7 ms·
There are a chain of media reports which inaccurately portray what Stallman was saying. But look past that into what was happening. Stallman was trying to def
by colechristensen 7y ago
There are a chain of media reports which inaccurately portray what Stallman was saying.
But look past that into what was happening.
Stallman was trying to defend Minsky who had sex with someone, a teenager, nearly 60 years younger than him on a billionaire's private island. There isn't an imaginable circumstance where what happened there was not, even in the best possible light, incredibly creepy.
His intellectual arguments were understandable in a way, but in the context of defending Minsky and in the venue they were wildly inappropriate and indefensible.
It doesn't matter how "great" you are or how socially awkward, any institution should fire you for doing something like that.
- washadjeffmad 7y agoStallman wasn't defending Minsky, he was explaining why Minsky didn't need any defense with the evidence as presented. That Epstein instructed an underage to have sex does not mean that she did. RMS points out that she did not ever say that she and Minksy had sex, although the prosecutor implied it, and there was a witness account that Minsky declined and warned someone else about what happened during the event. Pointing this out should not be a problem. So please look past the media's witch hunt and into what's actually been said.
- colechristensen 7y agoI read it. I saw RMS defending statutory rape by supposing that the young woman would have appeared willing when the perpetrator, his friend, was more than four times her age. Doesn't matter if the accused event happened or not. Defending the hypothetical in that manner gets you fired.
- Allower 7y agoMaybe you never noticed but statutory rape is not rape. And its definitely not even statutory rape since he hasn't been convicted yet (innocent until proven guilty ya know..). Who cares if you find it "creepy".. thats not a reason to fire someone.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoRead it again. RMS wasn't defending statutory rape, he only wrote to not use the term "sexual assault" when there was no evidence of violence being involved, because words have actual meanings and using wrong words confuses the issue.
- rhcom2 7y ago"sexual assault" doesn't require violence.
- Anthony-G 7y agoThe problem is with the ambiguity of the term. From a legal perspective, "sexual assault" doesn't require violence but for ordinary people, use of the term implies some sort of attack or aggression. It's only a few years ago that I learned from online discussions that in some jurisdictions the term "assault" has a specific legal meaning that does not imply violence.
- josefx 7y agoHe also redefined the legal term sexual assault in the discussion. According to him Minsky was at the very least innocent of sexual assault because having access to a dictionary let him conclude that assault implied violence[1]. There are winning arguments to be had, unless we adopt GNU/law that isn't one. [1]https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6405929/09132019142056-0001.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6405929/091320191...
- mtrower 7y agoHe did not say Minsky was legally innocent of sexual assault (he in fact gave no opinion of guilt). He said that sexual assault is a poor term, for reasons of broadness and vagueness, and that we should avoid using such terms in order to avoid ambiguity. He brought up the definition of "assault" because, as a component of "sexual assault", it colors the term, shifting connotations towards the side of violence. He didn't redefine the legal term, he just (tl;dr) said it sucks and we shouldn't use it (and instead should use something more specific).
- josefx 7y ago> He did not say Minsky was legally innocent of sexual assault (he in fact gave no opinion of guilt). That part of my comment was overly sarcastic. I have to apologize for that. > He said that sexual assault is a poor term, for reasons of broadness and vagueness, and that we should avoid using such terms in order to avoid ambiguity. I would say that the term is intentionally broad and vague precisely because violence is only one of many ways to force an unwilling participant and how it was done is mostly irrelevant to the end result. > he just (tl;dr) said it sucks and we shouldn't use it (and instead should use something more specific). As far as I can tell he never actually brought up a more specific term and just disagreed in a rather non constructive fashion against the use of both sexual assault and rape, even when someone explicitly referred to laws.
- jaxbot 7y agoIt also wasn't in isolation; he made very similar remarks in 2006 on his blog that he got flak for, but people mostly brushed aside as 'oh, Stallman..' Comments here seem to mostly equate this situation to a Cancel Culture outcry over an isolated remark. That's not what happened here. rms has had decades of inexcusable behavior for any individual, much less someone affiliated with MIT and heading something as large as FSF. He had to answer for this eventually. I sincerely appreciate his contributions to this world. But I also sincerely feel that we can't give people free passes for their behavior (see: courtesy cards at conferences) just because they've done well in other respects. We need to end the acceptance of Brilliant Jerks.
- mangodwango 7y agoHis Behavior being commenting or having opinions on things we don’t agree with? I think he should be able to say whatever he wants, and further that in this instance his comments have been taken wildly out of context. I hate this morality police sweeping in saying that he simply can’t talk about this because it is forbidden, wrong, etc. The majority should not decide what is ok speech or thought, we should judge him by what he has actually done, and challenge his thoughts directly with reasoned argument rather than immediately dismiss and denounce anything that isn’t in the moral majority.
