5 ms·
I think that a lot of times management believes it's only job is to cut corners. In those cases, maybe it's better not to have managers. Maybe if engineers we
by ilaksh 7y ago
I think that a lot of times management believes it's only job is to cut corners. In those cases, maybe it's better not to have managers.
Maybe if engineers were properly incentivized by profit sharing or something, they could help maximize profits without throwing out everything else like managers keep urging them to.
- generatorguy 7y agoLawyers and accountants become partners in their firms and are incentivized to work towards the long term health of the firm so younger lawyers will buy in and they can retire and continue to enjoy the profits of the firm. What do Civil, mechanical, electrical, non-software Engineers have as a career path? None are in upper management. Maybe you get some stock options? You certainly don’t get to be in charge unless you start your own small, fledgling engineering company and then the chances are you only work on small projects since you aren’t big enough to sue if anything goes wrong you can’t get big contracts. Hoping someone can shed some light on another path for career professional engineers.
- cco 7y agoI'm a big fan of the idea of codifying software "engineers" more clearly. When an architect, civil engineer, or doctor put their stamp on a job they are both civilally and in some cases criminally liable for that work. As such each profession has a professional society and legal framework for qualifying their members. If you are building a webapp, it's probably fine that you haven't taken an ethical code, been legally qualified to write the code, etc, but those "engineers" that write code that keeps airplanes in the air or driverless cars on the road have, in my opinion, crossed that line into actual engineering work and as such should hold themselves to the same standards as other professionals in the space. In the case of MCAS there would be a codebase with a signed commit by the responsible engineer, his or her name would be right there in bold when the first version was shipped and when hack upon hack was piled on. Of course this is no panacea but this has to be the way forward as software continues to extend it's reach into mission critical roles in our lives, right?
- zwolbers 7y agoIn aviation, DERs (Designated Engineering Representatives) fill that role [0]. They are responsible for ensuring rules/regulations are met, and need to sign off on everything before it's sent to the FAA. [0] https://www.faa.gov/other_visit/aviation_industry/designees_delegations/individual_designees/der/ https://www.faa.gov/other_visit/aviation_industry/designees_...
- cco 7y agoSo these software engineers would be referred to as Systems and Equipment Engineering leads in this case?
- zwolbers 7y agoTake this post with a grain of salt - I've never worked directly with a DER. Hopefully others can correct me where needed. > So these software engineers would be referred to as Systems and Equipment Engineering leads in this case? I suppose you could say so, however my understanding has always been that DERs are highly specialized. "Systems and Equipment" covers a wide variety of aircraft components; I would think that's more of a category than a title. As a software engineer, on a project level, we've always simply referred to them as "The DER". While DERs certainly have a background in engineering, they don't actively help create the product - I wouldn't classify them as a "Engineering Lead". When it comes to designing something, its safety is derived from different internal groups with different goals continuously evaluating each other's work. At each level, everyone signs off on the work they performed or reviewed. As I understand it, the DER oversees all of this, and on a technical level, is ultimately responsible for convincing the FAA everything is safe. On the software side of things, whenever there's a release, a DER has to sign off on it.
- WWLink 7y agoIf you have an ABET certified computer engineering degree, you can become a licensed engineer. Admittedly, I'm surprised that isn't a requirement for these things sometimes.
- 7y ago
- kthejoker2 7y agoLots of oil and gas CEOs are engineers by trade. And as an industry they seem to value field service in their leadership. My takeaway is embrace cartels, they're immune to market pressures and they're fundamentally conservative.
- acd 7y agoActually profit as a motivation does not work for highly skilled work. If you put a monetary reward for solving a problem the solution usually gets worse. "Based on studies done at MIT and other universities,[4] higher pay and bonuses resulted in better performance ONLY if the task consisted of basic, mechanical skills. It worked for problems with a defined set of steps and a single answer. If the task involved cognitive skills, decision-making, creativity, or higher-order thinking, higher pay resulted in lower performance" source: book The Drive by Dan Pink https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive:_The_Surprising_Truth_About_What_Motivates_Us https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive:_The_Surprising_Truth_Ab... Ted talk https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pink_on_motivation https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pink_on_motivation
- ilaksh 7y agoThat's exactly the type of hogwash executives promote in order to avoid rewarding engineers so they can keep more profits for themselves.
- swagasaurus-rex 7y agoThere's one very important thing keeping me and everybody from destitution: an income. Profit motive might not make me more creative (debatable) but it will certainly enable me to work for years on end.
- goatinaboat 7y agoActually profit as a motivation does not work for highly skilled work. If that is true then it logically follows that management is not highly skilled work, no? Do the people who come up with these theories even bother to think it through at all?
- solidasparagus 7y agoI take it you couldn't be bothered to read the links or look at the research behind the theory before ridiculing it? The idea is that after a certain point, financial motivation doesn't lead to better work - to motivate you need to fulfill higher-level needs like ownership, purpose, autonomy, etc. Your statement about management not being skilled work makes no sense. Do you have some evidence that paying managers more leads to better performance?
- tomohawk 7y agoEngineers of yore were trained not only in the technical skills, but also in economic analysis and management of systems. They were expected to take a leadership role as their career progressed in large projects. The treky model of engineer as skilled technician has not been helpful. Taking such a narrow view, many engineers fail to provide adequate and effective input into the program, and managers learn to ignore their concerns as not relevant to the larger picture.