7 ms·
“Your circle” unless it includes families with small kids, isn’t Disney’s primary audience. Most normal middle class people aren’t going to go through the troub
by scarface74 7y ago
“Your circle” unless it includes families with small kids, isn’t Disney’s primary audience. Most normal middle class people aren’t going to go through the trouble of pirating movies and setting up a Plex server and then worry about setting up their router to get a good connection while they are away from home and even then deal with the abysmally slow upload speed of the typical home network instead of spending $8 a month to just have the convenience of Disney+ to be a glorified babysitter.
In 2003, people said that the iTunes music store was going to be a disaster. Who would pay to download music when they could get it for free. That worked out pretty well.
- coldtea 7y ago>Most normal middle class people aren’t going to go through the trouble of pirating movies and setting up a Plex server and then worry about setting up their router to get a good connection while they are away from home and even then deal with the abysmally slow upload speed of the typical home network instead of spending $8 a month to just have the convenience of Disney+ to be a glorified babysitter. Depending on the country, you'd be surprised. I'm not sure why Disney has the hold it has in the US, but in most of Europe I know it's nothing special (to the point of being a "must have" brand). Kids can just sit in front of regular kids TV channels. And normal middle class families can and do pirate all the time...
- cptskippy 7y agoSadly Disney is a lifestyle choice for a lot of people and the passion they have for the brand can be downright cultish and creepy at times. Groups like hardcore Disney fans, R. Kelly fans, and Evangelical Christians all share a very similar devotion and loyalty to their idols.
- myself248 7y agoThis week, in "Speculative Mergers and Acquisitions Horror Theatre"...
- beardedwizard 7y agoTell me more about how R. Kelly and Disney fans are similar. Share your point by point analysis and include examples. Maybe you would like to bring Taylor Swift into the discussion? Your comment is a poorly disguised insult.
- 0-_-0 7y agoI can tell you really like R. Kelly or Disney but I can' tell which.
- cptskippy 7y agoIt's unclear which you ascribe to but it's curious that you don't take offense to either being compared to Evangelicals. In either case, they're both almost a Cult of personality. The fans are so adorant of their object that they often overlook glaringly evil deeds. At the same time, the level of manipulation exhibited and the devotion demanded by the personality is extreme to the point that outsiders see it as absurd. Idk, maybe it's just me but I find fanaticism to be very off putting in general. When the idol asks fans to make sacrifices to stay it in their favor, that's when it crosses a line into creepy. Disney walks a fine line where it expertly cultivates that culture while simultaneously pretending it doesn't exist and remaining open and accessible to everyone.
- reroute1 7y agoBut to be fair R. Kelly is being accused of pretty awful crimes which I don't see an equivalent from Disney...
- cptskippy 7y agoPerhaps not in depth of harm but in breadth it far surpasses R. Kelly. Disney has been accused of gross labor and environmental violations across the globe. So while R. Kelly has caused severe damage to a few, Disney has caused minor to moderate damage to a great number.
- 7y ago
- Jaruzel 7y agoFor Star Wars and Marvel fans, they don't really have any choice in the matter these days.
- mcv 7y agoAlthough I'd prefer to have everything on Netflix, I'm definitely going to get Disney+. Not a fan of Disney the corporation, but if Disney+ contains everything Star Wars, everything Marvel, everything from Jim Henson, and everything from all their other properties, there's no way I'm going to pay for easy access to that. We don't even watch regular TV anymore at my home. It's either Netflix or Youtube.
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoThere are only one or two Marvel or Star Wars movies a year though. Is that really worth subscribing to a streaming service for? (Not to mention that only maybe a quarter of these movies are worth seeking out, the rest are something I’d only ever watch for free on an airplane or something. But that’s just personal taste).
- dagw 7y agoTwo movies time 4 movie tickets pr movie (for a family) is pretty close to one years worth of streaming service. If you're also the sort of person that considers popcorn an integral part of the movie watching experience then the streaming services is almost certainly cheaper even if you only watch those two movies a year.
- scarface74 7y agoSeeing the box office results of Disney’s movies, your anecdotal opinion doesn’t jibe with the overall market. Besides, there will also be Disney original MCU and Star Wars TV series.
