2 ms·
> ... I consider myself consciously aware. I don't see what any of that experience has to do with language. How do you consider yourself to be anything if your
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
> ... I consider myself consciously aware. I don't see what any of that experience has to do with language.
How do you consider yourself to be anything if your mind does not use tokenised abstractions, ie some level of language?
Cogito ergo sum and all.
I've got to say I'm still pretty happy with the concept of the superego. That consciousness and ability for supervisory control seems to rely on the same handling of complex abstraction as language does.
- jfz 7y agoWhy must the abstractions be tokenized? I can notice myself feeling things, and surely that counts as awareness of the self. If you notice that you are full of anger or joy, you notice that _you_ exist.
- arunix 7y agoSurely noticing yourself means you've objectivized yourself i.e. tokenized yourself as an abstraction?
- zwkrt 7y agoWell you can even fall back to saying that all sensations are abstractions. After all when you feel wet there is no part of your brain that “gets wet”. But the constant mirroring of the external world by your mental abstractions is not something over which you have full control and you couldn’t stop it if you wanted to. Language has nothing to do with it. After all you don’t personally assemble the images you see from your rods and cones, nor did you ever get to choose what cinnamon smells like.
- simonh 7y agoIf a dog sees two other dogs, one a potential mate and another a potential rival, doesn't it have to mentally manipulate representations of them? Isn't that a form of tokenisation? I suspect language is a communications layer built on top of a pre-existing mental framework of sensory experience, identification, memory, recognition, emotional responses, etc. The alternative is to suggest that humans developed an entirely novel way of representing, interacting with and responding to the world from scratch that just happens to emulate many of the experiences we see expressed by animals - excitement, fear, desire, recognition, problem solving, etc, but shares nothing in common with them.