- roguecoder 7y agoYeah, you can’t excuse pedophilia in decent society because it puts kids at risk. Legally you can say whatever you want, but legally no one has to employ you when you do. Freedom of association is just as important at freedom of speech.
- freedomben 7y agoI agree regarding freedom of association and its importance. But, are you ok then condemning people to homelessness and poverty? It sure seems to me like you are viewing that as a perfectly acceptable punishment for saying something unacceptable.
- dependenttypes 7y ago> There are a chain of media reports which inaccurately portray what Stallman was saying. Here for example https://techcrunch.com/2019/09/16/computer-scientist-richard-stallman-who-defended-jeffrey-epstein-resigns-from-mit-csail-and-the-free-software-foundation/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/09/16/computer-scientist-richard... It went from "defended Minsky", to "Victims Were ‘Entirely Willing’" to "defended Epstein". > Stallman was trying to defend Minsky who had sex with someone I think that he was just trying to be rational. But being rational against a lynching mob is not a good idea (and hasn't ever been in human history). > but in the context of defending Minsky and in the venue they were wildly inappropriate and indefensible Would you mind expanding on that? Say that someone claimed that Stalin drank the blood of his victims, would it be "inappropriate and indefensible" to try to debunk such a claim (and thus defend Stalin) in the process?
- colechristensen 7y agoThere is a rational thing RMS was doing, supposing that Minsky's accuser would have appeared willing to him with the implication that in there was a defense for Minsky's behavior (hypothetical or not). The problem is defending a man accused of statutory rape by saying his accuser appeared willing. Everything else is irrelevant. And it wasn't a situation where there was the slightest bit of ambiguity. 17 and 73. Billionare's private island. Defending that situation - real or hypothetical - is very problematic. It gets you fired. There might be a very narrow context in which a discussion of that nature would be appropriate. Where it happened was a million miles from there.
- dependenttypes 7y ago> The problem is defending a man accused of statutory rape by saying his accuser appeared willing How is that a problem exactly? > 17 and 73 Would her being a 18 prostitute change anything in your eyes? Because I am pretty sure that most 17 year olds can easily be confused with 18 year olds and the reverse. > Defending that situation - real or hypothetical - is very problematic. It gets you fired. In our current "cancel culture" society, agree.
- codyb 7y agoSomeone on Reddit says the deposition states that a bystander saw Minksy turn the 17 year old down. However I can’t seem to find the original documents to verify that. And reading too much about Giuffre, my god. The list of powerful people. Epstein must of had blackmail on everyone. Almost like a cartel leader in their nation, he made big philanthropic donations for good press and then kept many of the world’s richest and most powerful people under his thumb.
- colechristensen 7y agoHow many of those kinds of things do you think we don't or won't know about?
- frabbit 7y agoFeel free to discard the following as "conspiracy" but it is interesting: https://www.counterpunch.org/2019/08/16/la-danse-mossad-robert-maxwell-and-jeffrey-epstein/ https://www.counterpunch.org/2019/08/16/la-danse-mossad-robe...
- giancarlostoro 7y ago> There are a chain of media reports which inaccurately portray what Stallman was saying. Why the hell the Media never puts up links to direct sources is what frustrates me the most. There's been some bad cases of this lately.
- colechristensen 7y agoThe media coverage I found of this was actually very well sourced with references to other articles and ultimately the original email thread in question. The analysis and statements in the articles were often ridiculous and had little connection to the original material (even the article publishing that material) other than exaggerating someone else's article in a perverse game of telephone.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThat's one media outlet of very few one's but there's a lot of other ones that have a lot of "he said she said" thrown around. It becomes harder to form a conclusion without sources.
- Beltiras 7y agoStatutory rape is not "having sex". Even if you make the girl a year older I am not sure the situation changes very much. The power dynamic is not allowing her a lot of free choices.
- speeder 7y agoSaw your post is recent and noone is debunking this so I should... Minksy DIDN'T had the sex. What the court documents said is: A woman, that at the time was 17, said Epstein told her to OFFER sex to Minsky. And another person that was present, Greg Benford, said that Minsky refused the offer. Nowhere was stated that sex happened.
- balaksakrionon 7y agoIs it a fact that Minsky had sex with the girl?
- pknopf 7y agoWhen you grow older, do always keep your attraction within your age? Is it only moral for an older 70+ year-old-man to be attracted to an equally aged woman? Of course not. Then, where is the line? If not 18, then, 25? 30? I get why it would be creepy from the perspective of the woman wanting to be with an old man, but why exactly is the man himself a creep? IMO, all adults are attracted to the younger opposite sex. Men have a biological drive to be attracted to women who will give birth to healthy babies, survive the birth, and live long enough lives to ensure that child is supported. I'm 30 now. I hope people never regard me as a creep for masterbating when I'm 60 to the teen section of PornHub.