0 is not really on the table because it is dilutive to 'P5' school earnings vs today's system of pretending to include G5 while excluding them from the big payouts. *The reason they will go with option 4 is that the only conference impacted by the law will be the Pac 12. While Larry Scott (Pac 12 commissioner) is probably not happy, he can't really move the needle for the NCAA like Big10/SEC could. If this law get enacted in Florida, that would be the tipping point to go to option 3. Going with option 4 today really only leaves the Rose Bowl as the only loose end.
- orthoxerox 7y agoWhat are these numbers, D0, P5, G5?
- jedberg 7y agoD0 == Division 0. Right now all the top teams play in Division 1 athletics, with a bunch of other teams that generally don't get nearly as much money or notoriety but give the top teams some other teams to "beat up on" so to speak (although they do sometimes lose). Division 0 is this idea that the Power 5 (see below) would form their own division. Right now there are three divisions, and they are based on school size, which is why all the big schools are division 1 but there is a big difference in quality. The idea here is to take the top teams and split off regardless of school size. P5 == Power 5. These are the five conferences that have almost all the top teams. Big ten, Big 12, the ACC, the Pac-12, and the SEC. G5 == Group of 5. These are there conferences with the lesser know teams. American, Conference USA, Mid-American, Mountain West, and Sun Belt
- orthoxerox 7y agoWhere can I read about this? Are conferences what divisions are subdivided into?
- capkutay 7y agothe worst argument I've heard from skeptics associated with the NCAA is "THE COLLEGE PLAYERS ARE ALREADY PAID!". As if forcing young student athletes who are often from very low income families to resort to illegal bribes is a better solution than regulated endorsements for something they're absolutely entitled to.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThey're paid with a free education. That doesn't balance out the inequity of profits made off their labor but it isn't nothing.
- jjeaff 7y agoYes and no. Some, not all, are given full or partial scholarships. And of those that are given full scholarships, many have a very difficult time balancing their studies and their athletics. Athletes are generally limited in which majors they can choose due to study time requirements and class, practice time conflicts. I once inadvertently enrolled in a "business calculus" class that was apparently hand selected by the football coaches. Almost the entire class was the football team. We barely got through the first 5 chapters of the book and that was the easiest A I ever got. So while the free education and room and board have some value, they don't have nearly as much as people think. I have known student athletes that quit playing and got a full time job just so they could afford to pay their own way and have time for classes.
- butterfi 7y agoThe average cost of 1 year of University is approx. 35k a year for private colleges according to collegedata.com. The average salary of 1 first year NBA player is 3 million. The lowest paid NBA player makes approx 500k. That doesn't sound like a "free" education to me. Players would be better off going straight to the NBA and going to college later, if they were still inclined.
- dillonmckay 7y agoOr forgoing college and play professionally in another country.
- aj7 7y agoEvidently that’s what California is for.
- elliekelly 7y agoOption 4: Litigation. Bring suit to have the California law declared unconstitutional and request an injunction on the law taking effect until a decision is made. I’m willing to bet the NCAA will spend millions on this, not for the benefit of student athletes, but to allow the NCAA to continue to exploit student athletes.
- kelnos 7y agoI doubt this would work all that well. Of course the NCAA can bring suit on whatever topic it pleases, but I don't see a court granting an injunction for something like this. It's a pretty common practice to enshrine into law rights that you aren't allowed to waive in contracts, and I don't see a judge believing this particular thing to be weird at all, let alone enough to grant an injunction. There might be an interstate-commerce-clause justification here on the side of the NCAA, but it seems pretty thin. IANAL, of course, so what do I know.
- elliekelly 7y agoI was thinking a dormant commerce clause[1] argument. And after a bit of duck ducking (duck duck going?) it seems they've won at least one case in the past using the theory.[2] I only skimmed the opinion but that case overturned a Nevada statute that set out due process requirements for those accused of NCAA violations. From the decision: > Essentially, the Statute requires any national collegiate athletic association to provide a Nevada institution, employee, student-athlete, or booster who is accused of a rules infraction with certain procedural due process protections during an enforcement proceeding in which sanctions may be imposed. Many of the procedures required by the Statute are not included in the NCAA enforcement program. For example, the NCAA does not provide the accused with the right to confront all witnesses, the right to have all written statements signed under oath and notarized, the right to have an official record kept of all proceedings, or the right to judicial review of a Committee decision. I'm not sure I really agree with the court's reasoning that it's a per se violation of the commerce clause but the rational is in Section B @ 638 if you're interesting. Here's hoping this precedent gets overturned but I'm not terribly optimistic. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dormant_Commerce_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dormant_Commerce_Clause [2] https://casetext.com/case/national-collegiate-athletic-assn-v-miller https://casetext.com/case/national-collegiate-athletic-assn-...
- slg 7y ago>Or Option 3, just change the NCAA rules to match California, and let players get paid. It needs to be pointed out that this law doesn't allow schools to pay players directly. There probably isn't enough money for that without totally restructuring athletic departments around the country (a football team like USC is wildly profitable, but most of that profit goes to pay for unprofitable teams like swimming, volleyball, etc). Paying players directly also has a number of Title IX repercussions that would likely need to be ironed out in court. This law instead allows the players a way to make money for themselves based off their participation in sports. That simply frees athletes up in the same way that non-athletes are unrestricted from how they can earn money while in school. No actor is going to be kicked out of their school's theater program because they got $200 for acting in a local car commercial. Now the football player won't either.