- coldtea 7y ago>Seeing the box office results of Disney’s movies, your anecdotal opinion doesn’t jibe with the overall market. Yes, but the overall market also doesn't jibe with taste, as Zappa would say...
- scarface74 7y ago
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMoreover, it's not like there aren't pirate streaming services available. In fact, I can't think of anyone non-technical I know who torrents anything; they all stream movies from pirate player sites. It's easier, and also perfectly legal for the viewer.
- scarface74 7y agoIt's not "easy" on mobile and definitely not easy when you have to depend on cellular connectivity to stream while on the road.
- coldtea 7y ago>It's not "easy" on mobile Short videos maybe, but I don't think I know anybody, young or old, who cares of streaming full movies on mobile. Maybe some outliers who watch their series on their commute... The vast majority watch movies when they are at home...
- scarface74 7y agoSo are you saying that all of the media streaming companies are wasting money creating mobile apps based on the "people you know"? Is the whole industry under the delusion that their apps are needed? Should they focus on just “people you know” or the entire mobile market?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoPeople like the ability to stream from the phone, but the same mobile apps also target tablets, which are very much used as portable TVs. Still, I don't see your problem. Given how good browsers are on mobile, a pirate streaming site isn't that much worse or less convenient on a phone than Netflix or YouTube app. You select the video you want to watch, tap Play, tap "full screen", and enjoy the show.
- scarface74 7y ago
- gldalmaso 7y agoPirating shows and putting them on an external drive that you plug on any TV and can take with you on trips works fine and most normal middle class people can manage it though.
- scarface74 7y agoAny TV except the ones in most hotel rooms that lock down the HDMI input and the ones that don’t exist in most cars. Then you have the issue of the kids fighting over what to watch and wanting to watch video on their phones and tablets.
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoI use VLC on iOS to copy movies and shows to my iPad from a Windows share. Works perfectly fine. In some ways it's better than Netflix/Amazon offline mode since I know my files will always work in VLC whereas I don't know ahead of time which streaming content allows offline mode or not.
- scarface74 7y agoYes and the typical household is going to download movies from torrent sites and use VLC.
- kalleboo 7y agoFor Disney's kids stuff sure, but they're also pulling Marvel movies and Fox shows from Netflix
- hendersoon 7y agoYou don't understand how low-friction piracy is these days. Only techies deal with automation and Plex. Most people just buy a "fully loaded" android box which lists thumbnails for all the latest movies and TV shows on various file storage sites. They select a thumbnail and the movie plays. Nothing local at all, all streamed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 7y agoWhich again doesn’t help when so much video streaming is done on mobile devices....
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThere's plenty of streaming sites, and since web browsers work so well on mobile devices nowadays...
- scarface74 7y agoSee my previous comment... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21005204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21005204
- Fabricio20 7y agoEver heard of Kodi? That's a set-top box OS but that also is an Android App.. Then watch some youtube videos on how to install the magic box addons and you have access to millions of movies for streaming. As hendersoon noted, nowadays, piracy is extremely low-friction.
- scarface74 7y agoTwo problems -- middle class households in the US are overwhelmingly iOS -- not Android and that still doesn't solve the problem of mobile and having to depend on cellular connectivity to stream. Disney+ and Netflix allow you to download shows.
- cptskippy 7y agoExcept the adults of families today were the kids who grew up with Napster, Limewire, and TPB so piracy has a sentimental feel to it like pulling a Nintendo out of your mom's basement.
- scarface74 7y agoI used Napster when it first came out, I was already 26. But as soon as the iTunes music store came out for Windows, I stopped using Napster and Kazaa. They were no longer worth the hassle. I didn’t buy an iPod until around 2005. I just made CDs. It’s the same with video now. If I plan ahead, I will still pick up movies that fall off the back of a truck and put them on my Plex server, but often, we don’t even bother. We just rent from Amazon Prime or iTunes. That’s even considering that I can just go to http://remote.vuze.com http://remote.vuze.com from anywhere on my phone and start a download on my home server.
