7 ms·
I appreciate the attempt to be diplomatic, and I agree that using average pilots is sensible. But, with respect, I could not disagree more with the rest of that
by dahart 7y ago
I appreciate the attempt to be diplomatic, and I agree that using average pilots is sensible. But, with respect, I could not disagree more with the rest of that.
> Blame is a loaded word.
Boeing’s response to the accidents was to blame the pilots, there is precedent for this word in this situation.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/23/business/american-airlines-boeing-pilots-union/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/23/business/american-airlines-bo...
> Boeing assumed that pilots could be relied upon
No, Boeing intentionally hid information from pilots. This is well known.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-withheld-information-on-737-model-according-to-safety-experts-and-others-1542082575 https://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-withheld-information-on-...
> Whether Boeing or the pilots is at fault is, from a safety perspective, irrelevant
No. If you want to fix the problem, you must know what the problem is. The cause may be irrelevant to the people who are dead, but it is absolutely relevant to solving the problem in the future especially from a safety perspective.
- totally 7y agoIt sounds like you're advocating for blame-ful post mortems. Is that the case and what's your reasoning?
- aeonsky 7y agoYes, when 400 people die for a company to save money, you must assign blame and put people in jail.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoI have downvoted your comment, because I believe it does more to obscure understanding than to enlighten. > when 400 people die for a company to save money Let me take a step back and ask: Why? Is it because we're vindictive, and demand blood? Or is it because this actually does something to help keep people from dying in the future? If the latter is more important than the former -- which I hope is the case -- how can we trust that we're pursuing a course that improves the future of society while also using rhetoric to the effect of "when 400 people die for a company to save money"? Consider, for instance: Part of reason for the company "saving money" is that it results in lower costs for planes, and ultimately lower airfare for customers who pay airlines' capital expenses, potentially resulting in fewer miles driven and fewer accident. Is reducing this statistical danger more or less than the danger of the planes? Quite possibly, it's not -- but using this rhetoric certainly won't help us find out. More broadly the "omg greed" narrative, which -- to me, at least -- just doesn't make too much sense. If the corner-cutting that led to 737 Max problems is to be understood as a "greed" move, it's a pretty incompetent one, because Boeing is almost certainly out billions over the mess. People who seek to maximize profits for their own self-interest also seek to mitigate risk, for the same reason. I would suggest that a "hubris" narrative, or something similar, is probably more appropriate here. If this is so, the remedies are entirely different, and the assertion that we MUST jail people, because it fits our "greed" narrative and whatever cognitive bias we drag into the picture, ensures that we will not remedy the problem effectively. This means people may die.
- toss1 7y agoJust because it us an incompetent greed move, dors not mean it wasn't a greed move. They lost big thus time, but they were winning big, with more orders than they could make. When Boeing mgt declared that they 'no longer needed [to spend money on] senior engineers because these are mature products', and successfully pushed for the same type rating for a plane with deadly different handling characteristics (to save money on pilot training), both were explicit greed moves. And yes, irresponsible managers who ignored the reality of physics and put their profits over the safety of passengers should go to jail for their criminally bad decisions.
- lorenb 7y ago> If the corner-cutting that led to 737 Max problems is to be understood as a "greed" move, it's a pretty incompetent one, because Boeing is almost certainly out billions over the mess. Incompetence and greed aren’t mutually exclusive. If you take the word of all of the good engineers who were pushed out or quit in frustration over the financialization of the company after the McDonnall Douglas merger, then “omg greed” really does explain everything. Note that this could have been (and was) predicted by anyone with half a brain: “On some level, though, he saw it all coming; he even demonstrated how the costs of a grounded plane would dwarf the short-term savings achieved from the latest outsourcing binge in one of his reports that no one read back in 2002.*“ https://newrepublic.com/article/154944/boeing-737-max-investigation-indonesia-lion-air-ethiopian-airlines-managerial-revolution https://newrepublic.com/article/154944/boeing-737-max-invest...
- tomxor 7y ago> the assertion that we MUST jail people, because it fits our "greed" narrative and whatever cognitive bias we drag into the picture, ensures that we will not remedy the problem effectively. This means people may die. You don't send people to jail because of "greed", broadly speaking you might divide it into two categories: A) this specific person is a threat to society; B) this person did something morally unconscionable, irresponsible, negligent etc. The reasoning for following through with B is not merely vindictive, it's societal value is in sending a message that this behaviour is not OK! that is a preventative measure - "you must be morally responsible". This is entirely applicable to this scenario: greed is NOT the problem, trying to make cheaper planes is NOT the problem, trying to beat the competition is NOT the problem - The problem is attaining those goals by gambling with peoples lives by cutting corners that significantly compromise safety, that is gross negligence. ... So yes! send the people responsible to jail, please show the next in line that this behaviour is not tolerated.
