7 ms·
If the political system in China collapses everyone should worry. That would likely result in a global economic crash the likes of which the world has never see
by onion2k 7y ago
If the political system in China collapses everyone should worry. That would likely result in a global economic crash the likes of which the world has never seen.
- stretchwithme 7y agoIf he's not careful, REAL communists might overthrow the government. Just kidding. Only people in countries that have been spared its horrors still believe in communism.
- anm89 7y agoI wish I could upvote more than once.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoPeople that have survived communism just accept high levels of corruption because it's better than the alternative. That's why Putin is popular.
- ajsnigrutin 7y agoPutin is popular, because he's better than what was before (i'm speaking mostly of the old drunk). And also because he does stuff that a lot of russians actually like. A lot of people (mostly westeners) don't understand, that if someone gets back "historic russian territory" from a "neighbor" you don't really like, and noone can do anything about that, that's a good thing for Russia. It's bad for the neighbors, it's bad for NATO, it's bad for everyone else who wants to influece Russia, but for Russia, it's a good thing. It's the same thing with Trump... he does this, he does that, outrage everywhere, and in the end, EU is even more fuc*ed, Chinese send threats but can't do anything, and USA gets richer, old industries come back, people get jobs, get paid more, etc. And some wonder why he won.
- jaynetics 7y ago"but for Russia, it's a good thing." Are you sure? Haven't the resulting sanctions damaged Russia's economic growth and increased prices for consumers? I can see the geo-strategic value of Crimea, but for the ordinary Russian citizen, where is the positive effect?
- puranjay 7y agoYou have to understand that democracy, even the idea of it, is not native at all to Russians. I was there earlier in June. What struck me the most was how much reverence the Russians still have for all their erstwhile Soviet era dictators (Lenin and Stalin in particular). The former Tsars are particularly venerated. The Russian people called Tsar Nicholas "little father". The assassination was an anomaly; the revolutionaries had to work very hard to hide the bodies because they feared the people would start worshipping the dead Tsars (which is exactly what's happening today). Even with religion, 70 years of Soviet oppression and Russia is now as religious as ever. So when you criticize Putin for crushing dissent, you have to understand that what might be oppression to us is perfectly normal for Russian people. At this point, I have to ask: why do we assume that we know what's better for Russians (or any other nationality) than the Russians themselves?
- StudentStuff 7y agoCitation for that last paragraph? All I've seen is a shrinking coal industry leaving workers unpaid for their last month on the job[1], 25% tariffs slapped on our hardware imports [2] (causing a 30% drop in our sales) and kids being killed by Customs and Border Protection [3]. None of this is good for the USA or my fellow American 1 - https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/19/us/kentucky-coal-miners.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/19/us/kentucky-coal-miners.h... 2 - https://www.forbes.com/sites/sap/2019/08/07/the-long-term-impact-of-us-tariffs-on-china/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/sap/2019/08/07/the-long-term-im... 3 - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/20/migrant-child-death-us-border-control-latest https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/20/migrant-chil...
- codeisawesome 7y ago
- varjag 7y agoDo dictators have to eradicate every slight manifestation of dissent and turn elections into rigged cargo cult shows because they are so popular?
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIt's subtle, but no, Putin isn't popular in the way freely elected leaders are. He's only preferable to the alternative.
- varjag 7y agoWho is the alternative?
- NicoJuicy 7y agoWas popular, a lot of protests happening this year.
- pandapower2 7y agoActually, true believers are a legitimate problem for the CCP https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/28/world/asia/china-maoists-xi-protests.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/28/world/asia/china-maoists-...
- devoply 7y agoWe have real Communists everywhere, they are called corporations, most people work for such government where once inside they are a number and a cog in a machine that tells them to cooperate and not compete. It was a stupid idea to take this corporate model and try to implement it on the scale of national governance and there is no fitness function to terminate it if it's not working as expected, i.e. everyone is not being a good Communist. You want real Communism simply install unions into any existing corporation and make all employees into shareholders, instant Communism.