- cptskippy 7y agoI have actually started buying movie codes off those dodgy looking sites Disney hates. You can usually own a movie for the cost of a rental from Amazon, Google or iTunes. I have never had a failure but I once had an issue with a purchase porting to Movies Anywhere from Google Play. Google was beyond useless in helping me out, I actually spoke with someone on the phone and it was as if they had never even seen the Play Store before. I emailed the seller about it and got an immediate email response with a couple suggestions to try before refund, the first suggestion worked.
- viraptor 7y agoThat sounds terribly complicated. You know you can google "watch ... online free" and get a streamable version in the first two pages of results, right?
- scarface74 7y agoAnd I just did that for Avengers on my iPad. The first result takes me to: - 5Movies4Free -- which then redirects me - mobilevpn.download -- and then when I click on "Install and Register Now". It redirects me to -"app.appsflyer.com" which then - redirects me to the app store - and then it just hangs Is that really the user experience that people want as opposed to just paying $8 a month and they can stream movies to 4 devices, download on mobile so they don't have to worry about poor connectivity and they can stream to almost any device? Not to mention your solution not only requires them to wade through shady sites, but they also would have to have a computer connected to their TV. In the US, Apple has close to half the mobile phone market and a much larger share of the market of middle and upper income households. Do you think that people who are willing to pay Apple prices for hardware will even blink at signing up for Disney+ and Netflix instead of going through all of these contortions? Edit: I forgot to mention that every major cellular carrier and MetroPCS (a sub brand of T-mobile) is bundling at least one streaming option as part of their family plan - except for Verizon. Edit 2: I would have never gone through the entire process on my computer, too much of a risk of drive by downloads. I knew that it probably wouldn't do too much damage on iOS.
- jeromegv 7y agoAgree with you. The only consistent experience for me is BitTorrent. But trying to google watching a movie for free? Does someone actually do that? It's always hundreds of popup, fake links, fake ads, and can never really get to the actual content.
- scarface74 7y agoBit Torrent “consistent”? Having to worry about the quality of rips, whether there is a complete seed, titled correctly, has the right language, hard coded subtitles in another language, etc? This is somehow more convenient than just paying $8 a month? Even then, I would still need to pay for a VPN and no VPN provider provides the bandwidth to keep up with my gigabit internet.
- tbyehl 7y ago> Most normal middle class people aren’t going to go through the trouble of pirating movies and setting up a Plex server But they probably have a friend who has a friend who put in the effort and is willing to share.
- scarface74 7y agoI like to quote John Siracusa when people complain about my Plex Server. "Do not expect five 9's from my Plex Server" (https://player.fm/series/accidental-tech-podcast/ep-309-do-not-expect-five-nines-from-my-plex https://player.fm/series/accidental-tech-podcast/ep-309-do-n...) And you still have the abysmal state of upload bandwidth in the US and what are the chances that they will have all of the Disney movies?
- tbyehl 7y agoSo? Not everyone in the US is starved for upstream. Not everyone is going to lose their mind if their friend's Plex doesn't have Five 9s availability -- and let's be real, with all the things that can and do go wrong between a user and a service on the Internet, Three 9s is optimistic for anything. And whose subscription service has Fresh Prince of Bel-Air? Saved by the Bell? Countless other shows and movies that aren't available with any of them? Disney movies? Add a Trakt list to Radarr, done.
- scarface74 7y agoI have gigabit up and down via AT&T, most Americans get their internet via their cable company - cable companies always have crappy upload bandwidth around 30Mbps. People want a reliable service and will pay for it. I have no idea why this concept is forum. Hulu and Netflix publish their numbers every quarter and about 60% of households have Amazon Prime Video (https://finance.yahoo.com/news/amazon-prime-members-59-percent-of-us-households-rbc-150743767.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/amazon-prime-members-59-perce...) 76% percent of households use Netflix (https://www.bestappletv.com/news/more-u-s-households-now-have-netflix-than-pay-tv-study-says/ https://www.bestappletv.com/news/more-u-s-households-now-hav...) It’s also estimated that 40% of households will get Disney+ by 2022 (https://www.fiercevideo.com/video/a-lot-people-are-planning-to-get-disney-according-to-ubs https://www.fiercevideo.com/video/a-lot-people-are-planning-...) It doesn’t take too much to understand that enough of the American public values convenience over price to make paying for a service over the hassle of piracy worthwhile.
