13 ms·
RMS has called himself "borderline autistic". His socially clueless black and white thinking makes it look like he is far in the spectrum. RMS is anal about
by nabla9 7y ago
RMS has called himself "borderline autistic". His socially clueless black and white thinking makes it look like he is far in the spectrum. RMS is anal about meanings of terms and their use. That's not working well in the current climate where words carry perceived intent. I find myself agreeing with RMS with most of the terminology and its use in this case. Women who tell stories about him paint a picture of lonely socially incompetent man who makes super creepy attempts to connect opposite sex.
I have worked in jobs where there have been very strange creepy people, both women and men. Some are angry and tense. Some are odd and talk restless or slightly disturbing stuff that make everyone uncomfortable. But if they do their work well they can stay. Others give them some room. It's called tolerance.
If RMS was just random superhacker doing his thing. I would defend him. His boss should find a position for him where he can contribute and other people should feel free to feel uncomfortable and avoid him.
But RMS is de facto leader and public figure in movement that is also political. He does not deserve the same level of consideration as normal HR headache would. Even if everything against him would be completely unjust, there is no requirement for just treatment for top leaders. They can be sacked for any reason whatsoever.
- mnm1 7y agoThis is ridiculous in a culture that elected and continues to support an accused rapist to its highest office. If the highest office in the nation (and many others) can have such a scumbag without him being forced to resign, how can we expect someone in Stallman's position to be perfect and PC with his speech so idiots don't misunderstand his direct style of speech? Such hypocrisy, such bullshit, this argument is.
- pjc50 7y agoThe President "should" also be forced to resign, but the power politics does not support that for a whole host of reasons. It's extraordinary to watch "Christian" evangelical moralists defend him, but in some ways that's the logical conclusion of their moral contortions.
- AnnoyingSwede 7y agoThen again, if someone believes a man in the sky created the world in 6 days, claims the earth is 6000 years old, ... , what stops them from defending the POTUS? Why expect logic where no other logic seems to apply?
- rightbyte 7y agoIt doesn't really matter for most decision wether the universe came to being 6e3, 6e9 or 12e9 years ago, or always has been ... unless you are a geologist.
- 1000units 7y agoI hereby accuse you of raping me. You're an accused rapist.
- urbanjunkie 7y agoPathetic woman-hating loser. You are a weak, uneducated, ignorant coward. I'm sorry your mother failed you so badly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- davidy123 7y agoBy evicting him, and finding someone who's better, making the parameters more clear each time. Who can say what would have been in place if a particular leader hadn't? They take oxygen. Some would even say we should move away from the model of a few leaders representing many.
- egdod 7y ago> accused rapist That’s the standard for being “canceled” now? An accusation? Anybody can accuse people of things. We have courts and the presumption of innocence for a reason.
- GVIrish 7y agoCredibly accused rapist. The courts are for determining whether someone should go to jail. But anyone can draw conclusions about whether or not they want to deal with someone who is accused of a crime. Someone might be accused of child molestation, but never stood trial. Would a parent then be obligated to be ok with the accused being alone with their children since 'hey he's innocent until proven guilty'? Should someone who had been credibly accused of many instances of sexual misconduct be trusted as if they are a model citizen? The presumption of innocence is there to ensure someone gets a fair trial in court. It doesn't mean everyone else has to ignore evidence of criminal conduct until a conviction comes down. It also doesn't always mean that someone who was found not guilty by a criminal court, didn't actually do what they were accused of. It just means the court didn't find guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoOut of curiosity, what is "canceled"? I haven't seen it used before.
- kube-system 7y agohttps://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Cancelled https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Cancelled
- Kye 7y agoThis culture didn't elect him. The culture that created the Electoral College did. This culture voted overwhelmingly for the other option.
- mnm1 7y agoA nomination to one of the two major political parties says plenty enough about the culture that allows this while targeting people like Stallman who haven't actually hurt anyone for their unusual opinions.
- Scarblac 7y agoWell, he started the movement and got it very far, with the dominant OS using his foundation's license. Despite his limitations. There is no one in the movement who should have the authority to sack him. But, he resigned himself. This is moot.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe president of the United States never fires anyone. He informs them he expects their letter of resignation on his desk at x time. FSF was pressured. RMS did not decide this all on his own of his free will.
- jessaustin 7y agoWhy does Trump care about free software?
- heisenbit 7y agoThere are numerous reports that he asks someone to ask the person expected to resign to pen such a letter.
