6 ms·
That's what we thought 20 years ago during the "peak oil" nonsense and they just invented fracking. Talking about oil "reserves" paints a picture that petroleu
by ajross 7y ago
That's what we thought 20 years ago during the "peak oil" nonsense and they just invented fracking. Talking about oil "reserves" paints a picture that petroleum extraction is like just scooping sludge out of a big underground bucket. Real deposits come in a huge variety of forms and qualities, and extracting them sits on a cost spectrum. All making oil more expensive does is make the more expensive oil worth extracting, prices stabilize at a slightly higher point and the market adapts.
Unfortunately we aren't going to run out of oil anywhere near soon enough to save the planet. We need to do it the hard way.
- ed312 7y agoHowever the costs of renewable tech is coming down - at some point it's just a better business decision to switch off oil.
- ajross 7y agoExactly. Which is the "hard way". We need to win this with technology and, where technology alone isn't enough, with government action to curtail emissions. We aren't going to get lucky and run out of oil.
- acchow 7y ago> prices stabilize at a slightly higher point Which encourages renewable development. Renewables would not be as successful today with oil at $20/bbl.
- fooblitzky 7y agoRenewables would be ahead on cost down to USD 9-10/barrel: https://investors-corner.bnpparibas-am.com/investment-themes/sri/petrol-eroci-petroleum-age/ https://investors-corner.bnpparibas-am.com/investment-themes...
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago"Competitive" is a curve, not a point. Solar can be cheaper for daytime generation before it's cheaper for nighttime generation (when you need to tack on the cost of storage). Electric cars may already have a lower TCO, but if you already have an ICE car, it may not be worth the transaction costs of immediately selling it and buying an electric car instead of waiting until you would have bought a new car anyway, whereas it could be if gas prices were higher. The TCO is also affected by how much you drive, so the gas price that justifies replacing your car depends on how much you drive it. There isn't a price level where $0.01 below it no one can justify buying an electric car and $0.01 above it everyone can. The higher oil prices get, the more people end up on the other side of the line.
- disjhshava 7y agoI'm really skeptical of lower TCO for electric cars. My gasoline-powered car is worth $5k. All electric cars with decent range cost more in depreciation alone than my TCO. I think in a few years a Bolt will have a competitive TCO, and maybe a Model 3 will a few years after that.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou're comparing the TCO of a new electric car to a used gasoline car. We all know that used cars have a lower TCO than new ones in general. Nobody is going to crush a perfectly operational two year old gasoline car just because of higher gas prices (though that would obviously cause it to suffer higher depreciation due to the loss in resale value). The real question is, as the old cars become unreliable and age out of service, how does the TCO compare as between the new cars that will replace them?
- disjhshava 7y agoI'm comparing the TCO of a good value gasoline car to the best value electric car available (including used models). If you have a ton of disposable income, buying a Tesla could be a good decision, but very few people are in that position. Since we are taking about TCO, I assume we are talking about a financially literate purchaser. I fully expect that electric cars will have a reasonable TCO in the future.
- acqq 7y ago> All making oil more expensive does is make the more expensive oil worth extracting, prices stabilize at a slightly higher point and the market adapts. For traders, at exactly which point matters a lot. > Unfortunately we aren't going to run out of oil anywhere near soon enough to save the planet. Yes, it's probably a good estimate: It doesn't mean that we won't achieve the "peak" in some decades, eventually even "more expensive" options will be used up, just that that won't prevent having much more CO2 than now.
- BlueTemplar 7y ago"Some decades" ? Last time I checked, Laherrere predicted peak conventional + unconventional for 2019 ? (There's always the political uncertainties of course, especially in the Middle East!)
