9 ms·
Georgia's entire voter file potentially compromised after voting machine theft
- snowwrestler 7y ago> Diamant said this is a huge deal, because the elections director said the machines contained the entire state of Georgia voter file, which includes names, addresses and birthdates for all Georgia voters -- all now potentially compromised. Hmmmm..... > By law, voter registration lists are available to the public and contain the following information: voter name, residential address, mailing address if different, race, gender, registration date, and last voting date. Pricing is set by the Secretary of State's Office. https://sos.ga.gov/index.php/Elections/order_voter_registration_lists_and_files https://sos.ga.gov/index.php/Elections/order_voter_registrat... So I guess now the hackers improperly know everyone's birthday?
- smt88 7y agoI get that it seems minor compared to, say, Equifax, but voting is intended to be a particularly private aspect of public life. You can say someone can buy their privacy by avoiding Gmail, Facebook, etc., but no one should feel like they have to choose between privacy and voting.
- lopmotr 7y agoWho people voted for is, but not really the other stuff. In my country, name, address and occupation on the electoral role are public-ish information that anybody can look up in the local library. The law requires it to be made public, though also disallows any bulk copying of it, so theft of the whole database would still be a problem.
- gus_massa 7y agoHere in Argentina too. It even includes the equivalent of the SSN, that is public here. I guess all the political parties get one whole copy and the relevant pages are posted in the walls of the voting building, so you can check in which room you should vote (if you didn't check before in internet).
- tinus_hn 7y agoThis is why in the Netherlands both private parties and the government are forbidden from using the ‘SSN’ for anything but a defined set of purposes. Your employer knows the number but can’t use it as your ID in their databases, your municipal authorities can’t link your garbage disposal pass to it.
- gus_massa 7y agoNow the number is assigned chronologically when you register your newborn during the first week of life, so knowing the birth date, you can guess all but the last 3 or 4 digits. If used like a "secret", it is a 13 bits secret. Until a few years ago (10?) each city got a block of consecutive numbers and used it until it got exhausted, so with the birthplace it was easier to get a more smaller range even with an approximate birthdate. (Some cities used to continue the numeration after their block was exhausted, but these numbers where in the block of another city, so there is some duplication.) (And many years ago, the numeration for men and women was independent, because they had a different ID. When the ID were unified there was a lot of duplication.)
- hyperman1 7y agoSame for Belgium. Your id is mostly birth date + 3 digits + a checksum. The 3 digits are half male half female. So 9 bits of randomness, and that's assuming all 500 combinations get used.
- codedokode 7y agoWhy is the occupation recorded in the list?
- BubRoss 7y agoWhat information do they have that isn't already public? That's what the parent was talking about.
- jdavis703 7y agoVoter information is posted publicly on the outside of each voting location (at least in California). Election monitors, journalists and nosey neighbors can check to see who voted and when. In some states you can even buy all this information on a CDROM. This is how canvassers know your name, especially when there's maybe a parent and adult child living at home (if the old person shows you ask to speak to the elder, otherwise ask for the child). I just don't see this as that big a deal.
- codedokode 7y agoThat's interesting. Here in Russia voter list is not publicly available. As a voter you can only check whether your own information is recorded correctly, and if you are an observer then you can examine (but cannot copy) voters list before election day.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> You can say someone can buy their privacy by avoiding Gmail, Facebook, etc., but no one should feel like they have to choose between privacy and voting. But again, >> By law, voter registration lists are available to the public Someone may have stolen information they are legally entitled to have. That's not a scandal.
- masonic 7y agoThese are voter registration data, not voter history data (showing elections voted in and vote method). Note that both Obama campaigns illegally distributed voter registration data freely and without qualification or tracking via their volunteer app.
- nealabq 7y agoI assume you're talking about the app where you could find out if your neighbors were registered R or D. I don't think that info should be made public, but I can't find any evidence that the app was illegal. Can you clarify?
- masonic 7y agoIn most jurisdictions, you need to sign policy protections (and pay a fee, except parties get the full set for free) to get voter data in bulk. That data can't be redistributed except under tracked conditions. The app made it available to everybody.
- gabrielgrant 7y agoActually, "Year of Birth" appears to be one of the voter file fields too. Not quite the same as an exact birth date (esp for identity theft purposes), but useful for demographic targeting.
- bboygravity 7y agoNaive question from a European here: how do you know and classify "race" and why is it relevant? Do you get entries like 1 person's race being "25 % native Filipino, 10 % Chinese, 15 % "black", 25 % Arab, 25 % Caucasian"? How do you even...?