- nabla9 7y agoFSF board of directors could have sacked him. RMS probably realized that he damages everything he has worked for if stays, or others convinced him.
- bubblethink 7y ago>But RMS is de facto leader and public figure in movement that is also political What does this mean ? He is a leader of an organisation related to software freedom (or more pedantically, the choice of licences used for software). How is it relevant ? All you are saying is, "Famous people can't talk like that".
- toomanybeersies 7y agoIf you are the leader for an organisation focused on advocacy (i.e. raising awareness and communicating), then your words become de facto the words of the organisation, even with comments not related to your organisations purpose. If your leader appears to advocate pedophilia, then your organisation no longer becomes "that organisation that advocates for free software", but "that organisation run by a pedophile apologist".
- robocat 7y ago> If your leader appears to advocate pedophilia He doesn't advocate pedophilia. Nothing has changed for years. Are you advocating it? He has just been completely misrepresented by some popular media as supporting statutory rape, and you are fueling the fire. It is pure bullshit - the journalists that write (or publications that publish) headlines that completely reverse meaning should be held accountable for their lies. It is libel: make it appear Richard said she was willing when he definitely said she was coerced (within the exact same paragraph as the "quote"). Seems she was 18 too - any organisation publishing clearly slanderous headings designed for sensation and payment for eyeballs should be punished.
- CJefferson 7y agoThe pedophilia advocating is much earlier. From his website (the last sentence is his opinion) Dutch pedophiles have formed a political party to campaign for legalization. [Reference updated on 2018-04-25 because the old link was broken.] I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily pedophilia harms children
- michaelmrose 7y agoTop leader of a staff of 11 and a budget of <doctor evil> 1 million dollars </doctor evil>
- flukus 7y agoYou write this like it's an insult, but with a dozen stuff and million dollar budget he's done more for the world than most of us could do with 1000 staff and a billion dollar budget. That's a testament to his vision and leadership.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 7y agoI wrote it as a poke at the parent poster who suggested that top leaders should expect to be held to different standards than the rest of us when speaking of a man who enjoyed none of the perks of being a "top leader" while contributing a lot.
- nabla9 7y agoThe scope of and influence of nonprofits can't be measured in staff and budget. Linux foundation and FSF have small staff and budget but the total economic value of the projects they steer is in tens of billions.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSo the lesson is: Don't selflessly give your work away for nothing out of idealism lest it improve the world in some fashion all out of proportion to the budget involved because, if you do, we shall surely expect your head on a pike at some point for some wholly unrelated personal gaff. Rather than, you know, finding some humane, compassionate approach to dealing with the personal shortcomings of someone who has done so very much for the world.
- 7y ago
- kelnos 7y agoCan we please stop excusing bad behavior with some form of "oh because autism"? It's an insult to the many, many neuro-atypical people who don't say shitty, stupid things online, who don't act creepy around women, who don't have a sign on their MIT office that says "Knight for Justice (Also: Hot Ladies)", who don't have a gross mattress in their office where they encourage people to lie topless, who don't try to pressure women into dating them by saying they'll kill themselves otherwise. All of those things describe RMS, things that have been mostly quietly ignored and hand-waved away for decades. We don't have to tolerate people who make women feel unsafe and unwelcome in our (or any) industry. You seem to be arguing the usual tired old thing: "but he's a genius and does such great work that we should tolerate the bad things he does". I really thought we'd started to move past that over the last few years.
- saruji 7y agoIt is you and those like you that make people feel unsafe and unwelcome. RMS is quirky and weird and he says what many don't feel safe to talk about. The recent assault based not on fact or principle but rather implied (assumed)intent is a farce and wont lead to good things. Tech is dead and RMS is a fallen king. Take your PC bullying and wreck havoc over everything the geeks or "autists" created. I'm moving on but the industry is no longer a place of inclusion and all of the safe guards put in place were not enough to stop societies wicked. Enjoy eating each other in your Brave New World.
- Angostura 7y ago> Can we please stop excusing bad behavior with some form of "oh because autism"? It's an insult to the many, many neuro-atypical people who don't say shitty, stupid things online. No it's not an insult to anyone. It's an attemoted explanation of why some neuro-atypical people behave in atypical fashion.
- kelnos 7y agoAre you, or the parent, a mental health professional? If not, then I'd suggest you aren't qualified to tell if he's even autistic at all, or, if he is, that his autism is what's causing the problems here, not terrible beliefs, behaviors, and attitudes. In that light, using autism as an excuse for Stallman's behavior is just an unfounded theory by an armchair psychiatrist with no business making diagnoses.