- ryandrake 7y agoWhy does everything have to be "streamed" these days? Hard drives are cheap. Just have a file and playback locally or on your LAN. No special set up of some server, your router, etc. Given the $/GB curve throughout the years you'll likely never run out of space. Do people really need to do a significant amount of movie watching outside their own LAN/home?
- scarface74 7y agoSo where are these files going to come from? Buying them from some place like iTunes or Amazon Prime Video - which is more expensive? Going through the trouble of finding a good rip on a torrent site? Ripping them themselves? Do people really need to do a significant amount of movie watching outside their own LAN/home? Asking this question is close to the old Slashdot meme “I haven’t owned a TV in 20 years, do people still watch TV?” Of course people watch video on mobile devices and they have for over a decade.
- ryandrake 7y ago> So where are these files going to come from? I’ve settled on buying physical media and ripping. The physical media serves as your backup in case of HD failure. > Of course people watch video on mobile devices and they have for over a decade. I suppose there are people out there who want to watch a full length movie on their 5 inch phone on a bus, but is that really a mainstream use case? I’d bet the vast majority of movie/show watching takes place in one’s home sitting in the sofa. More than willing to consider that I’m just an out of touch old guy though! EDIT (rather than replying because apparently HN doesn’t let you post more than 5 replies a day ¯\_(ツ)_/¯) Your points are taken and I guess I’m just out of touch! :-)
- scarface74 7y agoI’ve settled on buying physical media and ripping. The physical media serves as your backup in case of HD failure. Do you think most people are going to do that? I’d bet the vast majority of movie/show watching takes place in one’s home sitting in the sofa. More than willing to consider that I’m just an out of touch old guy though! Yes, you are an old out of touch guy -- no offense the 74 in my name is the year I was born. But kids especially watch a lot of movies on mobile. Most middle class adults prefer convenience over cheap and a combination of Disney+, Apple Arcade, and a $329 10.2 inch iPad in a ruggedized case or hand me down phone is a great babysitting device.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoI suggest you step outside of your circle. When I did, I found that many lower and middle class parents were using pirating setups that I didn't even know existed. For example, I learned about PopcornTime from a single parent who ran it on a laptop connected to their TV. The guy is bus dispatcher. When I need a recommendation for a streaming site or tracker, I ask my old neighbor who works as a lab tech. I've found that I'm generally ignorant of such things because everyone in my IT circle just pays for streaming services.
- scarface74 7y agoWell, which should I give more weight to -- your anecdotal experience or the published number of subscribers for Netflix, Hulu, etc?
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoThey overlap and aren't mutually exclusive.
- scarface74 7y agoOne is better to build a business off of.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoThat's fine, someone else will find a way to profit from the situation you won't consider.
- scarface74 7y agoGood luck with that with all of the content being tied up by the studios. Ask all of the money losing Android OEMs about how profitable it is in a commodity market trying to serve people who aren’t willing/able to spend money.
- camel_Snake 7y agoThere are VPS out there geared towards Plex/Torrenting. Mine costs ~$15 a month and came with all the bells and whistles installed, though I did some tweaking because I enjoy it. No need to worry about your home network speed or configuring your router, it's about the price of 1 or 2 subscription services, and I get to curate my collection of TV shows I watch so I just log in and see which new ones are available. I suppose the setup could be onerous of you find technology intimidating, but once it's working it's an absolute breeze to use. I do agree, however, that Disney's target audience is the 'I need a faux baby-sitter' type.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m speaking in general. I personally have gigabit up/down, no data caps, eight wired gigabit Ethernet connections throughout the house, 3 Roku TVs, a Roku stick 2 AppleTV 4Ks and my son has an Xbox 360 and PS4 with a wired gigabit connection on his room and a gigabit switch. Yes that’s a grand total of 6 TVs. I have a Plex server setup. But I know none of this is normal.