6 ms·
"According to Pew Research Center data...42% think spiritual energy can be located in physical objects such as crystals." Urgh. Is it really 42%? That's depr
by tyingq 7y ago
"According to Pew Research Center data...42% think spiritual energy can be located in physical objects such as crystals."
Urgh. Is it really 42%? That's depressing.
- apta 7y agoI'd question the survey they conducted.
- technothrasher 7y agoScience education in this country is seriously broken. The elementary schools jump right into teaching procedural skills such as the 'scientific method', which is really just experimental design and is useless without teaching the basic critical thinking and philosophy of science. Those are way more important for the majority of students, who are not going to go on to be scientists. We need to start the education at the preschool level, teaching the kids how easy it is to be fooled and why we have to always question. You can then build on that at the elementary school level with concepts of objectivity and repeatabily. By the end on elementary school you can then begin philosophy of rationality and empiricism. This can all happen in parallel to teaching 'science facts' that we do now. But none of this is currently happening at any kind of large scale.
- The_rationalist 7y agoIf this was done manking would be changed forever. Note about teaching reason: Cognitive biases and logical fallacies should be teached too.
- richk449 7y agoHow do you teach a preschool kid reason?
- technothrasher 7y agoYou don't. You simply teach them that they can be easily fooled. That's the beginning. Among other things, slight of hand magic and optical illusions are both fun, easy to grasp, and get the point across. Reason comes later. When my boy was a preschooler he came home one day with a terrible story about how his friend's dad had been sucked up by a vacuum cleaner! He was pretty spooked by the story. I simply said, "Hmm, interesting, let's try it." We got out the vacuum cleaner and I let him attempt to suck me up with it. It was fun, funny, and I could see the lightbulb go off in his head.
- abakker 7y agoHere’s an alternative view: we do an ok job of science education, but a deeply unsatisfactory job of teaching people that it is OK to be themselves and likes the stuff they like. Crystal spiritualism to me is just a reaction to the fact that people overascribe meaning to things that they like and enjoy, as a justification beyond “I enjoy it”. It goes hand in hand with the whole spiritualism around rock climbing or stand up paddle boarding or yoga - they’re all great fun, but, modern life under emphasizes the role of fun and preference and so people justify it with spiritualism.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoThe simple counter-example here is: everybody likes cocaine, but nobody likes what cocaine does to you over long term, so you should probably not do it.
- ozzmotik 7y agoi don't particularly like what breathing oxygen does to my body over the long term but i still do that. granted, out of necessity. anyway i agree with the point you're making, with one caveat: id say it's perfectly okay to do cocaine responsibly. it's just really difficult to do so evidently! if one were to only occasionally do it then i would think that the overall negative impact of it would be significantly less than what would happen if one were to do it consistently for a long period of time. granted my experience is with methamphetamine, which is, uh... an entirely different beast! but either way. if someone likes crystals, it's ok to like them and to collect them, even to believe some woo things about them. but it's a problem when they start trying to convince everyone else that their experience is absolute and not just anecdotal. the same concept in a roundabout way goes for cocaine: if you like it, by all means, enjoy it! just be responsible with it. personally i don't like cocaine at all, just the way that it smells /s
- Scoundreller 7y ago> We need to start the education at the preschool level, teaching the kids how easy it is to be fooled and why we have to always question. You’re going to have to rejig several years of curriculum based on the Easter bunny, various Christmas holiday creations, children’s books and probably ruin a lot of imaginative fantasy books. I’m okay with it though, my older siblings basically did the same thing to me from a young age.
- cam_l 7y agoWell, i don't know, but i don't think it's possible to believe in spiritual energy without thinking it can be located in a physical object. I mean, what would be the point of it, if it could not interact with the world. And if you simply believe that the physical world is all there is, well i guess whatever spirituality is, then it must be located in matter. So i guess i don't find it that depressing compared to all the other batshit crazy things people believe.
- noodlenotes 7y agoDo "physical objects" include communion wafers, holy objects, and churches? If so, this is hardly a new idea and I'm surprised it's as low as 42%.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- verylittlemeat 7y agoThe use of "such as" in that question feels weasely. I think plenty of people walk through a museum and feel that certain inanimate physical objects carry a nearly spiritual weight. That didn't mean they think there's healing power in a geode.
- tim333 7y agoIf you use the word energy in the sense of I don't feel that energetic today, ie as a mental state then that's not so bad. Obviously it doesn't make sense for energy in the joules sense.
- rstuart4133 7y agoIt is depressing as knowing someone [0] make a living out of Rumpology [1]? I remember discovering [0] decades ago when the internet was young. It was funny back then. I search for it recently to illustrate to my kids how wild the early internet was, and to my horror found it hadn't disappeared. One the contrary, it had grown stronger. (Definitely same site run by the same woman - I have never forgotten her face.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumpology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumpology [1] http://www.jacquelinestallone.com/rumps.html http://www.jacquelinestallone.com/rumps.html