7 ms·
If it goes well, the history of quantum computing will be divided up in to three eras: the era of twisty philosophical arguments that it's working ("the molecul
by whatshisface 7y ago
If it goes well, the history of quantum computing will be divided up in to three eras: the era of twisty philosophical arguments that it's working ("the molecule is simulating itself"), the era of academic arguments that it's working ("we can solve this one carefully constructed problem") and the era of practical arguments ("Amazon is selling QC time for $20/kilogate-bit, what do you mean it's not possible?"). Quantum supremacy marks the transition from the first era to the second.
- p1necone 7y agoI really enjoy seeing comments on here that fit the 3rd kind. "Thing is ridiculous, that could never work because of reasons A, B and C." "What are you talking about, here is project that does thing, it functions perfectly." Nothing like reality proving someones baseless naysaying wrong immediately.
- smsm42 7y agoExcept reality has so far proved that it is possible to use QC for solving one QC-specific task that is hard to solve classically, that's it. That's not what "naysaing" was about - the "naysaying" was about the fact we have no way to use QC for known classical tasks, and the path to such juicy targets as breaking commercial public key encryption is entirely unclear. Virtually nobody says it would never ever happen - but so far it has not happened and will not happen soon, and reality has not proven anything contradicting that yet. When, in 2038 or in 2083, the reality finally gets there, then your condescending attitude towards the naysayers would finally be completely warranted. But not yet.
- gowld 7y agoWhat are the theoretical models for the energy cost of computing on a qubit? I'll be excited for QC when there is known way (even with some handwaving and future-tech plans) to compute a non-trivial result for a reasonable sum, such as "crack someone's private RSA key for under $10M of compute cost"
- sanxiyn 7y agoThis depends on your definition of "trivial". But if we restrict it to factoring, no, there is no known path to QC factoring at the moment, none at all.
- jessriedel 7y agoI don't understand. Factoring composite numbers into their primes is definitely a predicted use for QC in the future. Are you just saying the architecture of the machine powerful enough to do that is still uncertain?
- sanxiyn 7y agoI think it is analogous to fusion. Fusion definitely works (the Sun and hydrogen bomb) and power generation is a predicted use of fusion in the future. That doesn't mean we have known path to fusion for power generation. To extend the analogy, quantum supremacy is like fusion for neutron source. There are commercial fusion devices to be used as neutron source.
- ac29 7y ago> That doesn't mean we have known path to fusion for power generation. Perhaps this was just a poor example, but we absolutely have a path to fusion power generation. ITER [0][2] is under construction now, and is expected to be capable of 10x power returns. DEMO [1] should have 25x. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMOnstration_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMOnstration_Power_Station [2] https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/j/newscms/2017_52/2273651/171226-iter-mn-1255_f551b56b750349b0b42e94e629ae430c.fit-2000w.jpg https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/j/newscms/2017_52/2273651/17122... (worth a click)
- dfsegoat 7y agoFrom the ITER wiki link: > ITER Project was initiated in 1988. > The expected cost of ITER has risen from US$5 billion to US$20 billion, and the timeline for operation at full power was moved from the original estimate of 2016 to 2027. > A technical concern is that the 14 MeV neutrons produced by the fusion reactions will damage the materials from which the reactor is built ... definitely not clear to me that this is a "clear path forward" to fusion power, but I was encouraged to learn that a project of this sort was underway.
- smsm42 7y agoThe third stage is the hardest. Thermonuclear energy production has been sitting in "theoretically possible, but economically unviable" for decades, tons of technologies like supersonic commercial flight has been achieved and then scrapped because of practical concerns, many other technologies struggle with passing economic viability barrier. Taking that into account, getting from 2nd to 3rd stage would be the hardest task. Comparing to classic computers, their practical usability has been clear since Babbage time, so far it's not the case for QC.
- lebed2045 7y agoI don't think it's true for quantum computers. Folding proteins and stuff is good use-case of the cause but the real drive is the military. Same as for gen-AI. If you don't r&d this but Chine does - you're fucked. So the only way to do not become in the disadvantageous position - is to reason it yourself.
- Judgmentality 7y agoIf the military is paying for it then it's already in stage 3. Just because something isn't readily available to the public doesn't mean it's a failure - I can't buy a rocket but the various space programs still do lots of cool things and they have money to pay for it.
- smsm42 7y agoMilitary pays for a lot of stuff that then is not going anywhere. Just as other venture funds do. You can't win without taking some risks. But that doesn't mean everything the army pays for automatically is a great thing.
- smsm42 7y agoThe military what? Comparing again to computing engines, even when computers were not at all like they are now, there were always lots of people queueing around them with workloads they want them to do now - and which computers could help them with as they are, not 200 years in the future. For QC, I do not see many users with workloads that can be served right now. I don't say it shouldn't be developed because of that - lots of things took time to bring to maturity - but we should be ready for it taking a long time to get to real usefullness.
- baby 7y agoWe still don’t know if the third era is possible.
- sgt101 7y agoScience : welcome!
- hamilyon2 7y agoThere is market for two, maybe three quantum computers on earth.
- OJFord 7y agoThere was a market for two, maybe three classical computers until they became smaller, cheaper, and more general purpose.
- tome 7y agoThat's the joke.
- scrollaway 7y agoI believe GP is referring to Thomas Watson's famous quote from the 1940s: "There is a world market for maybe five computers."
- fizx 7y agoThere's plenty of active research into quantum computing meets machine learning. Any real progress here would create quite a market.
- vixen99 7y agoKen Olsen founder and CEO of Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC) in 1977: "There is no reason for any individual to have a computer in his home.”
- rangibaby 7y ago640 qubits ought to be enough for anybody
- braindead_in 7y agoIf all goes well, Google may be the last company. They'll just gobble up everybody else and become Skynet.
- doctorpangloss 7y agoMaybe. I’m pretty sure this FAQ is as much about quantum computing skepticism as it is disbelief that a giant corporation is really as totally responsible for some invention as its brand management would lead headlines to believe.
- oldgradstudent 7y ago> Amazon is selling QC time for $20/kilogate-bit Except that you'd only be able to pay with physical cash.
- andrewla 7y agoFrom what I've parsed of the paper, this appears to fall firmly in the first category. This is a quantum computer simulating a quantum circuit; it's like saying that swirly water in a sink is achieving fluid dynamics supremacy, because we can't compute the results as fast as the water moves. Q12 touches on this. I'd be really interested to hear what Gil Kalai has to say on this particular subject; he's generally pretty fair minded while being of a QC skeptic. He has a response up [1] but I haven't read through it yet. [1] https://gilkalai.wordpress.com/2019/09/23/quantum-computers-amazing-progress-google-ibm-and-extraordinary-but-probably-false-supremacy-claims-google/ https://gilkalai.wordpress.com/2019/09/23/quantum-computers-...