4 ms·
Because the literal destruction of the ecosphere due to global warming is not a sufficient motivation.
by adrianN 7y ago
Because the literal destruction of the ecosphere due to global warming is not a sufficient motivation.
- rr-geil-j 7y agoIf there's something I've had to accept is that at the end of the day, societal changes are realized either because the alternative causes financial losses or the "new thing" will bring in higher profit. For example, "pink money"[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink_money
- rowan647 7y agoWho owns the supply of minerals required to make electric car batteries? Does anyone know?
- adrianN 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Terrestrial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium#Terrestrial
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- benj111 7y agoI'm not sure you've established cause and effect here. Theres plenty of dirty money around, that hasn't made it socially more acceptable.
- rr-geil-j 7y agoI'm not saying that involving money with any X will make X socially acceptable. My comment is specific to most social causes which only gain traction not because of goodwill but because there is a threat of financial/economic losses and/or promise of financial/economic gains. Primary example of 'threats' would be business disruption through protests and boycotts, while the opposite will be promotion and recommendation. Or in the case of this article, people might be convinced of using EVs because there is threat of higher oil prices, not because the environment is being destroyed.
- stunt 7y ago> Because the literal destruction of the ecosphere due to global warming is not a sufficient motivation. Events like this can't shake it. Sadly so much money and power involved in the oil business. And looking into what giant energy companies are doing for more money and power, you realize the last thing they care is ecosphere.
- chrisco255 7y agoExcept the CO2 is acting as plant fertilizer: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/carbon-dioxide-fertilization-greening-earth https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2016/carbon-dioxide-fer... And it's not surprising since plants evolved on an earth with CO2 in the thousands of PPM.
- masklinn 7y ago> Except the CO2 is acting as plant fertilizer: That's not actually helpful to existing ecosystems, let alone to us. > And it's not surprising since plants evolved on an earth with CO2 in the thousands of PPM. None of the current ecosystems (to say nothing of humanity, let alone human civilisations) did. The last time CO2 was above 1000ppm was some time before the E-Og extinction event, 34Ma.
- chrisco255 7y agoI fail to follow your first argument. How would something that is good for plant life be bad for life on the planet? Plants form the base of the food chain. Virtually all modern plants grow at higher rates right up to 1200PPM. I'm not sure how taller trees and taller grasslands would affect us negatively. Presumably, more plant life means more animal life. As there is more food to support ecosystems.
- adrianN 7y agoIf you keep temperature and humidity controlled, like in a greenhouse, more CO2 is better for plants. It's completely unclear whether the dramatic changes that global climate change will bring will be similarly beneficial to the plants we have today.
- masklinn 7y ago> How would something that is good for plant life be bad for life on the planet? Because it's only "good for plant life" in the very long (geological) term. In the short and medium (again, geological) terms it's a significant upheaval which is good for pretty much nothing. > Virtually all modern plants grow at higher rates right up to 1200PPM. I'm not sure how taller trees and taller grasslands would affect us negatively. The 1200 PPM CO2 and associated effects would do that, especially in the short-term, it would take tens of thousands of years[0] for new ecological equilibriums to be reached during which the entire web would be broken. > Presumably, more plant life means more animal life It would mean very different animal life. The intermediary period would be mass deaths across the board. [0] at the very least, could be millions depending on the scale of disruption, it took ~2My for the ecosphere to stabilise after K–Pg, and a further ~8My for it to recover pre-K-Pg levels of diversity. Local disruptions are easily resolved as species can migrate from neighbouring non-disrupted ecosystems but global disruptions (of the entire ecosphere or of a very isolated ecosystem) not so.
- duckfruit 7y agoYou are being sarcastic, but this is literally true. Sadly loads of people don't even believe the truth of global warming (as if science is subject to the whims of people's beliefs). What would these people find more compelling? A slow, systemic process like global warming, which involves incremental changes taking place over decades - or the spectacle of exploding oil refineries, armed drones, and the drama of conflict. Probably the latter, even if the first is far more catastrophic.
- wallace_f 7y agoFor something to be Science, it requires the ability to stand up to the scrutiny of the scientific method. Edit: Imagine what kind of thinking could get this idea downvoted. It is not a good thing.
- benj111 7y agoYour comment reads like climate change denialism, reading the parents comment on yours I'm not entirely sure that's what you meant, so I invite you to clarify your position.
- wallace_f 7y ago>Your comment reads like climate change denialism I think this is religious thinking. You are attacking my idea for being somehow a kind of Wrongthink, and your implication is that expressinf Wrongthink is the reason for the disagreement. But then when you read the comment, it is a statement about what Science is. That being said, I don't feel my personal opinion matters, what is true is my statement. So I think for any further clarification, my comment should be applied to the subject. Can you scientifically prove CO2 is a greenhouse gas? Yea. Can you scientifically prove the world is going to end? No. This latter expression of alarmism is an opinion. This kind of consensus is wrong all the time. Remember Morton's skulls? Look up the history of some of the most embarassing Nobel Prizes. You might think I am a non-believer, heathen by now. Actually, I do try to reduce my carbon footprint, in stark contrast to my observations of most eco-holier-than-thou's behaviors. But I don't buy into the extreme alarmism, nor am I dumb enough to consider this apocalypse a fact. If you're buying this you're just regurgitating ideas that people more powerful than you want you to believe. Probably because they want more authority over the global economy and our lives, and to stop Russia from getting its massive windfall in economic resources that it would get from a significant increase in temperatures.
- iamsb 7y agoCurious - how much impact we would have on global warming if each and every car currently running is electric? Given that most of the electricity is provided by fossil fuels. Dont want to come across as a denier, this is a genuine question.
- adrianN 7y agoProbably a rather small impact. On the other hand, replacing all energy consumption but transportation with carbon free alternatives isn't enough either. Global warming doesn't have a simple solution. We need to attack a large number of problems simultaneously if we want a chance to prevent catastrophe.
- iamsb 7y agoI was hoping for a number, like say 1%. I wish there was a website which shows you exactly what are the causes of global warming and how much they contribute to it, preferably by industry and country. For example a small country like Australia which has less than 1% of human population, contributes enormously (15% of methane due to animal husbandry) but there is very little being done in that country to control this.
- pinkfoot 7y agoipcc.ch From the proverbial horse's mouth.
- dagw 7y agoCould only find numbers from the EU, but there passenger cars account for ~18% of total CO2 emissions. Everybody else seems to report cars and trucks as one group so it's hard to estimate how much of that impact is cars.
- reacweb 7y agoThe overall losses between the power plant and consumers is in the range between 8 and 15%. An electric motor typically is between 85% and 90% efficient. Conventional gasoline vehicles only convert about 17%–21% of the energy stored in gasoline to power at the wheels. State-of-the-art fossil fuel plants at 46% efficiency. Using average values gives a ratio of 46x0.885x0.875/19=1.87 (electric almost twice as efficient). This calculus has not taken into account transport and filling the tank and older fossil fuel plants (maybe they compensate each others).