- friendlybus 7y agoI don't understand what you mean. Corporations as a legal structure are built to compete & live or die, governments are not. The point of having political power is to control it for the sake of prosperity. Having a 'death clause' in your government worker's performance would mean you've failed as a political actor to get enough control to guarantee prosperity. That's a bigger threat to the gov than having useless employees. Controlled incompetence, plausible deniability, ect are all useful political tools. Not always needed, but they are still useful tools. If you want a 'communist corporation', just give every employee shares. You don't need unions or whatever else. You could start a company right now that does that. Some big UK firms do a performance sharing scheme with everybody in the company, even cashiers. Granted it's not much money in real terms, but it's proof how flexible the corporate legal structure can be.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> If you want a 'communist corporation', just give every employee shares Co-operatives in this form aren’t communist. They compete for members, vendors and customers. They don’t have a monopoly on violence. They can be held accountable by the rule of law. None of the above apply to communist governments. They have a monopoly on violence and the factors of production. That precludes an independent check on state power which, in turn, precludes the rule of law.
- friendlybus 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sgjohnson 7y agoYou joke, but CCP is Communist in the name only. I wouldn’t be surprised if there are still some die hard communists around that’d love to seize the power.
- adam_ellsworth 7y agoHaving not studied economics/politics during my time in college, wow does one qualify "collapse" here? What are the properties?
- 88840-8855 7y agoDramatic political reforms, similar to what happened in 1991 when the Soviet Union "collapsed". Corruption would skyrocket, Oligarchs would emerge from the state owned enterprises, HK would declare independence, inner Mongolia, Tibet, Xinjiang, probably Yunnan would follow. Flows of money, including taxes, would be interrupted, people wont get paid. State owned enterprises would not be able to pay their people, the banking system would collapse (as all major banks are state owned - and dont forget, 5 of the 10 largest banks on this planet are Chinese). Shanghai Composite (their stock market index) would plummet. As there are many micro investors, this would radiate into the housing market. hundreds of Millions would lose their homes. Such a collapse would bring China back to the 1980s, increase poverty by hundreds of millions of people, disrupt global supply Chains (50% of the global electronics are shipped from the Pearl River Delta, 50% of all ACs and fridges are made there, Daimler, BMW and GM source 20-30% of their parts from China). Western factories would reduce production as parts are missing. Western companies that export to China would have to reduce output (Volkswagen, GM would have to cut production by 30-40%, Airbus and Boeing by 20-30%). Western stock markets plummet, housing crises emerge, poverty surges, unemployment increases dramatically. All in all, this would not be a great thing and a lose-lose situation. The Soviet Union was not integrated into the global value chains. China is. A collapse would make the 2008 crisis look like a cute little girl on a pink bicycle and bring the global economies back into the 1990s.
- jacobush 7y agoSo, you want war, or you want war? Nice choice we have.
- 88840-8855 7y agoI doubt that. People all around the globe want prosperity. Prosperity derives from an expanding economy. An economy can only grow if there is stability that allows to plan and forecast to allow efficient resource allocation and utilisation. War is chaos. War destroys supply chains. War is standing in direct contrast to planability. Nobody wants war. Just look at Russia and its behaviour after the collapse of the Soviet Union. 1991-2000 was pure shit: chaos, corruption, high suicide rates, absolute poverty where poor old Grandmas and Grandpas suffered and committed suicide as there was absolutely nothing. In the early 2000s reforms were made that brought certain stability back to the country. Unfortunately, the economy was depending on resource exploitation - and the government knew that ofc. They tried to open up and integrate themselves into the global economy, e.g. by suggestion to join the NATO (for more stability and less spending on the military) and to join the EU (for better integration into the European markets). The Western nations said no to both suggestions. This is where the wars began: Georgia, North Kaukasus, Ukraine and now Syria. My two cents: it was a huge bullshit made by the USA to 1) fuck the ex Soviet republics after the collapse in 91 - and yes, they had the option for a Marshall plan 2, and 2) to not integrate Russia into the Western military and economy. Shit for Russia, shit for the EU, shit for the US, shit for the global economy. Thanks again, USA.
- devoply 7y agoGood. The come up will be a lot sweeter.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIt won’t be good. China doesn’t have a good record on feeding its population during extreme situations.
