6 ms·
Putting Victimhood Behind You
- algaeontoast 7y agoI think a lot of the rhetoric in this article could also be applied to people who struggled in school early on due to an unknown mental health diagnosis, essentially internalizing that they’re either too stupid or lazy to succeed. As someone who had great parents, but parents who denied mental health as an issue or excessively large tonsils as a trigger for sleep apnea and behavioral issues a lot in this article resonates. Especially given my experience finally seeking professional help after college and realizing that a lot of why I’d been struggling was because of ADHD likely caused by sleep apnea caused by my tonsils. Seeing this drastic change in mood and my mental ability was life changing, but to this day sometimes I still catch myself re-itorating the words of my HS guidance counselor telling me I didn’t have the grades to study at an elite college or to be an engineer.
- dfsegoat 7y agoLifelong ADDer here. Yes, the damage of lifelong undiagnosed mental / attentional issues is absolutely a real and crippling thing. You HAVE to break those patterns and the negative self-talk. Cognitive behavioral therapy is helpful for this. Probably the biggest thing I've found helpful was David Goggins book "Can't hurt me: Master your mind and defy the odds". [1]: >>"For David Goggins, childhood was a nightmare — poverty, prejudice, and physical abuse colored his days and haunted his nights. But through self-discipline, mental toughness, and hard work, Goggins transformed himself from a depressed, overweight young man with no future into a U.S. Armed Forces icon and one of the world's top endurance athletes..." The audible version is PHENOMENAL IMO. He talks explicitly about learning disabilities and attentional issues - but be-forewarned his language is very raw, but it is 100% authentic. 1 - https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41721428-can-t-hurt-me https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41721428-can-t-hurt-me
- jigglesniggle 7y agoThis is kind of dangerous. The article is basically saying you should not demand more of society. I had problems in school and everyone brushed me off -- am I not right to be angry? Am I not right to demand I get the same consideration that others got? What do I need to do to do it, get back into school, and get the same free money?
- corodra 7y agoWell, let's put it this way. Being a Polish-Jew in a rural, and very southern high school in Florida, one where I was considered a minority because there were no other minorities, wasn't all roses. Then when it came to being a white male applying for scholarships. More than half of those scholarship books pretty much told me that I need not apply. My post high school education is quite lacking because of it. It took me a while in my 20s to realize how much of a benefit all of that was. And to quit being angry. Compared to all my peers from high school, I have a pretty damn good amount of resiliency. There's already a few known suicides in my graduating class, post-graduating. Plenty of drug addiction. Only a few folks really escaped like I did. But even them, when I touched based with them, it's all doom and gloom. In my early 20s, I faced an eviction, plenty of debt, debt collectors and lots of other problems that, well, never crushed me. Honestly, a lot of problems I shrugged off and found solutions. I think the worst thing that's ever affected me was my cats dying a few months ago. That, honestly, was the worst thing that happened to me, even though I was homeless for a while, couldn't find work, scrapped to pay for food. I could do all that again if I have to. Losing a pet... that hurts. But that brings me to the next, and I think biggest benefit from all those problems from school. I have a "sixth sense" on people's intentions. Just a gut reaction that's been correct every time. You have no idea how beneficial this has been since I went into business for myself. It also means, I have zero tolerance for assholes and incompetence. The time I save from wasting time on assholes, I spend on my real friends. I value my real friends and have tight relationships with them. Something my generation really doesn't have. Now, I am abrasive to people the moment I realize someone is underhanded, a user, asshole, etc. Even if they're mostly strangers and it's only been 5 minutes since I met them. But my friends are fully aware that I'm loyal, without end, to them. And thus far, every time I ignored that gut feeling on someone being bad, it always bit me in the ass. If I listened, I would find out from someone else a few months later on what bullet I just dodged. At the end, the world truly owes you nothing. Having a rough life is actually a blessing. It builds resilience and teaches you to greater appreciate the good and not focus on the toxic. Without experiencing hate, you can't truly love. Plus, you can't blame the entire world population over what a group of teenagers did. The older you get, the more you realize all teens, all over the world, are an equal amount of stupid.
- uwuhn 7y agoI got my tonsils removed in high school and it was life-changing. I didn't have oversized tonsils, but I would get tonsilitis 2-3 times a year.
- vivekd 7y agoI think what she is saying is true, unfortunately the article is a bit shallow. I went into this article looking for examples of behaviours that mark people for victimization and strategies for changing those behaviours. I didn't find any, and despite searching I have yet to find a good guide to this anywhere. There seems to be a vauge grey line between being properly assertive and being selfish or being a jerk. Finding the proper assertive behavior is especially a challenge for people who grew up in abusive circumstances and don't know proper boundaries.
- throwanem 7y agoThe links in the article (near the top, 3rd paragraph?) address the concern you raise about identifying frequently targeted behaviors and learning how to change them. It's a good question to ask! The answers I saw in those links accord with my experience, for whatever that's worth. Speaking from that same experience, you're right that the border between assertiveness and assholishness is not clearly marked, not least because all people and situations are to at least some extent unique. I can recommend only cautious experiment as a means of developing an understanding of how to be assertive without being a dick.
