7 ms·
I'm totally a layperson on the subject but the other day I thought about how far more devices in my house use DC than AC than 30 years ago. It seems odd that I
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I'm totally a layperson on the subject but the other day I thought about how far more devices in my house use DC than AC than 30 years ago. It seems odd that I convert solar to AC then back to DC.
I wonder if there's any future to running both an AC and a DC bus through the house, or if that makes no sense for reasons beyond my basic understanding.
- shantly 7y agoI've seen (owned a house having) dual-fuel natural gas + electric light fixtures, mounted to walls, gas pipes to every room right alongside the (knob & tube) electrical wires. So we've done weirder shit in the past to deliver two types of power throughout houses. And no, I never tried lighting one. Hopefully none of them had had an active gas supply in decades.
- froindt 7y agoAlso a layperson. How many different specs are running around the house, and what sorts of electrical variations can they withstand? I think you'd need to have a house-wide AC-DC converter to feed in energy when your solar supply drops down. Or a battery storage system probably makes more sense.
- adrianmonk 7y agoPower losses in wiring are an issue. Many of your DC devices also happen to be low-voltage. (For example, USB devices.) If you transmit the same number of watts at a higher voltage (lower current) rather than at a lower voltage (higher current) through a wire, you will lose less power. So for moving the power around the house at distances more than around 10 feet (~3 meters), it's more energy-efficient to convert it near the point of use. And if you're already going to convert it, it's probably not worth the expense and complication of running two separate wiring systems.
- kragen 7y agoThe USB power supply is probably a 5-volt switchmode power supply which doesn't care whether its input is 80 volts or 300 volts, or ac or dc. You could very reasonably run 100 volts dc or 200 volts dc to things that use switchmode power supplies like that.
- sephamorr 7y agoA normal worldwide USB power supply accepts 86-240v AC, so you can usually supply a DC voltage on the same terminals of the same voltage with no issue (convert from AC peak to peak to DC)
- BurningFrog 7y agoLooked around a bit, and the link below says DC has a lot of problems. One is that you's still have to convert your home DC voltage to whatever voltage each DC device uses. https://www.quora.com/Why-do-we-use-AC-but-not-DC-in-households?redirected_qid=25900530 https://www.quora.com/Why-do-we-use-AC-but-not-DC-in-househo...
- elihu 7y agoMost things that use DC use pretty low voltage, like 5 or 12 volts or so. High voltage allows you to transfer energy much more efficiently. So, for low power devices it might make sense to run a low voltage line but you wouldn't be able to run high-power devices out of it unless you wire your house with really thick wiring.
- Tharkun 7y agoI wish more devices would run on PoE. It's DC, it's easy to install, it carries power and data. There are some (but few) PoE light fixtures, but not as many as I'd like.
- velox_io 7y agoThat does make sense, especially for IoT devices (literally anything low power). However, I haven't seen PoE used outside of business use. The problem is that Wifi is becoming ever more prevalent (on my network I have 12 devices using wifi, and only my desktop using an ethernet cable - ironically the only device that isn't suitable for PoE).
- rodgerd 7y agoI use PoE UniFi gear, because running a single Ethernet cable to power e.g. a wifi AP gives me a lot more flexibility in placing it cleanly than having to worry about power; that's for residential use. Given the degree of fire risk in houses that's associated with 230V/10A wiring and devices, I do wonder how much safer it would be to have fewer AC/DC transformers scattered around the house with DC wiring.
- maxdamantus 7y agoIf you're using DC to transmit the same amount of power, you'll probably be using similar voltages (otherwise you're going to need thicker cables). I suspect DC is probably a greater fire risk in this case due to arcing. An arc is less likely to persist on AC since the potential keeps passing through 0 V (hence DC switches are designed to have a bigger air gap). If it's just a matter of providing alternative circuitry for low-power devices, presumably you can already improve safety by just using lower-current circuit breakers.
- rodgerd 7y ago> If you're using DC to transmit the same amount of power, you'll probably be using similar voltages (otherwise you're going to need thicker cables). A good point - I guess I'm mostly thinking about the volume of things in the house that don't really need access to even a fraction of the 2.4kW available; having moved from incandescent bulbs to LEDs, I've got a bunch of unnecessary power supply and per-bulb transformers, for example.
- conk 7y agoIt has less to do with ac vs dc and more to do with the voltage and distance from source to load. If you wanted a dc bus inside a house you would need to have voltages in the same range as ac power 120/240V in North America. At this point you have the same challenges of how do you reduce the voltage to something low and easy to work with for an end device like a light bulb or cell phone. Stepping down voltage is easy to do with AC power but difficult for DC which is why I don’t think it will ever be practical.
- convolvatron 7y ago48v dc bus and buck converters work just fine. generally power supplies that work off AC rectify and go through the same business - except they need larger inductors to sort out the zero crossing. i think the difference you're looking for is in volume of copper.
