2 ms·
It's true that in a complex world, there isn't going to be a single cause for anything significant; there will be multiple causes and there can be complex relat
by pdonis 7y ago
It's true that in a complex world, there isn't going to be a single cause for anything significant; there will be multiple causes and there can be complex relationships between them. The article recognizes that very point:
"The issue with root cause analysis is that it can lead to oversimplification and it is rare for there to be one single root cause."
But that is not at all the same as the notion of cause itself being suspect. Taleb on that point is simply wrong.
- sitkack 7y agoThis misattribution is something America loves to fall for. And we react in _gigantic_ ways against the wrong thing. Communism, Unions, Vietnam, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Central America, Iraq, the environment. We are great at solving the last big problem in the most headon disastrous way. We only react, never predict. We treated Mexico like sht, if we helped build her up, we both would be a solid position right now. Our war on drugs directly fueled a bloody civil war that has and is displacing millions. The war on drugs was the problem, it raised the price of drugs that made something both attractive and illegal, perfect combo. It is like a cryptocurrency called DistableCoin, where you can mine for more by attacking the state. The root cause is a direct physical cause, but the problem space is the problem. We need to go up-dimension, to project the problem into lots of different lower dimensions. Lots of cut off roasts in the world. The next level of meta is to ask why people cook their own food. Then one asks why the have to eat at all? Why are they biological? Why are they physical?
- Qqqwxs 7y ago>> "The issue with root cause analysis is that it can lead to oversimplification and it is rare for there to be one single root cause." Root cause analysis is a complex and varied topic, discounting it so easily is an oversimplification.