- l_t 7y agoWhat follows is my personal opinion. (Disclaimer, I'm a guy and I've not been abused, but I have had to deal with troublesome people and as a confrontation-avoidant person I've worked out some strategies for dealing with that. These strategies are more oriented towards avoiding panhandlers than avoiding abusers, but perhaps they can be useful.) First, the interesting thing about "being selfish" and "being assertive" is that they actually overlap. If someone tells you that you're being selfish like it's a bad thing, that person is probably trying to manipulate you. They want you to stop being selfish so they can be selfish. This is literally how they try to get their way. Another way to think about it is that "assertiveness" comes into play when there is a conflict of interest. You want X, the other party wants Y. In this situation there's no way to satisfy both X and Y. At this point you can fight for what you think is right, or you can fold. The other people want you to fold, and if they're abusive, they're going to try and insult you or make you feel stupid until you do. Which brings me to some concrete recommendations for being "assertive:" 1. When walking, look like you have somewhere important to go. You're not meandering casually, you're walking with purpose. You're in charge. People are much less likely to approach you if it looks like you're going to turn them down immediately. 2. In conversation, use the "fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me" approach. Operate in good faith until you feel that good faith is being abused, then retract it. Don't be angry, but don't let it happen again. "Forgive, but don't forget." 3. Don't apologize for things you didn't do. If you are afraid and feel like you have to apologize, then do it verbally but don't believe it. Tell yourself that you're lying to this person about being sorry. You're not sorry. You're tricking them because they refuse to accept the truth. 4. Think about the reasons people say what they do. Words coming out of a mouth are like symptoms of the mental state of the person. Don't just take them at face value but ask yourself: "Why are they saying this?" 5. If possible, find people you trust who can be a sounding board. Especially if you think your own "assertiveness compass" is whack. Err on the rude side. Then literally describe your encounters to the trusted party afterwards and ask whether you were rude, so you can refine your social barometer. 6. Protect yourself! You're a living organism and you should be your number one priority. Nobody else has the right to make your decisions for you. Hopefully that's helpful to someone. But like I said, I'm coming at it from a bit of a different angle, so I welcome any feedback / questions.
- charliesharding 7y agoGreat article. I wonder if different people respond to this kind of a message differently though.. I firmly believe in taking personal responsibility for my behaviors and my actions - however I think that is because I'm inherently wired to avoid responsibility and try to find the easy way out. Because of this, the only conscious way for me to effect positive change in my life is to strive for taking responsibility and ditching thoughts of victimhood. On the other hand, I've known people who seem to be hardwired for responsibility so much that it is overwhelming for them and causes all kinds of anxiety (control issues). For these people, would it be beneficial to use that conscious effort on relinquishing control and adopting more of a "victim" mindset?
- throwanem 7y agoFor those people, it might be beneficial to recognize that they are not God, and there's only so much that it's reasonable for them to expect themselves to control. - that, and that sometimes you can do everything right and still lose. "Ditching thoughts of victimhood" can be taken to the sort of extreme that your last question hints toward. People who have been abused learn a variety of coping strategies, one of which is the specialization of apophenia that leads us to imagine that our actions and those of our abusers are meaningfully linked: "if I do X, Y happens; if I don't do Z, A happens". That easily lends itself to believing that, because I did X, I had Y coming - a belief that abusers, for obvious reasons, encourage. Discarding that is part of recovery, and for that reason, I'd hesitate to give advice like yours to someone early in that process, who may well still be in the habit of blaming themself for someone else's behavior.
- jonfw 7y agoFor self responsibility to work, you obviously can only accept responsibility for things under your control. If you are taking responsibility for things outside of your control, I think the more appropriate solution is to learn some humility, rather than to adopt a "victim" mindset.
- ljm 7y agoIf you look at Karpman’s Drama Triangle, you’ll wonder just how many people fall into the ‘rescuer’ corner, and further than that, how you might get the saviour complex from it. Just as you say, the response there isn’t to switch to the victim or even the persecutor. The response is to break out of it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karpman_drama_triangle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karpman_drama_triangle
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoIt's a real shame how difficult politeness and sorta-kinda-deference can be to decouple. I'm super confrontation avoidant. It's a problem I work on, but I want to be kind and respectful and liked, so I'll go along with a lot. Being kind and respectful and liked and saying a solid no is really hard. Even sacrificing those to say a solid no is hard. Weird how difficult it is personally to reprogram. Props to the OP for growing.
- vorpalhex 7y agoIf people don't like you when you politely refuse them, they don't actually like you, they like for what they get from you. A great test of friendship is to refuse someone for a simple thing, politely. A good friend will dismiss the matter and move on with no hurt feelings or issue.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoAgreed, and yet that knowledge doesn't make it that much easier. For example, if it's a project at work where we're trying to agree on direction, consensus must be built. Saying "no I disagree with that decision" (or that interpretation of an analysis or whatever) is quite difficult. When performance review time comes around, I get the feedback that I should speak up more since people value my opinion. And when I do speak up, it's well received, and we always have polite constructive discussions and everyone's happier for it, even when it ends up with "agree to disagree." It's kinda the ideal scenario and yet it still takes such a huge emotional toll.