- jws 7y agoMaybe we should instead invent a domestic 3 phase distribution system. No more zero crossings requiring energy storage, just flat constant power. It would require a new, small four conductor plug to be designed. Total volume of copper would be a less for the same available power, since the three wires deliver twice the power as two single phase wires for the same conductor size. There would be more insulation involved so the wiring might grow or might shrink if outlets were held to 1500watts. The big savings would be in longer lived electronic devices. A sizable portion of digital electronics ultimately fail because the capacitors in their power supplies exceed their designed lifetime. Electrolytic capacitors (ticking time bombs) are cheap and compact for the capacity so they are used for the energy storage required in single phase systems, but if designing a three phase power supply less storage is required and maybe manufacturers wouldn't have to optimize the smaller, capacitors with electrolytics. I've had a 4k TV and a rather expensive musical instrument amp fail for capacitors this year, about $3000 of gear there. Looking back further there are a couple of professional powered sound reinforcement speakers (twice), an iMac G5 (three times). It's probably safe to say over the decades I've had $10k of electronics fail prematurely from electrolytic capacitor failure. These are all items which were not obsolete or worn out. Scale that up from one person to worldwide and it's easily in the hundreds of billions (10⁹) of dollars which could be saved. The problem is you can't get there from where we are. No one wants to drag more wires to residential houses, no one wants to shell out >$1k for a household phase converter and then rewire their house. You won't convince people to add three phase to a new house because it might be the future. And you won't convince the semiconductor houses to make a line of three phase power supply controller chips just because, well, maybe someone might use it. We're probably trapped at a suboptimal local maximum. Edit: In response to atoav's comment I found IEC 60309 and its extra low voltage variant which is a 42mm (1 2.3") 3 phase plug and connector in two compatible sizes good for 1.3kW and 2.6kW. Also, that Germans and Swedes did the engineering first and then built an electrical system and they get 480V 3 phase at 16A to their cooktops and stoves through a plug for a whopping 13kW!
- lapinot 7y agoIt's actually a good intuition. See: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2016/04/slow-electricity-the-return-of-low-voltage-dc-power.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2016/04/slow-electricity-t... tldr: it would make sense for an office building but actually not that much in a residential one.
- F_r_k 7y agoNew (>2005) AC/DC converters (switching PSU), have such a high efficiency than I would think it's not worth the hassle
- xxs 7y agoPretty much all switching power supplies would run off DC as well - from 110V - 350V DC.
- namibj 7y agoIs there any safe way to test this for a server PSU? As in "unlikely to blow the PSU", potentially requiring slight pre-checking by looking at the circuit?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y agoYes, a noop and declaring the "test" successful. I would be very surprised if you could find any non-ancient (and I really mean ancient, like, pre-PC, probably even pre-home computers) computer PSU that you couldn't feed with DC. What voltages will work will vary, but as long as you stay below the peak voltage corresponding to the effective voltage printed on the label, you probably won't damage anything. If you really want to test it, you could measure the resistance at the mains input, if that gives you a non-infinite value that stays at that value (rather than increasing towards infinity), you are dealing with a mains transformer. But you really won't find that in a computer PSU.
- xxs 7y ago~240V fully rectified to DC is 340V. Since AC varies it's safe to say virtually any PSU that's not exclusively Japan or North America will take 350V DC.
- namibj 7y agoThanks! It's a hot-swappable 300-1897 (aka X6328A aka Type A217) 1050W Sun PSU. I'm primarily worried about the active PFC I expect in it. Is there a way to test such a PSU without risking the entire server? (save for taking everything out that isn't needed to post into BIOS)
- xxs 7y agoRealistically 25-30A with thick copper wire are doable. 20V is a good ground but even then it could power a TV + couple laptops, perhaps lights too. That would be a solution to have dedicate DC lane in-house but the conversion to low voltage DC must have in-house (office buildings would require tons of copper). Galvanic corrosion might be an issue to a certain degree. Carrying high voltage DC, comes with its own issues - likely doable though. Many household devices would run perfectly fine on high voltage DC (instead of AC).
- namibj 7y agoHonestly, just use aluminium cables. Those only need proper crimping, which isn't too expensive. The cost for the cables themselves would be lower than copper AC, even.
- HALtheWise 7y agoFor the devices that run off of low voltage DC today, lots of other commenters make good points about needing to regulate the voltage anyway, and I'm inclined to agree. Those devices generally use very little power anyway, so it probably isn't worth running a second set of wires because copper is expensive. On the other hand, the biggest power users in a house (heater, air conditioner, dryer, stove, refrigerator) seem like they are a different story. In a future home with solar power and a high voltage DC battery pack, I think there is opportunity to make appliances that operate from the raw battery voltage, which is in the 300-500v DC range. That way, there isn't any conversion required at all, and those applications should be able to handle slight variations in voltage as the battery discharges.
- pjkundert 7y agoAny high voltage DC distribution system would require every load to have a single run, with intelligent connectors paired with remote switches to shut off the circuit at detection of any detected alteration of the circuit (eg. Ground fault, capacitance change, etc.) High voltage DC is spectacularly more dangerous than high voltage AC.
- woliveirajr 7y agoCould you give more details of this danger?
