3 ms·
But I can falsify the assumption about the effectiveness of oversight with cases from overreach that happened in the past. So oversight probably isn't effectiv
by raxxorrax 7y ago
But I can falsify the assumption about the effectiveness of oversight with cases from overreach that happened in the past.
So oversight probably isn't effective enough for agencies like the NSA and I am reliant on first hand information such as provided by Edward Snowden. Which have shown that it happened again.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoI'd say your very examples are proof that oversight does work, in general. And you are imposing your personal views on those doing the overseeing, namely the branches of government. From their point of view, such "overreaches" may not necessarily be that far. Also, the respective presidents didn't only know about the programs, they ordered them. And the oversight committees mostly new about that, also. I'm not saying that nothing went wrong, but the level of oversight in the US system of government does provide better "worst case" guarantees than in many other nations. And in the end, pretty much every significant wrong-doing seems to come to light, often through the political process or in case that is too slow, the media.