- vorpalhex 7y agoI've noticed amongst some of my friends with similar issues that they see disagreeing as being a kind of harm. That to make someone uncomfortable or upset is as bad as kicking them in the shin or yelling at them. You can't feed a child nothing but candy. Candy is delicious and great, I love candy, but it's just sugar. To merely agree with someone all the same is to both undervalue their agency (what makes them human, their ability to engage critically and freely with new information) and over-value the norm. In other words, to agree with someone all the time is to give them nothing but sugar candy. That's not license to yell or be a jerk. Please don't go around trodding on people and calling them sheeple. But do disagree with people because it both helps you and betters them. To engage with opinions we don't have, to consume information we don't like is the intellectual equivalent of eating your vegetables.
- dundercoder 7y agoThis reminds me of this good article as well. Confusing kindness with being polite/nice. https://www.outsideonline.com/2241096/how-teach-girls-they-dont-have-be-nice https://www.outsideonline.com/2241096/how-teach-girls-they-d...
- elil17 7y agoIt’s obvious that this article is immensely helpful for anyone as an individual, but it also address the larger problem. My understanding, from my own life and what I’ve read, is that almost all abusers were themselves abused. Preventing someone from being serially abused, even if it doesn’t deal with abusers immediately, leads to a reduction of abusive people in the future.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm the author of the piece. That's exactly why I blog about the things I do. People who have really had something terrible happen need a way out and it's typically very problematic for others to reach out to try to help them. It's problematic because helping someone can set up a situation where they expect you to keep helping and others may agree that you "owe" them. Giving once can become a trap where they keep making demands and you don't know how to extract yourself, so best to just not help. And if you help people based on their sob story, then they don't learn to be productive members of society. Instead, they learn to be con artists who extract money based on pity because, hey, that works and they need to eat. It's maddening for me because I've tried to figure out how to earn my way and there seems to be no way to get taken seriously for that. There seems to be no way to convince people I merit an adequate earned income. I'm viewed as a "charity case," which isn't a nice thing to say about someone. But, yes, we need to find ways to help people actually escape such, if only because the alternative is the Prison-Industrial Complex and other very broken models that do not constitute a healthy society.
- throwanem 7y agoI don't know if I'd agree that it's best to just not help. I've been in situations like the one you describe, especially with regard to monetary help, and found that it isn't really all that hard to disengage if that becomes necessary. I start that process with what some might call a "come to Jesus" talk, where I explain that I can't just keep giving money away to what looks like no good end, and lay out what I need to see - concrete steps toward leaving an abuser, getting treatment for substance issues, whatever - before I'll be willing to consider doing so again. Where I can, I offer resources that might help, even if that's just best guesses - which is all too often the case, our society mostly sucks at helping anyone who really needs it - but I offer whatever I can. After that, I just say no or don't respond, unless I see what I said I needed to. I mean, yeah, it sucks to have to do, but you're not wrong that some people will just bleed you dry if you let them. Some won't, though, and in my opinion they're worth taking the risk, because sometimes all someone needs really is just a hand up to where they can start climbing out of a hole on their own.
- dlphn___xyz 7y agoi hate seeing these things on HN...its another side effect of our manic PC culture
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIn the list of articles, each entry is really concise. It's really easy to just ignore the ones you aren't interested in.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- v64 7y agoI think this article is arguing for the opposite, taking personal responsibility for your future. In PC culture, victimhood is somewhat idealized and the goal is to make demands of others as compensation.
- StellarTabi 7y ago> In PC culture, victimhood is somewhat idealized I don't even think this is true. It sounds like a strawman used to deny and vilify actual victims.
- v64 7y agoIt's important to make a distinction between actual victims and those who participate in victimhood culture. A good example of victimhood culture which has made national headlines is actor Jussie Smollett's staged assault. [1] In order to make a political point, he went out of his way to make himself out to be a victim, because he knew portraying himself as such would get him positive attention from the media (and it did at first before the fraud was revealed). The criticism is not toward actual victims, but those who fabricate or exaggerate their experiences in order to participate in victimhood. The latter group is partly responsible for the former group being unfairly denied and vilified. Edit: This sociology article [2] differentiates the two in the context of microaggressions, as summarized in Wikipedia [3]: > Campbell and Manning argue that accusations of microaggression focus on unintentional slights, unlike the Civil rights movement, which focused on concrete injustices. They argue that the purpose of calling attention to microaggressions is less to elevate the status of offended victim. "When the victims publicize microaggressions,” wrote Campbell and Manning “they call attention to what they see as the deviant behavior of the offenders. In doing so,” they “also call attention to their own victimization.” They do this because it lowers “the offender’s moral status” and “raises the moral status of the victims.” [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jussie_Smollett_alleged_assault https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jussie_Smollett_alleged_assaul... [2] https://brill.com/configurable/contentpage/journals$002fcoso$002f13$002f6$002farticle-p692_2.xml https://brill.com/configurable/contentpage/journals$002fcoso... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_Victimhood_Culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_Victimhood_Culture
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]