2 ms·
When I was in college, prob & stats were taught in one of two ways: 1) Memorization of formulas and rules, in the course for psychology majors; and 2) Proofs, w
by analog31 7y ago
When I was in college, prob & stats were taught in one of two ways: 1) Memorization of formulas and rules, in the course for psychology majors; and 2) Proofs, which were taught in an upper level math course.
Neither would be better than trig and calculus. Nobody remembers the formulas and rules unless they use them regularly, and a course that is heavy on proofs would be too hard for most students.
In my view there might be a third way, which is to let the teaching of prob & stats revolve around simulation, rather than by algebraic derivation (proofs) or memorization. What can you learn from a giant bag of random numbers? What if that bag is divided down the middle and given to two groups of students? What can you deduce, when you know something about a set, but not everything about it? Can you make random numbers produce outcomes that are sometimes as convincing as the outcome of an experiment?
And so on. Even to this day, if I think that I've used the correct statistical formula, I test my recollection by feeding simulated data through it.
This kind of exploration could also gently lead students into... coding.
- chii 7y agoWhile learning by simulation is going to garner deep understanding, it takes a lot longer. And in the end you end up discovering the same "formulae" (but of course having done the experimentation to "derive" means you understand it much better than if it had just been told to you).
- analog31 7y agoProbably true. There must be a balance somewhere. I also think that general math instruction should include more computation.