6 ms·
As someone who has designed shipping HDL including more SPI masters than I can count, and now works as a security researcher (among a couple other hats I wear a
by monocasa 7y ago
As someone who has designed shipping HDL including more SPI masters than I can count, and now works as a security researcher (among a couple other hats I wear aty current job), I really think Bloomberg got dragged through the mud.
Everything they said about the BMC was plausible. It was bizzare hearing about how such a scheme would literally break the laws of physics, when by accident (read shitty, undebugged HDL) I've caused exactly what they were claiming.
- Sephr 7y agoI've similarly expressed this opinion openly on Twitter and then I was immediately harassed by Tavis Ormandy of Google Project Zero in my DMs with meme-y taunting messages. It's odd how dismissive some supposedly-serious security researchers are of hardware implant capabilities.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y ago> It's odd how dismissive some supposedly-serious security researchers are of hardware implant capabilities. And it really doesn’t take much effort to sneak even a bashbunny into an internal USB header - especially in the last mile of the supply-chain. Get a temp-job as a UPS delivery driver in an area that services the datacenter of your target, whenever you deliver a sever box - open it up, add your implant, re-seal it all in the privacy of the back of your delivery truck, and that’s it.
- taviso 7y agoThis didn't happen, I have never DM'd you.
- enisberk 7y agoI love how well connected HN to tech world. Did you see that by chance or do you have some kind of an alert system set up ?
- taviso 7y agoWell, a human alert system, a friend saw my name and sent me the link :)
- yborg 7y agoNot sure if I should downvote or upvote parent now :p
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sephr 7y agoI'm sorry for initially claiming that you DMed me a harassing ancient aliens meme in response to my comments regarding the Bloomberg hardware implant story. I recall it being you, but it must not have been.
- zaroth 7y agoPlease avoid personal attacks and/or libel.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoCan you show us the messages? He’s saying that never happened.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 7y agoThe problem with what Bloomberg reported was not that it was implausible, but rather that it was unsubstantiated as to whether the attack actually occurred. If Bloomberg had narrated the article as "this could happen", attempting to explain a possible attack vector, that would have been fantastic. I do agree there was a lot of "but SPI requires 6 wires and the slave can only respond when talked to" (treating SPI with the assumptions of a design engineer rather than an attacker), but that was ultimately just noise.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoAgree. Remember BadBIOS? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BadBIOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BadBIOS Same problem. EVERYTHING that Dragos Ruiu claimed is plausible, and it could be a great cyberpunk plot written by Neal Stephenson. But there is ZERO evidence that the malware actually exists. And finding an actual incident in real life is much more important than theoretical possibilities. For example, almost everyone knows that it's very possible for semiconductor vendors to include a silicon-level backdoor since the 1980s, but finding an actual Intel/AMD chip with such backdoor (not ME, something like a secret instructions) is another matter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sephr 7y agoME has a debug mode that might be possible to enable with a signal sent through the 3.5mm jack on some laptops[1]. I'd be pretty concerned about ME bugs and backdoors disguised as ME bugs. 1. https://youtu.be/xUJQps2-VWk?t=301 https://youtu.be/xUJQps2-VWk?t=301
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoI meant, finding a backdoor in its full form on the main system would be a much more significant find, and its impact and newsworthiness is greater than any hypothetical or baseless speculations, such as Bloomberg's BMC affair. The impact of the BMC affair, if true, is showing real evidence and real demonstration that such an attack has happened, has been used in the wild, rather than showing that the attack is possible (we all know). Unfortunately, bad journalism at work. P.S: I'm not saying that the ME subsystem, or buggy speculation (pun not intended) isn't a threat, just to make a point. > I'd be pretty concerned about ME bugs and backdoors disguised as ME bugs. Same consequences. I'd say they're effectively the same thing.
- pfranz 7y agoLike others have said, the pushback came from saying it was happening, not that it was plausible. As well as refusing to pull the story or clarify the details. I also swear I had read articles months/years before that companies like Apple literally photographed motherboards before shipping and compared them after arriving to look out for hardware tampering in transit. That, to me, shows they are not only aware of issues like that, but taking meaningful steps to detect it. Edit: Here's an article from 2016 about it https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-worried-about-spy-tech-in-servers-it-buys-2016-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-worried-about-spy-tech...