- snuxoll 7y agoNot playing the blame game is what you do when you have a development team figuring out what went wrong when something went down for a couple hours. This is a corporation putting a product on the market with a critical safety system that lacked redundancy and poor training given to pilots. Yes, there is blame to be placed here. Individuals who worked on the system aren’t the issue here, a greedy corporation is and I feel no sympathy for the company itself.
- tomekn 7y agoThere is a difference between what we in tech consider a post-mortem, and a more literal one.
- bennylope 7y agoThis wasn't a web service that was unavailable for a couple hours; planes crashed and people died.
- wsy 7y agoThe essence of successful post mortems is getting the fact collection right, before discussing how to prevent the issue. The grandparent's summary omitted essential facts.
- wtvanhest 7y agoThere is a nuance to his/her comments that may be being lost. When an airliner goes down, the airline, the pilots union and the airline manufacturer all point fingers. That is what happens. When Boeing says we should use "average pilots" there is subtly in the statement that assigns blame. Boeing should have said, "we should use pilots who are trained through normal training procedures, rather than over trained test pilots." That statement would not have assigned blame and OP is probably correct that the statement choice was intentionally designed to shift blame back to the pilots.
- treis 7y ago>Boeing’s response to the accidents was to blame the pilots, there is precedent for this word in this situation. Your cite says Boeing said: >The actions of the pilots played a role in the chain of events that caused the crashes Which isn't blaming them and is factually correct in both crashes. The Lion Air pilots didn't disable electric trim and the Ethiopian air ones turned it back on. Those actions played a role in the crashes. Whether that makes the pilots responsible and at fault for the crash is a separate question. >If you want to fix the problem, you must know what the problem is. And, again, the problem (among other problems) was that the designer of the aircraft made assumptions about pilots that were incorrect.
- o-__-o 7y agoDon’t forget the pilot of the previous LA607 flight was able to recover successfully. Other pilot crew had more flight time, thus more experience. Look at NTSB crash data, experienced crews have a higher chance of lower fatalities in an accident. Why? Because these pilots understand their vehicle like the back of their hand. A 5000+ hour pilot has deep knowledge, for instance, of the hydraulic system of the plane and will try to e.g drop flaps to squeak out extra fluid in an emergency. Is this a good thing? Maybe. Probably. Is it sustainable? Like managing a growing server farm manually, probably not. Planes are going to get dumber, but there will be a lot more connected planes for remote troubleshooting/control
- beamatronic 7y agoWhat type of process could be used to make sure that their experience and knowledge gets back into the mainline product?
- IllogicalLogic 7y agoHow about Boeing stops taking cost saving measures that end up throwing unnecessary curve balls at otherwise well trained pilots? At the end of the day, this is the foundation of the problem.
- mlyle 7y agoIn aviation we tend to look at failure chains. There are many, many things that went wrong: 1. The stuck AOA instrumentation on the plane. 2. MCAS not using redundant AOA information and being fooled by the stuck instrumentation. 3. Lack of clear indication of what MCAS was doing contributing to flight crew confusion. 4. Improper execution of the runaway trim procedure/checklist by flight crew. 5. Training shortcomings about MCAS in particular. 6. Operator / national regulator training shortcomings in dealing with runaway trim procedure. If you remove any of these links in the chain, the crash is less likely to happen. Good risk management tries to improve all of them. #5 that you mention is important. #4 / #6 are important, too -- jurisdictions that emphasized this training produced flight crews that did the right things and survived. #2 and #3 are most important, IMO, and even #1 deserves some thought (can the instrumentation be made better/more reliable?) I say #2/#3 are most important because using training alone to fix a system that does tricky things at a difficult time is a band-aid, and is going to let some of the accident scenarios through.
- dahart 7y agoAgreed! Your comment reminds me a lot of this 1998 article about the ValuJet crash in Flordia https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/03/the-lessons-of-valujet-592/306534/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1998/03/the-les... Specifically it's the argument in the article that large disasters often have multiple causes. "Perrow says, Murphy's Law is wrong—what can go wrong usually goes right. But then one day a few of the bad little choices come together, and circumstances take an airplane down. Who, then, is really to blame?" In large disasters, sometimes several not very likely simultaneous failures happen at the same time. "The ValuJet accident is different. I would argue that it represents the third and most elusive kind of disaster, a "system accident," which may lie beyond the reach of conventional solution, and which a small group of thinkers, inspired by the Yale sociologist Charles Perrow, has been exploring elsewhere—for example, in power generation, chemical manufacturing, nuclear-weapons control, and space flight. Perrow has coined the more loaded term "normal accident" for such disasters, because he believes that they are normal for our time. His point is that these accidents are science's illegitimate children, bastards born of the confusion that lies within the complex organizations with which we manage our dangerous technologies. Perrow is not an expert on commercial flying, but his thinking applies to it nonetheless. In this case the organization includes not only ValuJet, the archetype of new-style airlines, but also the contractors that serve it and the government entities that, despite economic deregulation, are expected to oversee it."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]