- threeseed 7y agoSure. If you're middle/upper class living in a wealthy country. But for the poorest and most vulnerable in our society they will experience hardships not seen since the Great Recession. And the inequality gap will rapidly widen which affects everyone.
- devoply 7y agoI rather live in a world where the CCP failed and a bunch of poor people suffered than a world run by the CCP where 1/2 the world is at their mercy. America can be a tyrant but I believe the CCP would be much much worse.
- King-Aaron 7y ago> a bunch of poor people By that, you mean you are championing the potential mass starvation and violent deaths of hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of people.... cool
- devoply 7y ago> mass starvation and violent deaths of hundreds of thousands America in its reign is responsible for that itself, it's also saved hundreds of thousands if not millions. So it's nothing new. Mao killed millions, was no big thing, and the modern CCP thinks that he's the reason for China's eventual success. CCP around for a hundred or more years something similar is bound to happen, just see what they are doing the Uigurs. So yeah that sort of rhetoric really doesn't fly in the face of political reality where empires kill and starve millions without batting an eye. WWII killed 55 million, and I don't regret that it happened. I wish it didn't have to happen this way, but I don't see any other way to curtail CCP's growth or power... if this does not happen then the most likely outcome is CCP will be triumphant and control the significant portion of the world for many years during which it will exercise its power and cost many people their lives and freedom.
- missosoup 7y agoIf the alternative is China going unchecked and eating the world. I'll take the economic crash. I grew up in poverty and I'd rather go back to poverty than live under a dystopian surveillance dictatorship.
- onion2k 7y agoI'm not arguing in favor of the current Chinese regime, just that change should come somewhat more slowly than a collapse.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- spectramax 7y agoI want to imagine the world with China as a democracy only to assure the world that xenophobia is the first thing that comes to mind when people take an anti-China stance and as a reminder that Chinese culture, their arts, the land and the people are wonderful. I am against this dystopian overwhelmingly powerful and suppressive government. I imagine if 1989 was a turning moment for Democracy in China.
- missosoup 7y agoThe wonderful culture and arts you're thinking about is historical. It doesn't really exist in China now. It was mostly wiped out during The Great Leap Forward, along with 30 million people give or take. Fun fact: advanced Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioners travel from China to Japan to learn. Japan preserved records of the TCM knowledge that China destroyed during the great leap.
- WanderPanda 7y agoAs well as many of their people...
- powerapple 7y agoNot they preserve Chinese artifacts. China has been invaded so many times, the collapse of governments had led foreigners to scoop artifacts from China at no cost. Look at British Museum, Lourve. It happened to all countries have suffered from war. Japanese took most books, paintings, because those are not seen as valuable for westerners. British took most vase, china.
- Iv 7y agoIf the political system in Chine does not collapse everyone should worry too. Because they are very quickly becoming the #1 economic power in the world and I really do not want to see them spreading their views on authoritarianism and citizens control. I am of a boring old school of thought that thinks democracy is a pretty cool system and that it should be preserved. I really hope the Chinese political system collapses at one point. However we should not underestimate the reputation that has a system that tripled the average wage in the last 10 years. Also I would not trust Bloomberg much outside their field of expertise.
- txdv 7y ago> I am of a boring old school Like authatorian dictatorships are now super hip? :D
- cameldrv 7y agoThat does seem to be the trend.
- StreamBright 7y agoThe majority of recorded human history China was the #1 economic power though.
- Iv 7y agoAnd?
- StreamBright 7y ago>> Because they are very quickly becoming the #1 economic power in the world and I really do not want to see them spreading their views on authoritarianism and citizens control. For one, China has been the #1 economic power in the world longer than any other country. Second, they do not spread their views unlike the Western world. How many interventions the US committed in the last 70 years with the approval of the UN? This is exactly the difference between China vs the Western world. They do not force their views on you. This is why they are much more successful in Africa than any Western country ever will be. It is spelled out in the documentary "The Chinese are coming".
- ourlordcaffeine 7y ago>That would likely result in a global economic crash the likes of which the world has never seen. Forgive me for doubting this. It will lead to an internal crash in China, but this won't cause the whole world to crash. There will be a slowdown at worst. Taiwan and Vietnam will likely take up a lot of the slack.