3 ms·
Math Notation is Terrible
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoThe article itself is interesting, but what really caught my eye was the 5 flaming comments it received. Bitter much, guys?
- timr 18y agoWell, I generally agree with the premise of the article (math notation sucks), but I also agree with the five flaming comments -- his example was bad. In particular, the "optimized" code was atrociously unreadable. It may have used fewer lines, but those lines were so packed with cleverness that they took more work to understand than the original notation. The first version of the code was okay, but probably not much easier to understand than the original math. There are some very bad examples of mathematical notation out there, but this wasn't really one of them.
- Tichy 18y agoSorry, bit math formulas in code are really unreadable. Bad, bad idea. It's the only downside of the popular book "Collaborative Intelligence" that it doesn't give proper maths formulas, only code.
- Kaizyn 18y agoFunny, I find just the opposite to be true for me. Formulas in code are easy to understand while math in notational form isn't.
- Tichy 18y agoI like to be able to take it all in at one glance. Sure, I can read code, but only "command by command", it is hard to see the big picture - for me, anyway. I think math notation evolved over centuries, too. That's not a proof that it could not be improved upon, but I remain sceptic. What will be next, musical notation? OK, admittedly play_c play_d play_e play_f# is more readable than musical notes in a way (namely, if you can't read notes), but I bet that if you want to actually play the notes with an instrument, you might eventually prefer the classical notation. Although for music, there are alternative notations that make sense in special cases. Maybe for maths it will be the same. Anyway, anybody who writes a maths paper is free to choose the representation they want.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoIt's true, especially for papers about algorithms. But if you need to do complicated calculations, math notation is useful; compactness does help you keep everything in your head. Most fields standardize notation quickly, and conventions helps also. In a physics paper, $\rho$ is a density and $\psi$ a wavefunction. Any author who gratuitously forks notation deserves to be rejected (with instructions to fix the notation). As for "too many subscripts", I'm not sure how other notation could fix it. That's just a problem coming from nested loops (sums, integrals, whatever): if you can't get rid of them, what can you do? Is ∑_x ∑_y f(x,y) worse than tmp = 0 for x = ... : for y = ...: tmp += f(x,y) return tmp
- andreyf 18y agoI agree, but the last part (assuming you meant to write in Python), could be written as: sum(f(x,y) for x in X for y in Y) ...which, ironically, is syntax inspired by mathematical notation :)