- maxdamantus 7y agoAn arc on AC is more likely to be extinguished since the current drops to zero many times every second (so eg, on 50 Hz AC, an arc is not likely to last more than 1/100 of a second). DC switches and circuit breakers are designed with greater concern for arcs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thatcat 7y agoYou could do power over ethernet to get connectivity too.
- heimatau 7y agoConk has a good response but you also have to realize that it's still too expensive to setup a battery as well. So, since the grid will be needed, you'll need conversion to be able to handle the fluctuating demand your home requires. And don't install new devices, as that can change your equation but connecting back to the grid allows much needed simplicity. Other companies are working on this (energy sovereignty) issue, my guess it (stand alone affordable systems) will be solved within the next twenty years and be affordable. DC use might be apart of it but I'm doubtful since there is a level of complexity that each device is using different amps/volts/etc that will take new products to solve and the independent grid system still takes a lot of capital.
- 205guy 7y agoA friend of mine did something similar. He put in a small solar array with only 3 panels, an inverter/charger, and 400 Ah of 12-volt batteries. This DC then feeds into a breaker panel and goes to lights in all the rooms. He uses LED spotlights, the little bulbs that plug into wires stretched across the ceiling. He said he just ran 10-gauge Romex wires through the attic, down to DC-rated switches and then to the ends of the cables. He still has all the original 110 wiring and fixtures in the house, but this battery-backed solar system runs all his lights. It can easily go 2 days without sun before he needs to use the regular lights. Another benefit is that DC LED bulbs are by definition flicker-free, and also low consumption (4-6 watts each) but bright. He calculated he can light each room better than before with 6-8 bulbs, so 40-50 watts, thus only 4-5 Amps (@ 12 VDC) to each room. All the big appliances in the house still run off of of AC, but he does have a 110 inverter so that he could run a critical appliance such as a fridge during an extended outage. So this little system replaces 1-2 kWh of incandescent lighting per day (CFC or LEDs on 110 would be less, but not flicker-free), while providing lights during outages. He says it's not cost-effective (the usage displaced by solar and battery usage doesn't cover the cost of the system), but the backup powers is worth it to him.
- holoduke 7y agoI am actually thinking of something similar. Instead of 12v DC I probably would go for 48v or maybe even higher. With 12v your cables soon start to become too thick to be practical if you want to run serious things like garage doors / window shades etc.
- 205guy 7y agoMy friend said he picked 12V because that's what the easily-available LED bulbs are rated at, and he just wanted a simple lights-only system. I guess you could pick whatever voltage you want for your loads and cable runs, but you need to have the appliances you want available (or easily DIY) in that voltage. It would probably be possible to convert down the voltage once, but any more than that and you're introducing loss again.
- 7y ago
- rock_hard 7y agoThis is a thing! The ISS runs 120v DC for this reason...higher efficiency and much less complex since you don’t need inverters and and power supplies. My burning man camp of 65 people also only has a DC grid that runs on 24v 30kwh daily solar harvest It’s a thing of beauty :)
- holoduke 7y agoConverting DC voltage is unlike AC with transformers not easy or practical.
- makomk 7y agoVery few AC-powered devices even use traditional transformers anymore. Mostly they have some kind of switch-mode power supply which immediately rectifies the AC to DC. (Better and higher-power supplies have complicated active power factor correction circuits to do this.) Then they convert that high-voltage DC to low-voltage DC.
- walrus01 7y agoA number of off grid cabin setups use DC distribution within the house and purely DC appliances (fridge, LED lighting, etc). Usually in the context of places that are very far from a grid, with wood heat, or tiny home size off grid setups. Think of it something like planning the DC loads on a 55 ft sailboat. People who do this will usually have one small 300 to 500W sized DC to ac pure sinewave inverter for laptops and chargers of small consumer electronics.
- mycall 7y agoMany of your AC devices are actually DC after transformer.
- droithomme 7y ago> I wonder if there's any future to running both an AC and a DC bus through the house I used to have a house built around 1950 which had combination 117/220AC and 25VDC wired throughout the house. The electrical box was sectioned and the 25V had a large transformer. The house had low voltage DC ceiling fixtures that were tricky to source, and everything in the house that was switch controlled was on relays that allowed multi-point control, smart timers, and various other functions. It was a chore to get replacement parts but fortunately the attic had gangways and such so replacing blown relays was not horrific once you had the replacement parts. It was perfect for upgrading to smart control which I did for about half the house before selling it. Here's the thing. Tons of houses back then were wired this way. It was the wiring of the future and they explicitly realized in the 50s that someday they would be able to have computers in the home, perhaps as small as a single room, control everything. So instead of an electrical closet there was an electrical room with enough space for a refrigerator sized computer should such a thing ever come to market. 1950s.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt’s happening even more than you think. Your fridge is probably running “variable frequency drive”, so instead of being off and on at full blast, it just runs the compressor at 20hz or 30hz or whatever it needs continuously, and dialing that up or down depending on demand. Your air conditioner too. For bigger customers, this saves them a fortune in demand charges. For others, it prolongs life by vastly reducing stop/starts.