- kodablah 7y agoIs there a meaningful difference between a school paying players with booster-provided money and a company doing so? EDIT: To clarify, I mean a "practical" difference whether a booster gives money to a school to pay players or gives it to a company to do so. The payer matters to law, not to the paid nor to the practical result.
- jsgo 7y agoOne is an employee, the other is basically an influencer?
- aripickar 7y agoIn terms of title IX repercussions, there very much is.
- kodablah 7y agoI was a bit too succinct and therefore unclear. To rephrase, is there any meaningful difference between a booster paying players via the university or a booster taking their money to pay a player and doing it via a company instead? I understand the legal ramifications of who the payer is seen as, I am talking about the practical ramifications and whether a school having a player that is paid by a company rooting for the school (and with monies from same pockets) is meaningfully different. I'd say not.
- rconti 7y agoCan you explain who the Power 5 are, and what Division 0 would mean? And would Division 0 be inside or outside the NCAA? I don't get the implication of them all leaving the NCAA to create their own organization is, because I don't know the players in this 'game'. EDIT: Answered in a jedberg reply elsewhere in this thread.
- JackFr 7y ago> If sounds like the only winning move here is for the NCAA to allow paying players. That is the end of the NCAA. If California can dictate the fundamental nature of a voluntary organization, there's really little sense for the organization to exist.
- jessaustin 7y agoThank goodness, NCAA has been a blight on collegiate education for decades. The end of NCAA would be good for students, good for athletes, good for athletics, and good for colleges and universities. If most of what an organization does is harm, then absolutely that organization shouldn't exist.
- JackFr 7y agoI’m curious how ending the NCAA would be good for all those stakeholders.
- jessaustin 7y agoThe NCAA's monetary and administrative requirements distract from the educational mission of colleges. Ending that distraction would be good for students and colleges. NCAA's conservative tendencies and commercial interests hurt athletes directly as documented extensively on this page, and as often attested by the athletes themselves.
- khawkins 7y agoThe NCAA doesn't really have to choose anything here, just enforce rules on the books and nothing changes. It seems as if the law only removes the restriction that student athletes can't be paid, not that it requires payment. Whichever teams decide to pay their athletes will be excluded from the NCAA. Absent legislation with more teeth or a broad coalition of states and schools from across the country, I highly doubt California schools will drop out to create their own league. In fact, the money they're looking to give to athletes will soon dry up, absent the lucrative contracts the NCAA holds. Who would watch an independent league with so few teams in it and basically no national tournament circuit? Far from forcing the NCAA's hand, I think Newsom just passed feel-good legislation which doesn't really change anything. Perhaps other states will jump on board, but there doesn't seem to be any sight of that at the moment.
- Misdicorl 7y agoYour arguments are very much tail wagging the dog. NCAA has lucrative deals because of the schools, not vice versa. A division with UCLA, Berkeley, USC, Stanford, UCSD, UC-Davis + plenty I'm forgetting would be instantly watchable in football and basketball. Really the only thing they'd be missing out on would be March Madness (a big deal) and the college football championship (a minor deal). There would be a very swift Rose bowl replacement, and I'm sure the invited BIG10 would be happy to attend, and if not for whatever reason a top 2 from that division would be a fun championship game too. Really I see the only blocker here being participation in March Madness- but that feels like a short term roadblock and 'lets figure out when to pull the trigger' situation rather than an impossible hindrance. The smaller sports will certainly suffer in the short term- but California is a massive market and having a California only college league is totally plausible.
- lscotte 7y agoOption 4: ban college sports. School should be about education, not sports.
- basementcat 7y ago> Option 4: ban college sports. School should be about education, not sports. Are you okay with paying higher tuition that would have otherwise been offset with TV, merchandising, ticket revenue and alumni donations?
- TheCoelacanth 7y agoOverall, sports drain money from the universities; they don't provide it. About half of D1 football and men's basketball programs do make money, but even at those schools, the athletics program as a whole is still a money loser.
- seiko988 7y agoCarol Quigley points out in "Evolution of Civilizations" that institutions over time tend to do the opposite of their initial stated purpose with football being one example: A game called football was invented about 1870 to provide healthful physical exercise for the undergraduates on bright autumn afternoons. Seventy years later the undergraduates who needed exercise most were seated in the stands of a city baseball park on Friday night, with their flasks and their coeds, while on the grass (or mud) below, the undergraduates who needed exercise least pushed each other about under the floodlights.
- the_watcher 7y agoOption 3 is definitely the path of least resistance in terms of long term consequences. That said, I fully expect the NCAA to aggressively threaten Option 1, then back down when it becomes clear that they'll just lose out on all the revenue of that new league/competing governing body, which would have no trouble growing as schools that don't make a ton via the NCAA system looking for a recruiting edge race to join (a funny subplot for anyone who follows this sort of thing: how fast would SMU race to join a governing body that lets players sell their endorsement?). Then, they'll settle on Option 2, which allows them to do nothing and blame others for the fallout, despite it being the worst of the 3 options for all non-NCAA bureaucracy stakeholders.
- lstroud 7y agoI always thought the NCAA was a voluntary organization. Seems they can just take option 4 and ban teams that don’t comply with their rules. This move would have been more successful if had passed during a period when CA had competitive teams.