6 ms·
Make a healthy climate a legal right that extends to future generations
- pdamoc 7y agoThe best idea I found around this topic is https://www.ethicalsystems.org/ https://www.ethicalsystems.org/ If there is a move from shareholder primacy to stakeholder primacy, the environment can be one of the stakeholders and there could be laws preventing businesses abusing this stakeholder.
- headmelted 7y agoI was going to say this will never work, but actually I think it might with a couple of additions. You'd need this signed into international law. Mass protests could probably help with that, but you'd also need an international election drive towards green parties among the youth to get a critical mass of supporters at the UN level. You'd also need to handle enforcement and compliance, which is where these agreements have fallen down in the past. Some nations, and a lot of people, just don't care about climate change, so you'd need hard consequences for polluters. You'd also be parting oil-rich states and agricultural beef businesses from the source of their income. The farmers won't do much but the oil states would probably go to war over it. On that topic I'll say this: electric cars. Yes they still need energy, no that doesn't make it "the same as driving a gasoline car" as the EV energy doesn't have to come from fossil fuels (and increasingly is not), which means you can move at a macro level away from oil and coal over time. If you remove the demand for fossil fuels you don't need to ban them. I'm still not convinced it's impossible if we take the problem seriously and stop pretending it doesn't need a global response.
- LoSboccacc 7y agoexactly. if one can't sue China/India with it, it's toothless. next best thing would be to tariff polluting countries, but how you gonna do that fairly
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoGoing on what I see of youth I think a significant shift toward green politics, and away from "the usual suspects" is coming. Whether it is soon enough is another question. Perhaps the climate requirement needs to get incorporated in WTO and World Bank rules. Then sanction those who don't meet them...
- bryanlarsen 7y agoInternational law? That phrasing is going to turn off a lot of people. And it basically requires unanimity among nations given existing structures -- pretty much impossible. Shaping it as a trade agreement among a small set of nations that any can join should make it easier to get started, to get buy-in and to get those enforcement provisions that it desperately needs. https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/ https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoFuture generations having rights is a weird concept. If we cut science spending, can someone sue on behalf of future generations that they are being deprived of a better world. Is advocating for negative population growth a hate crime against future generations since you are trying to ensure fewer will be born? The real issue with climate change is that it is not electorally popular to do anything other than a few token gestures. The increased gas taxes contributed to the yellow vest protests in France. The Australian election upset was also spurred by concern that one of the parties would try to cut fossil fuels. I do not know that trying to do an end around the electorate and appealing to the judiciary on a novel legal theory is going to work in the long term.
- headmelted 7y agoUltimately you're right if course. The real problem is that half of the people on the planet either just don't care about climate change or believe in science, and a lot of the other half are largely unmotivated. We need to tackle the hardest problem, which is changing hearts and minds. I don't have a suggestion here, just pointing out that we need to be honest about the real problem. It's like complaining about Brexit and/or Trump. Your problem isn't the situation itself, it's that half the population looked at an option utterly abhorrent to you and said "sounds good to me".
- _pmf_ 7y agoEnjoy your precarious jobless future in a healthy climate.
- konschubert 7y agoEnjoy your job on Venus.
- whtrbt 7y agoWhat do you even mean by that? That you think a job is better than a healthy climate?
- draugadrotten 7y agoSometimes the right thing to do is just the right thing to do. It doesn't need to be justified by artificial rights to people who do not yet exist.
- King-Aaron 7y agoI seem to recall the Jetsons once coming back to sue the Earth for destroying the climate, they didn't win the case however.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoWe can be mindful of the climate, but inevitably the sun is going to explode in roughly 5 billion years (note: the earth is 4.5 billion years old, so we're roughly half way through the sun soaked portion of Earth's existence). The Earth will continue to possibly exist, but sunlight does seem critical to supporting the food chain, and more broadly, life. We can legislatively protect the Earth for the future --and it should be welcomed-- but the future is coming for us. Over extremely long horizons, no law will save us. And modern humans have only existed for 200,000 years -- would such a law protect generations that are no longer Homo Sapiens, but are our descendants? If we do indeed succeed in protecting our planet, with enough time (short by geological standards) we won't even exist in our current form.
- saagarjha 7y agoAt the risk of sounding hypocritical, I think we can ignore that issue for now.
- FranzFerdiNaN 7y agoWrap it up folks, no use doing anything at all because in 5 billion years the sun wil explode.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoI am supportive of us do something about climate change. It's just isn't a panacea to all our problems. It seems counterintuitive to be worried about climate change, to protect future generations, but then ignore planetary death because that's "too far out", when the whole premise of stopping climate change is to give future humans a shot at continuing the species.
- esotericn 7y agoYo, I've just killed your dog and reformatted your HDD. No big, the sun's going down in 5 billion years. :D
- Theodores 7y agoThe thing about rights is that we don't have any. We can make laws that give us rights to education, equal opportunities and a whole raft of things but society can be corrupt or fall to pieces. The wars we have had in recent years are proof of this, the UN rules on selling weapons are not enforced and it is the security council members that are doing all the preparations for war. For this reason we need to be discussing the climate without using the 'rights' word.
- roenxi 7y agoThis isn't a good idea; if we can justify protecting people who don't exist from consequences we do not understand then we can justify literally any inane policy. I already think it is a poor argument when applied to abortion. This direction goes pretty much directly into a world where it is impossible to use evidence to justify policy. In practice it is nonsensical to take the opinions and values of people who do not exist as evidence. If these ideas get a hold in the political sphere as it stands the politicians would have a field day justifying terrible ideas on the basis that it benefits imaginary persons. We've found precious few ways to sieve good ideas from bad apart from (1) what does everyone agree on today and (2) what does a small trusted committee think is workable. Trying to create a legal rule to protect the non-existent is an interesting experiment but also both dangerous, unlikely to work and overprivaleges the opinion of the person who speaks for the hypothetical individuals. Also as a minor point there is no way that unborn generations will feel badly about the world that they grow up in unless they are trained to. People will accept and be comfortable in the world they are born into; that is how people work. People who are born in the tropics don't curse their ancestors for not living in temperate zones, people born in arid areas don't whine about their right to live in the tropics. I don't pine for a world where I live in a small village and can see stars in the night sky, I quite like being in a big cosy city even if it is a bit bright at night and the air isn't as good and it is a bit warm. I dunno. I make a weak argument because I have no idea what the climate was like 100 years ago, my ancestors came from a different continent with a radically different climate and I don't care enough to research it.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWhat a nonsensical idea. You can't have judges writing environmental law on the basis of legal rights. And there is no such thing as a healthy climate -- an unhealthy environment is caused by local pollution, not greenhouse gases.
- polotics 7y agoI beg to differ: there is such a thing as killer heatwaves. Unhealthy climate!
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoYang proposed a constitutional amendment to ensure climate is a priority for federal and state govts. beyond a single administration: https://www.yang2020.com/blog/climate-change/ https://www.yang2020.com/blog/climate-change/
- dgudkov 7y agoHow is it more reasonable than making healthy food a legal right? Yet, I haven't heard about anyone of The Economist's scale seriously suggesting making healthy food a legal right. Maybe because it's too idealistic.