4 ms·
I assume the idea isn't "don't go to the bathroom" so much as "please use the bathroom before class starts." That isn't such an unreasonable ask if classes are
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I assume the idea isn't "don't go to the bathroom" so much as "please use the bathroom before class starts." That isn't such an unreasonable ask if classes are relatively short.
Adding that to a computerized point system is what makes it seem creepy...
- KirinDave 7y ago5th grade classes typically have hours without interruption. I'm pretty sure I pee once before lunch too if I don't have a terrifying and dystopian social credit system docking me for the priviledge of emptying my bladder.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI'm sure every school is different, but I've observed 5th grade classes (I was planning to become a teacher at one point), and they never went longer than an hour, at least not without a quick stretch break or something.
- reaperducer 7y agoStretch break? Never heard of it. Class 1 → Class 2 → Class 3 → Recess → Class 4 → Lunch → Class 5 → Class 6 Fourth grade and under, insert Milk Break between 2 and 3. But that's it.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThe break is only if it's an abnormally long class. If there's six classes + lunch + recess, none of those classes should be longer than an hour. Remember, school is usually seven hours or less, and you need some time between each class for the kids to get from point A to point B.
- KirinDave 7y agoNot sure where you're from, but here in western America most 5th grade activities aren't split between classrooms. They have one or two primary teachers and one primary workspace for the whole day. That class based split appears in middle school, which is Grade 7 onwards.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI've seen 5th grades in the US where the kids are walked between classrooms for different classes, specifically in order to "prepare them for middle school." In other cases, I've still observed some sort of break. You can certainly construct a scenario where this bathroom policy makes zero sense, but you can also construct one where it's a bit more logical. I feel like we're missing a lot of context here, and absent information to the contrary, I'd rather assume the best than jump to outrage.
- KirinDave 7y agoWhy should we? Schools are universally reviled in the US because of what they have become. Mindless drudgery and ineffective teaching techniques mixed with a sullen workforce prepping the next generation of sullen workforce. Wealthy individuals counteract this with extensive (and expensive!) private tutoring.
- watwut 7y agoIn schools here, continuous class is 45min and there are breaks between them. No one has hours without interruption.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoMost American schools are like that only from middle school. Elementary schools have teachers traveling between classes instead, if they bother changing the teacher at all. Breaks are simply recess and lunch periods.
- KirinDave 7y agoAmerican schools are pretty terrible and have only gotten worse. Even private institutions.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI remembered teachers constantly acting like we had 20 minutes between classes, so we had no excuse if we didn't have the time to do everything from taking a shit to printing resources out at the library between classes. Of course, they also wouldn't let us out of class in time ("I dismiss you, not the bell!" power trip). In reality, the time between classes was used up just commuting between classes and changing your textbook from the locker. I also remember so much downtime during class that I would regularly sleep in school. So the idea that bathroom breaks need to be some scarce resource is ridiculous. Not to mention any time you need that privacy whether it's GI issues or adjusting your colostomy bag or whatever.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 7y agoNot all people's bodies work the same all the time, and not all 5th graders have perfect decision making. Urgent bathroom needs are an event that everyone will have in their life. Negative reinforcement for isolated instances of this is abusive. Bathroom usage is of zero concern to an instructor unless it becomes an abnormal pattern. And if it is, the interest should be out of a concern for health, unless demonstrated otherwise, not a concern for discipline.
- cwyers 7y agoThe length of classes doesn't matter much is passing times between classes are short. My kid goes to school in a building with three floors.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI feel like we're missing a lot of context here. How much time does this school have between classes? How long are their classes? And, are there any actual consequences for losing points?
- nwallin 7y agoWhen I was in fifth grade, we had lunch break, and a mid morning break. Other than that, we were in the same room all day. "Don't go to the bathroom" when you have a ten-ish year old bladder under those circumstances is a completely unreasonable request. Where I grew up, elementary school was done in one classroom and taught by one teacher. There were no breaks between classes because we didn't have separate classes. I'm not convinced this is the best system, but I am convinced ~2 hours is too long to go without a bathroom break.
- Consultant32452 7y agoMy daughter is in middle school. She is not allowed to use the restroom within the window of 10 minutes after class starts or 10 minutes after it begins. Also, the time between classes is like 3-4 minutes, which is not enough time to take a restroom break and get to class. Basically, schools are hell.
- mantap 7y agoFor the same reason you wouldn't expect young children to lift heavy weights. Adults have much stronger muscles than children, including bladder muscles.