9 ms·
> but I predict WeWork is still going to be around in another decade. There's clearly a ton of demand for what they provide There's also a TON of rent-a-desk p
by gwbas1c 7y ago
> but I predict WeWork is still going to be around in another decade. There's clearly a ton of demand for what they provide
There's also a TON of rent-a-desk places.
The big questions are:
- What's the benefit to a large corporation doing this instead of lots of small companies? (The economies of scale need to outweigh the large corporate overhead.)
- What's WeWork's secret sauce or first mover advantage?
- seisvelas 7y agoThe advantage is similar to that of a large gym chain - you can pay more to get a membership that's valid at all the WeWorks in the entire world. This is great for people who regularly travel between many large cities.
- cj 7y agoI suspect the majority of WeWork's revenue comes from people working in the same location day in, day out. Same with gym chains. People sign up for Planet Fitness because the nearest location is the most convenient, not because they plan to visit multiple locations over the course of a year (not to say there aren't people taking advantage of the multi-city aspect, just that they aren't the typical customer).
- jjeaff 7y agoYa, I can't imagine that is really a draw at all. If you travel a lot, you will have an office in your hotel room or can use the business center in the hotel.
- MrFantastic 7y agoIt would be more impressive to meet a client at a WeWork office.
- goatinaboat 7y agoNot sure what industry you’re in but I don’t think most people’s clients think like that.
- nradov 7y agoIf you're travelling you're probably meeting the client at their office.
- lancesells 7y agoI get your point and agree but I think gyms make money from people not being there at all. If every gym member showed up multiple times a week it would be like going to the gym the week after New Year's.
- vinay_ys 7y agoWeWork may soon be headed the way of Gym's business model which is to oversubscribe like crazy assuming not everyone will show up at the same time and many will not show up at all. When that happens, I wonder what happens to NPS. How many people will be a WeWork member (like their gym membership) but don't really need/want to use it?
- cj 7y agoThe answer to that question is already answered by looking at existing coworking spaces. WeWork isn't doing anything different. Existing coworking spaces already make lots of money off of people who don't fully utilize their membership (which isn't necessarily a bad thing). WeWork is no different.
- cj 7y ago>What's the benefit to a large corporation doing this instead of lots of small companies? (The economies of scale need to outweigh the large corporate overhead.) I like this way of thinking. WeWork isn't doing anything "new" - coworking spaces have existed for years. What's the upside of having a giant corporation owning all coworking spaces, versus having many small and independent small businesses running and operating independent coworking spaces? The answer to this question isn't obvious to me. WeWork is also very similar to Uber in the sense that you also need a very effective "on the ground" team managing operations of each individual location, doing tours for prospective renters, managing upkeep + maintenance for the space, etc.
- munificent 7y ago> What's the upside of having a giant corporation owning all coworking spaces, versus having many small and independent small businesses running and operating independent coworking spaces? Advantage to customers? Likely minimal. Advantage to the company itself: economies of scale and, likely more importantly, lack of competition allowing them to increase prices. The very clear trend across all sectors is that companies trend towards giant monopolistic behemoths unless some very strong regulatory force prevents it. People act like healthy, competitive, transparent markets just appear out of thin air, but they are an artificial creation of government.
- jen20 7y agoThe advantage to me with Spaces (which I believe is owned by Regus) is that I can do guest co-working in any city they happen to be present - and since I travel extensively, the bigger the network the better, as far as I'm concerned. Sadly WeWork do not appear to offer this option (or didn't last time I looked).
- ageitgey 7y agoWeWork offers this if you sign up for an American Express Platinum Business card and take advantage of the free year of WeWork benefit. I can (and do!) book any WeWork in the world any day - all for $0. Yes, that's right, the free AMEX WeWork plan is significantly better than any WeWork plan you can buy. That's start-up logic for you. I stopped paying WeWork after 1-2 years as a paying customer because their free plan was better. I live in London and I can choose from any of 36 WeWork London locations for tomorrow along with anywhere else in the world. It's nice living off of VC money.
- david-cako 7y agoAnother value of their large network, WeWork has relationships with large companies (like Amazon) to manage satellite offices across the country. Some of those are just a corner of a WeWork carved out, and some of those are entire floors of office buildings that WeWork handles administrative, custodial, and break room for. I don’t know how much that impacts their profitability or value as a company, but it feels like a very cloud computing model of work space where you get what you need where you need it, so that you can have local employees in cities across the country to serve customers there.
- klodolph 7y ago> What's the benefit to a large corporation doing this instead of lots of small companies? From what I understand, WeWork is structured as many small companies, so they can negotiate favorable terms with long-term leases on office space and the smaller company can fail without leaving WeWork on the hook for the rest of the lease.
- scott_s 7y agoIn addition to the advantages others listed, I think a big advantage of a large corporation is risk management. If you're a "small" company managing a handful of buildings, and something catastrophic happens to one of those buildings, that could threaten the company's existence. More so if those handful of buildings are in the same city, and all suffer from the same event (flood, hurricane, earthquake, etc.). A large company managing hundreds of buildings spread across the entire country would more likely be able to handle a one-building catastrophe.
- jakoblorz 7y agoBut that doesn’t prevent small companies to just take the risk. And by doing so, they are as efficient as WeWork and compete on the same level. What counts is the product and that is the same from the small and big company.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIn fact small firms may be more efficient. If they make a bad bet on some real estate they fold while WeWork has to spread that cost to all of its users and keep on moving.
- rurp 7y agoI agree with your general point, but in the specific case of WeWork the benefit has to be tempered to a large degree by the fact that they are losing obscene amounts of money. They are definitely not running as a sustainable business right now and, while they might make it work long term, but I doubt many people will be shocked if WeWork doesn't exist in 5 years.
- pbreit 7y agoI’m not sure exactly what the secret sauce is but it’s undeniable that WeWork has a large supply of it.
- keerthiko 7y ago> - What's WeWork's secret sauce or first mover advantage? Softbank $$$
- byeadam 7y ago> Softbank $$$ And that not so much anymore. All they had was a cannabilized version of Meetup.com for doing reservations.
- austhrow743 7y agoSame reason I often eat at mcdonalds. Consistency. I know what I'm going to get.
- iamsb 7y ago> What's the benefit to a large corporation doing this instead of lots of small companies? (The economies of scale need to outweigh the large corporate overhead.) Same answer in case of gyms. Your advertising overhead does not scale linearly as you grow. Once you build a brand. Customer acquisition costs go down. For moving workforces - entrepreneurs, sales, executives - it becomes more affordable to use one brand rather than plenty of smaller brands.