7 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this. I am absolutely aware this can be a means to intentionally exclude specific groups due to prejudice and can be a polite way to
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I have mixed feelings about this. I am absolutely aware this can be a means to intentionally exclude specific groups due to prejudice and can be a polite way to do terrible things. I get that.
But the reality is that the modern world seems to seriously suck at figuring out how to help people find the right kind of job for themselves or help employers find the right people for the job. I keep thinking "Surely, there must be a better way than what we are doing currently."
Maybe if we worked on solving that issue we would see less of this issue. Like if it is a job for writing HTML and you write HTML, there are ways to find you based on that and it won't matter what your gender or age is.
- nefitty 7y agoThis is a great idea. What about a service that allows proctored skills tests for applicants? Like Sitepoint but with some additional verification layers. Hiring managers would then pick a tech stack or set of skills they need, and matches would bubble up based on applicants in the area with the relevant skills. The "culture fit" question could be another egg to crack. Who knows if interviews are the best way to figure that out...
- hysan 7y agoAny process that attempts to “solve” the technical skills verification problem will not work unless it replaces the technical portion of the on-site interview. Otherwise, companies can still reject based on technical assessments in which case you’ve solved nothing. You’ve simply changed the shape of the hiring funnel. Also, looking beyond the immediate need, companies would also need to understand that this only applies to very specific positions. You shouldn’t apply this to entry level, nor should you apply this to positions where the employee is expected to adapt quickly to changing tech stacks. What this leaves you with is contracting. You hire experts with a very specific skillset that you need that is verified by an agency. For everything else, there is still not a good generic solution.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou’ve simply changed the shape of the hiring funnel. Sometimes, that's enough to make a real difference. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rooney_Rule https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rooney_Rule
- hinkley 7y agoYou know what's super weird? My company selects for people who can pass white board interviews. Which are not only terrible in their own right but also not the way anybody I know codes. And despite that, most of the people I work with are actually below average at explaining things with drawings or whiteboards. And since that average in our industry is already "pretty awful" that's saying something. So not only are we looking for the wrong thing, but we haven't even proven our own people can do the thing we thought we were looking at. I'm starting to think a lottery system would be better. We know we have algorithms that do better with random sampling. Maybe hiring is one of them.
- aheilbut 7y agolike college?
- PeterStuer 7y agoSounds like you are hiring faceless nameless cogs in a machine.
- mschuster91 7y agoMost coding and other jobs these days are cogs in the machine. The amount of jobs where one can have individual impact is next to negligible.
- PeterStuer 7y agoDepends on which side of the industry you are I guess. In bespoke software most of the work is either customer facing or at the very least would require team skills, even for 'coders'.
- goatinaboat 7y agoWhat about a service that allows proctored skills tests for applicants? You mean like... a university?
- nefitty 7y agoDo universities provide employers with the results of skills tests on things like Git?
- seanmcdirmid 7y ago> there are ways to find you based on that and it won't matter what your gender or age is. For the higher paying specialized jobs, it’s called a network. But networking is even more biased than formal recruiting approaches.
- formercoder 7y agoIs it biased in a bad way? It’s really hard to measure someone’s ability to do a job, especially for a more senior role. Therefore, I feel comfortable hiring people recommended to me by others that I trust.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoBecause white men that dominate those jobs already typically know white men to recommend for those jobs.
- macintux 7y agoDirector of engineering at a former employer once said in the span of 30 seconds: “we’re trying to hire more diversity” and “please reach out to your social network”. To an audience of 98% white males. The director acknowledged the incongruity, thankfully, but never solved the problem.
- gleenn 7y agoI think you're assuming white males don't know how to suggest females and non-whites. We may be statistically more likely to hang out with other white males but I'm pretty sure I can suggest people besides them.
- macintux 7y agoI can and did, but that doesn’t alter the fact that the preponderance of our collective networks were white males. That’s not a strategy for significant diversification.
- tomlockwood 7y agoI think even more generally, companies suck at ad targeting. Companies may have all the data in the world about their targets, but they don't particularly have the time nor the will nor the incentives to think about good segmentation, so they fall back to the "tried and true /s" age and gender segments.
- kjs3 7y agoThe "modern world" sucks at figuring out how to help people find the right kind of job for one of two reasons: 1) they keep thinking about gender and age as qualifiers for jobs for which those factors have absolutely zero relevance (girls are bad at math! Old people can't learn new things!), or 2) They invent the delusion that gender and age disqualifies you for a job (girls will just get pregnant and leave! oldster can only do Cobol, they'll never learn Python!).
- soulofmischief 7y agoI'm glad you care about these things, but to say those are the only two reasons why we have trouble correctly matching people to fulfilling jobs is asinine.
- kitsune_ 7y agoThis very post is about targeted advertising to keep women and older people from seeing job ads. You then went off a tangent about employer-prospect matching in general. What other reasons are there that lead women and older people to be excluded? I'd probably add salary as a factor with older people.
- arkh 7y agoOlder people and women: usually prefer a good work life balance. So they're harder to exploit.
- soulofmischief 7y agoDude: > The "modern world" sucks at figuring out how to help people find the right kind of job for one of two reasons: > 1) they keep thinking about gender and age as qualifiers for jobs for which those factors have absolutely zero relevance (girls are bad at math! Old people can't learn new things!), or > 2) They invent the delusion that gender and age disqualifies you for a job (girls will just get pregnant and leave! oldster can only do Cobol, they'll never learn Python!). I didn't "go off on a tangent" about anything. OP already refocused the conversation to apply to the entire problem domain of career matching, which is absolutely absurd, so I teased the two issues back apart. Put on your reading glasses.