4 ms·
Isn't the practice of the NSA just plainly treason? And why would it not be?
by raxxorrax 7y ago
Isn't the practice of the NSA just plainly treason? And why would it not be?
- em3rgent0rdr 7y agoHypothetically, a benevolent NSA would primarily develop cryptographic security tools for the populace.
- raxxorrax 7y agoTrue. But besides their interest in acquiring exploits, I think their data collection seriously collides with peoples amendment rights against arbitrary state surveillance. I know there are some judges and institutions that enabled this madness, but I think they might be guilty as well. These judges should be accountable to the public in theory. I am not saying the everyone working at the NSA is a criminal. But maybe Snowden was the only one with perspective. The NSA as an institution certainly did more damage to the US than most of its enemies.
- Craighead 7y agoYou must not understand how cyber war works. The US has judges and legislation to enable the NSA. Russia, China, Iran, NK, and many other authoritarian states seek to use their power to attack America 24x7 and do so without any oversight.
- anilakar 7y agoA few countries actively try to hurt us, so let's spy on everyone, including our own citizens and allies!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 7y agoI am not disputing other countries to not have bad intentions, but as a justification to breaking the law, this seems to be a defense where the guilt has already been determined. Personally, I think the "cyber war" is the typical scare to reduce civil rights. That is a pretty common pattern to bolster and justify disregarding the law. In reality, the cyber war is probably still focused on the classical industrial espionage. I fail to see the need to subject citizens to mass surveillance.
- hos234 7y agoNot that I want to spend time defending the NSA, but back then collecting all data happened because it was the easiest thing to do, more as a reaction than an actual solution to certain threats. When society has no great way of preventing, let's say for example, the Boston Marathon bombing or the Las Vegas Concert shooting, providing an appearance of activity, however mindless, like a bunch of ants feverishly running around when a stone is thrown into the anthill, is just the default setting of the security establishment. You can't blame them for that because we aren't yet psychologically, socially or politically sophisticated enough to do anything better. But today after collecting and sitting on top of shitloads of useless data they themselves admit its unnecessary. You don't find who the best Tennis player in the neighborhood is by monitoring the entire neighborhoods conversations but by just watching the local tennis courts. What you can do is ask why it took so long, with that nudge from Snowden, for the establishment to admit this. That kind of questioning prevents them jumping into further "we can do it so lets do it" bullshit projects down the road.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIn fact, there is no clear indication that they did not act in what they perceived as the interest of the US and its citizens. Many would disagree with that perception, and I also believe that amount of surveillance to have been wrong and counterproductive, but there hasn't been any evidence or significant hints into possible corrupt motivations. One mustn't forget that all of this was put into motion after the 9/11 attacks, and both the Bush and Obama administrations where still working under (somewhat irrational) pressure from citizens afraid of a repeat performance.
- ncmncm 7y ago"They" is an expansive word. We could better say there is no indication that nobody who had access to illegally-obtained information misused it. We have plenty of evidence of cops misusing databases they have access to, and that stuff is way less juicy.
- oh_sigh 7y agoWouldn't those same tools make it easier for the baddies to do their bad things?
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoAh but they tried to, there's been proposals for cryptography that had NSA approved backdoors but they were never accepted or widely used. (IIRC / I believe)
- auiya 7y agoThey do. https://cryptome.org/2016/01/CNSA-Suite-and-Quantum-Computing-FAQ.pdf https://cryptome.org/2016/01/CNSA-Suite-and-Quantum-Computin...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoTypically you define treason in terms of the needs of the state, not the populace. You can come to your own conclusion how well the state interests align with its peoples’.
- freddie_mercury 7y agoNo, it isn't plainly treason. This is the definition of treason: Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court. Did the NSA levy war against the US? Did the NSA give aid & comfort to the enemies of the US?
- bayesian_horse 7y agoParticularly it has been ruled that "treason" as per the US constitution or laws is impossible unless war has been declared on a foreign nation.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMakes sense. So that means Snowden cannot be a traitor either or are there exceptions?
- bayesian_horse 7y agoNot in the criminal sense. He violated several laws around the general topic of national security, he made the work of US intelligence agencies harder and he did endanger US troops abroad. He also helped along Putin's general interest of destabilization. So colloquially, there may be a case to call him a "traitor". It's impossible to clear him from the accusation that he worked with/for a foreign government, maybe even before he fled to Russia. And at the current point in time, he wouldn't be able to refuse any request the Russian government made of him. He also featured in a fake "ask-me-anything" with Putin, just to make that point.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMy initial statement was nothing else as colloquial and should be regarded as such of course. I would say implementing mass surveillance would equally make it impossible to clear the NSA from such accusation.
- maze-le 7y agoDo you really want to think and judge people/institutions in these terms (traitor/non-traitor etc.)? I doubt this is in any way helpful to find a political solution. I know that this is being done with Snowden -- but lets not resort to this level of (hyperbole) accusation -- else the sanke pit is open to everyone to be define the other side as "traitor" in one way or another.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt could be argued unconstitutional, under the 4th amendment. But so far as I know, no one's brought a case against the NSA to the Supreme Court.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIt's quite common to confuse breaking laws with treason, but that just isn't the same. Accusations of treason at every corner hinder rational democratic discourse.
- narrator 7y agoWhat if Snowden was a deep state pawn sent to take down the NSA, or at least give other agencies total control over it? It is holding the crown jewels after all. The rabbit hole on this one is extremely deep. Hint: What agency did Snowden work for before the NSA?
- ncmncm 7y agoIt doesn't matter if he was put up to it. The facts are the same. That criminal misuses of the data were not also exposed suggests that he knew what line not to cross.