- monocasa 7y agoThe hack supposedly happened in 2015. Apple being super concerned about server motherboard supply chain management in 2016 for unspecified reasons lines up with the timeline very well.
- Spooky23 7y agoFederal buyers use companies like Harris Corp to sample and analyze devices and components for tampering or counterfeiting. Even then, bad stuff gets through. Apple cares about supply chain integrity, but it’s not enough to stop this kind of threat.
- thaumaturgy 7y ago> Everything they said about the BMC was plausible. Not just plausible; something not altogether dissimilar was documented to have been happening by the Snowden documents back in 2014: https://www.engadget.com/2014/05/16/nsa-bugged-cisco-routers/ https://www.engadget.com/2014/05/16/nsa-bugged-cisco-routers... I'm good with Bloomberg being expected to do a better job covering this activity than they have. And, without further evidence that it's actually happening, I can't quite take the step into believing that it's probably happening, because that way lies tin foil hats. But for all the security researchers that straight up claim that what Bloomberg reported was impossible, I wonder what their opinion would have been about reports that the NSA was bugging routing and server hardware in transit before 2014?
- ColanR 7y ago> because that way lies tin foil hats I wonder why we're so collectively afraid of being labeled 'conspiracy theorists'. What is so wrong with supposing that bad things are being done intentionally?
- thaumaturgy 7y agoIt's not a matter of supposing that certain things may be happening, or even that they probably are. It's a matter of believing with certainty that they are, without concrete evidence and sometimes even when there's evidence to the contrary. It's a pernicious bug in certain kinds of psychology that makes it quite hard for someone to tell the difference between nightmarish fantasy and reality. I don't want it.
- javajosh 7y agoWell said. Of interest to me is why these beliefs? Without evidence, one is capable of believing anything to be true. So why believe conspiracy at all? What psychological and/or aesthetic need are these specific beliefs satisfying?
- colordrops 7y ago
- earthboundkid 7y agoI don’t know which is more likely: China leaning on Apple etal to hush up their spying attempts or USG feeding misinformation to Bloomberg to gin up the trade war. But it’s probably one or the other or both.
- doctorsher 7y agoBloomberg was rightfully dragged through the mud (IMHO), and like the parent I am immediately distrustful of any technical stories they put out. The issue was not that the BMC hack was implausible, but rather Bloomberg's refusal to supply solid evidence backing up their claims in the face of strong denials and perceived issues with the reporting. A subset of the perceived issues with the reporting: - How do the exploited servers phone home to China, when they were not connected to the open Internet? Not impossible, but it's asking for a lot of trust without more information. [0] - One of the only named sources, Ryan Fitzpatrick, saying the details in their big hack article are identical to an example he constructed for the journalists to show that type of attack is plausible. The entire podcast is a great listen, but here is a direct quote: "In September when he asked me like, 'Okay, hey, we think it looks like a signal amplifier or a coupler. What’s a coupler? What does it look like?' […] I sent him a link to Mouser, a catalog where you can buy a 0.006 x 0.003 inch coupler. Turns out that’s the exact coupler in all the images in the story." [1] - An accusation that the journalists who authored the Big Hack have had a previous story that made a big claim, they had many anonymous sources that back up their claims, but in the end there were extreme doubts of the veracity from people in the know. [2] - Bloomberg sent another reporter, completely separate from the Big Hack article, in their tracks to discreetly talk to sources / involved parties to figure out the truth. [3] Sources: [0] https://daringfireball.net/2018/10/bloomberg_the_big_hack https://daringfireball.net/2018/10/bloomberg_the_big_hack [1] https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ https://risky.biz/RB517_feature/ [2] https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1049617855396933632.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1049617855396933632.html [3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2018/11/27/bloomberg-is-still-reporting-on-challenged-story-regarding-china-hardware-hack/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2018/11/...
- emmelaich 7y ago(the famous) Dan Farmer was alerting about problems with IPMI / BMC around the same time http://www.fish2.com/ipmi/ http://www.fish2.com/ipmi/