- LaGrange 7y ago> RMS has called himself "borderline autistic". As someone actually autistic, he doesn't get to blame being a douchecanoe on being autistic. > His socially clueless black and white thinking makes it look like he is far in the spectrum. Then _learn_. Also, we're not talking about not getting social cues about when it's okay to start talking, we're talking his considered and repeated position on issues such as sexual assault, and his _actual actions_ towards teenagers. > But if they do their work well they can stay. Others give them some room. It's called tolerance. Great tolerance for the people your creeps chase out or abuse, thanks. You actually do have to pick, and if you pick people like RMS, you pick against all the people that can't - and shouldn't have to - deal with an environment people like RMS create.
- nabla9 7y agoI'm sorry if I communicated badly. English is not my native language I was trying to give explanation, not excuse. I was trying to communicate understanding, not acceptance.
- Jedd 7y ago> As someone actually autistic, he doesn't get to blame being a douchecanoe on being autistic. Was he a douchecanoe? Is that even a helpful label for you to apply to him? Was he claiming he behaved / behaves the way you think he does solely because he's borderline autistic, or are you extrapolating?
- LaGrange 7y ago> Was he a douchecanoe? Yes. > Is that even a helpful label for you to apply to him? Yes. > Was he claiming he behaved / behaves the way you think he does solely because he's borderline autistic Yes.
- Barrin92 7y agoSad to see that you're being downvoted. Richard Stallman's insane statements about child abuse have nothing to do with autism. The man has defended pedophilia and apparently also harassed women throughout his career. Absolutely disgusting behaviour that has nothing to do with being neuro-atypical.
- mantoto 7y agoHe said things as a certain role model or in a setup where he shouldn't. It's just reasonable to remove him from those positions. Independly I find it very weird what he was saying nonetheless and for this he falls under a category of humans which I don't think are worth it to give such amount of support. There are other people out there which are worth it more. I stopped working with people who might be technical good or very good but dicks. I hate working with dicks. There is no amount of brilliance which justifice being a dick.
- raxxorrax 7y agoHe is the founder of the FSF. He advocated free software so that it is accessible to anyone. But sure, he is probably a dick so let us remove them... You know what? He actually probably isn't the easiest person to be around. Just saw him once and he certainly isn't the guy to move crowds. But let us be certain that we have very distinct definitions of what constitutes "being a dick".
- badumtss 7y ago> Women who tell stories about him paint a picture of lonely socially incompetent man who makes super creepy attempts to connect opposite sex. Really?
- teachrdan 7y ago"When I was a teen freshman, I went to a buffet lunch at an Indian restaurant in Central Square with a graduate student friend and others from the AI lab. I don’t know if he and I were the last two left, but at a table with only the two of us, Richard Stallman told me of his misery and that he’d kill himself if I didn’t go out with him." https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-appendix-a-a7e41e784f88 https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-appendix...
- brlewis 7y ago> That's not working well in the current climate where words carry perceived intent. I agree that there's a current climate that's even less amenable to open discussion than at other times. However, I disagree that words carrying perceived intent is something new. Any time you make an assertion about individual facts of a particular situation, people's first assumption is going to be that you're pushing the narrative best supported by that assertion. Telling people what you're not saying will continue to be important even if the current climate improves. EDIT: To clarify, I'm stating a general principle, not saying anything about what RMS did or didn't say, or did or didn't intend to say. I don't have time to dig into all that.
- dangerface 7y ago> He does not deserve the same level of consideration as normal HR headache would. Even if everything against him would be completely unjust, there is no requirement for just treatment for top leaders. They can be sacked for any reason whatsoever. The only people who deserve less consideration are those that pick and choose who to treat justly.
- lliamander 7y ago> But RMS is de facto leader and public figure in movement that is also political. He does not deserve the same level of consideration as normal HR headache would. Even if everything against him would be completely unjust, there is no requirement for just treatment for top leaders. They can be sacked for any reason whatsoever. If his past behavior was sufficient justification for his sacking, then that should be enough. However, that is not why he was sacked. He was sacked on the basis of false allegations, and as an attempt by MIT to deflect from their own complicity in the Epstein scandal. This is not (only) about finding a place for weirdo super-hackers to contribute to society (without bothering people too much) but about the truth dammit.