- acqq 7y agoThe latest I was able to find from Laherrere is: https://aspofrance.files.wordpress.com/2018/08/35cooilforecast.pdf https://aspofrance.files.wordpress.com/2018/08/35cooilforeca... "The main conclusion of this study is this from 2018: -only 6 countries have not yet reached peak: Brazil, Canada oilsands, Kazakhstan, Iraq, UAE, Venezuela Orinoco -19 countries (out of 35) have or will have a decline rate of 5 %/a It means that, excluding the 6 countries before peak, the best and the simplest way to forecast future production is to decrease present production by 5 % per year" "6 countries have not yet reached peak" and "excluding the 6 countries" surely doesn't sound like "peak" everywhere. So yes, it seems that, at longest, in "some" decades the global peak will do happen. Laherrere also documents why the exact predictions are hard (see all the graphs there). My point is more, whoever thinks that "scientists will always find something" surely thinks in short enough frames. There is a finite amount of fossil fuel material on Earth.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- okcando 7y agoPeak oil isn't nonsense. Predictions about when are often wrong but the idea is sound. And it never meant running out. It's exactly what it says on the tin: a peak and a probably very long tail of decline.
- philipkglass 7y agoThere is "peak oil" as the basic geophysical concept, which is perfectly fine. There is also "peak oil" as the prophecy of imminent collapse of industrial civilization, which was a much bigger thing a decade or so ago. It may still have some loyal believers. I think that people unfortunately have the means to extract far more oil than we have the means to safely burn in Earth's atmosphere.
- pault 7y agoI can confirm. My mom is susceptible to internet fear mongering and got on some "peak oil" forums back around 2005. Many of them wanted you to believe that things were going to spiral out of control and that rioting and food shortages were imminent. Of course they could go back and say that they never said that explicitly, but the implication was there and it was clearly meant to scare the shit out of you. It seems that there's a certain type of person that secretly wants society to fall apart because they think it will solve all of their social and financial problems. I'm not sure they've thought it through very well.
- stale2002 7y agoWell, there is an alternative. You are talking about peak oil supply. Instead, what if we run into peak oil demand. IE, instead of running out of oil, we run out of oil demand, as everyone moves away from oil onto better technologies.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoNot likely to happen as we don't have better technologies, and now no time left to develop and especially build the infrastructure for them...
- logfromblammo 7y agoI think maybe the hard way will be gene-edited phytoplankton and overcoming efficiency bottlenecks in photosynthesis, such as by introducing bacterical carboxysomes into plants to make RuBisCO more efficient, or by making plants use C3 in the midday leaves higher on the plant and C4 everywhere else, or by replacing chlorophylls with versions that respond to different wavelengths of light.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThe peak of the peak oil scare was 40 years ago (given that the peak was scheduled for the mid 70s), not 20. This is actually the first time I’ve heard of there being another scare 20 years ago. For example, Mad Max in 1979 comes from that sentiment.
- oil-crisis 7y agoI think the Carter administration's incident in the late 1970's is more accurately characterized as an "oil crisis" because there were real shortages, serious enough to alter trends in car purchasing habits, warranting economy automobile redesigns (smaller, lighter, more efficient, no more muscle cars). Gas stations actually ran out of gas, resulting in hours long waits on miles long lines, and theft by siphoning forcing the introduction of keyed locks on gas tanks. These were real problems people faced, although it wasn't exactly a full panic. Oil "scares" on the other hand were threats that raised eyebrows, and caused dramatic price fluctuations in anticipation potential problems. Each "scare" really only hit the wallet and bank account, without altering real behavior. In that sense, yes, there were a few other "scares" between Jimmy Carter and present day. Each grouping came periodically, maybe every ten years. Almost all of them were tied to Iraq. The first was the invasion of Kuwait in 1991. I think gas prices blew past $2/gallon for the first time. The second was 9/11, and $4/gallon gas starting late 2001. This one was rough. Pretty much everyone I knew was groaning about gas prices, and with Iraq invasion rumors people started thinking $5 would break them. The 2003 Iraq invasion actually resulted in a downward trend (due to international theft or spoils), but it's ever been below $2 again, and it's been back up to $4 at the pump, here and there, depending on geographic region and state taxes, here and there. With the 2008 meltdown, oil prices weren't displaying any gouging, and there wasn't much of a scare at the 2001 decade mark, because as others have mentioned, fracking has buoyed domestic production.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoPetrol is still cheap when inflation is considered (consider $1 in 1984 is $2.40 in 2018). Also, the first oil shock occurred during Nixon (with a second one under Carter).
- 7y ago