- speedplane 7y ago> Naive question from a European here: how do you know and classify "race" and why is it relevant? Very naive, especially considering you're european. Race has much less to do with genetics and biology and more to do with perceived social norms. During the 1800s in the US, person who is 10% black is still often considered black. In Nazi Germany, a person who was 10% jewish was still considered jewish. Putting people into race buckets is often based on unscientific (and immoral) notions of "purity" and a "natural hierarchy" of disparate societies.
- craz8 7y agoMany, many* forms in the US ask this information so they can do later analysis on how they are racially biased in their decision making, so they can Do Better Next Time (Tm) Since I can answer in the Best Possible Way - old white guy - I don’t mind answering these optional questions. They never ask about how cynical I am though! * many includes Job Applications, Loan applications, and, it seems, for voting too
- snowwrestler 7y agoRace is self-reported. So if people answer honestly, the form records their own opinion about their own race. The categories on forms have been built up over time by finding commonalities in what people report.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Do you get entries like 1 person's race being "25 % native Filipino, 10 % Chinese, 15 % "black", 25 % Arab, 25 % Caucasian"? This isn't really something to worry about. The odds are pretty good that there is no person in the world with the ancestry you describe; if you did get input like this, the sensible thing to do would be to discard it. (Note also that Arab is a strict subset of Caucasian...)
- aloknnikhil 7y ago> The state will soon roll out a new, $100 million voting system which Raffensperger said will have a new iPad-based check-in system, which they can track and delete data remotely if they get stolen. I'm confused. Why are these records on the device at all? Why not a server? Why spend $100 million just to move it from paper to an iPad?
- wtallis 7y agoThey need to be able to check in voters on election day even if the polling place's internet connection drops.
- aloknnikhil 7y agoI get that. But you could always fallback onto another way of reaching the server (LTE/4G) or even a direct connect to some central server close by. I mean, this is sensitive data that is essentially being replicated across the whole state onto devices that are not heavily guarded apparently. Surely there are better ways to handle this? And as connectivity gets better, I think there should be a push to adopt client-server architectures for critical infrastructure. How would remotely wiping an iPad help? What if the stolen iPad is never allowed to connect to a network?
- jefftk 7y agoThis is not sensitive data; voter registration information is public and available for purchase from the government.
- Beldin 7y agoSidenote: whether this is appropriate is a completely different discussion. To me, as someone from a country where this data is considered sensitive, the fact that you can purchase this data is mind-boggling.
- an_account 7y ago
- tunesmith 7y agoOr perhaps it's a "theft" to justify some other effort to further restrict people's voting rights - like, I guess it's time to make everyone re-register, except for those right-thinking folks that they're already sure aren't cheaters...
- dralley 7y agoI hope this helps the lawsuit to force Georgia away from using electronic voting. Clearly their security procedures (physical and digital) are lacking.
- OrgNet 7y agodigital voting is not an issue only in Georgia... but that would be a start.
- Beldin 7y agoThe officials somehow need to verify eligibility. If not with a computer, then on paper... which could also be stolen in exactly this manner. So I doubt it'll have this impact.
- mhh__ 7y agoOr just distribute the verification work to a local level where theft of one set of names is only locally useful.
- r0m4n0 7y agoHaving spent quite a bit of time requesting voter files from the government, I can say it’s not hard to obtain this data in most states. Many times it’s just a small fee, a pinky promise that you won’t use the data for non political purposes, and a photo of your drivers license. I think they should be more worried about someone reverse engineering the closed source software of the checkin machine in this case...
- victor9000 7y agoThis is what you do if you want to probe one for weaknesses.
- gordaco 7y agoSorry to be that guy, but here is the obligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/. As a tech worker, and as someone who knows about computers, I very strongly oppose electronic voting. And the more I know, the more I oppose it. It's slightly more convenient, but in exchange it's way way less secure. Also, this is not the first time Georgia has had problems related to electronic voting: see https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1003966/diebold-insider-blows-whistle https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1003966/diebold-in....
- pmontra 7y agoBut it's the wet dream of people willing to spend a lot of (not theirs) money and maybe rigging the results.
- mhh__ 7y agoI think both practically, theoretically and ethically the only response to electronic voting is to kill it with fire
- codedokode 7y ago> The state will soon roll out a new, $100 million voting system which Raffensperger said will have a new iPad-based check-in system, which they can track and delete data remotely if they get stolen. Will they be able to delete votes for a wrong candidate remotely too?
- rovr138 7y agoPretty sure they mean apple’s remote tools for tracking and deleting. This does say check in.