5 ms·
Researchers used a neural network to reconstruct a lost Picasso painting
- throwaway66920 7y agoThat has... so many obvious artificial flaws it’s not even funny. I’m surprised I got a downvote. Compare the fake (e) to the real (d). The algorithm appears to have gotten the broad color scheme correct, but that’s about it as far as the similarities go. There are uncomfortable smudges all over the painting, the lighting makes no sense, and several details have blurred together around the hands, feet, everything.
- herodotus 7y agoThis title is misleading. The painting was recreated, not retrieved. The title of the article itself is "This Picasso painting had never been seen before. Until a neural network painted it."
- Yuval_Halevi 7y agoI actually prefer your title
- abrichr 7y ago> They have taken a manually edited version of the x-ray images of the ghostly woman beneath The Old Guitarist and passed it through a neural style transfer network. This network was trained to convert images into the style of another artwork from Picasso’s Blue Period. Perhaps a more accurate title would be something like "Researchers used a neural network to stylize a manually retrieved lost Picasso painting" Original paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1909.05677.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1909.05677.pdf
- tobr 7y agoTop third of the screen is covered with a cookie warning, bottom third is warning me that I’ve read 1 of 3 free articles, when I scroll down to read this article they already count as read, there’s a big empty space, followed by a prompt to subscribe to some newsletter, followed by four lines of said article, which fade over into a button to actually read it - followed by an attempt to distract me with a different article. I get the hint, you really don’t want me to read the article, so I won’t.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- llarsson 7y agoBrowsing with JavaScript off, and all I get is the contents, an image, and some "related articles" at the end. It truly is the best way to browse in 2019. Deeply ironic, considering all the time and effort web devs have put in to creating all the annoyances you list.
- d--b 7y agoJesus it looks like crap. Compare with the two other painting, the guitarist and the one they used for style transfer, it just has nothing to do. Maybe the problem is that they took too much of the underlying painting, which was either very unfinished or damaged. Anyways, this is quite useless.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 7y ago> Jesus it looks like crap. Maybe that's why he painted over it.
- discreteevent 7y ago"Computers are useless they can only give you answers" - Picasso
- egypturnash 7y agoThis looks like poop. It didn’t even do a good job of faking brushstrokes, much less guessing at what the colors might have been. It’s a half-assed job that’s not doing much more than a style transfer phone app could do. Doing this right, imho, would entail taking x-rays of every Blue Period Picasso possible, and training a network to output the visible image when given an x-ray. I don’t know offhand how many paintings were in that period, so there may not be enough work to usefully do this.
- pvaldes 7y ago> it didn’t even do a good job of faking brushstrokes That part could be intended. There is a blurred line between recreation and falsification and maybe they wanted to mark clearly and a plain sight that is not a real picasso work. > It’s a half-assed job 100% agree with that, this is not even a lost painting. It was there all the time. Is a discarded try, a misfit that didn't pass the painter's test.
- lopmotr 7y agoSo much "research" is just people doing normal mundane work but they happen to be familiar with the process of publishing research papers so they do that for whatever they can think of. This particular work is more like a hobby or perhaps some curiosity for art historians to look at. They didn't do anything that we couldn't already and obviously do anyway.
- JonathanFly 7y agoThis is a neat idea, but the execution was kind of minimum-viable-attempt. You can do this yourself though, just google some famous paintings with X-RAY images and try it. I doubt this is very accurate but it is fun. I posted a few https://twitter.com/jonathanfly/status/1175966107091574784 https://twitter.com/jonathanfly/status/1175966107091574784
- JonathanFly 7y agoIn particular https://twitter.com/jonathanfly/status/1176355623857991681 https://twitter.com/jonathanfly/status/1176355623857991681