3 ms·
Ok, I will bite. I just doubt the relevancy of the Russian propaganda story. If propaganda has been induced in social networks, there should be evidence about t
by raxxorrax 7y ago
Ok, I will bite. I just doubt the relevancy of the Russian propaganda story. If propaganda has been induced in social networks, there should be evidence about that. Also estimates about the reach of these measures. Again, I would be surprised if there hadn't been such efforts at all, but to counter them, it should be imperative to identify and reveal the messages in question. Since that hasn't happened at all, I just think people voted differently for their own reasons. The media had ample criticism of Trump for months on end. All that should have been outplayed by a secret Russian media campaign, for which there still isn't evidence besides of statements of intelligence agencies? Very doubtful in my opinion, especially since effords to create this narrative have been revealed.
On the other hand it would be quite understandable that people might get a little angry if they are told they just hold opinions because of Russia while subjected to all those nagging categorical imperatives that were common in the race before the election. The Russian story just doesn't make sense in the end, not because they wouldn't want to have that level of influence or from a lack of trying. But you could also have the view that executive organs have misbehaved in front of their own constitution. That is far more probable in my opinion.
- simonh 7y ago>If propaganda has been induced in social networks, there should be evidence about that. There's tons of evidence of that, provided by both Facebook and Twitter. They did the same here in the UK. https://www.vox.com/2018/10/19/17990946/twitter-russian-trolls-bots-election-tampering https://www.vox.com/2018/10/19/17990946/twitter-russian-trol... https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-46590890 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-46590890 However I do not believe the Russian propaganda was decisive in the election. Like most such propaganda it just went into the wash, but it did happen and did have an effect, not so much swaying the vote one way or the other but in terms of polarising opinion and poisoning the debate. An attempt to sway opinion would be aimed at the centre, where the swing voters are. Russian propaganda is aimed squarely at the left and right wings trying to push them further apart.
- mistermann 7y agoFrom your first link: "Twitter announced that all the tweets it was releasing had come from “3,841 accounts affiliated with the IRA [Internet Research Agency], originating in Russia..." This phrase "affiliated with" is interesting. I happen to have spent many hours following the string of unequivocally stated facts behind this story, particularly the Twitter based one. I have yet to find any claim on behalf of Twitter that these accounts _were_ Russian, as is reported in the media. The original and only unequivocal statement I have found from Twitter is that the accounts are _suspected to be_ Russian (based on I believe 3 attributes, each of which is spoofable). Have you read anything more specific than I have, that you could provide a link to?