10 ms·
Attorney here! (Not legal advice, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.) Don't get me wrong, but easyDNS may be jumping hastily to conclusions. I
by otterley 7y ago
Attorney here! (Not legal advice, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.)
Don't get me wrong, but easyDNS may be jumping hastily to conclusions. In many countries, soliciting business there makes you subject to its jurisdiction and laws, regardless of where your business is based.
I don't know German law, but I hope that easyDNS consulted their own attorneys on the subject before publishing this post, or they could potentially end up quite embarrassed.
- manfredo 7y agoSo any DNS registrar that registers sites accessible in Saudi Arabia is subject to its blasphemy laws? Without any presence in foreign countries, the most the foreign country can do is block the offending website or infrastructure provider. I guess they could also request extradition, but most countries only extradite citizens if what they did was also illegal in the home country.
- otterley 7y ago"Make accessible"? That, alone, is probably insufficient. But if you advertise there or otherwise target its nationals, then it is much more likely. Enforcement is, of course, a separate matter. The country may not be able to reach you without some sort of agreement with your home country; but if you ever visit a country with which it does have an agreement, you could find yourself taken away to answer to the law.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hyperman1 7y agoWell no. There was one case where the USA couldn't reach a company in another country, so the next time an employee came on holiday to the USA, he was thrown in jail. Don't remember the details, unfortunately.
- OatMilkLatte 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd.
- alistairSH 7y agoDeBeers (the diamond company), perhaps?
- rndgermandude 7y ago> So any DNS registrar that registers sites accessible in Saudi Arabia is subject to its blasphemy laws? Well, yes, kinda. But the Saudis will not be successful in extraditing you, most likely. However they can still block your services, and Allah help you if you decide to travel there after you've been found guilty of violating their laws. Then again, not as bad as the US is on and about... Just ask Mr Dotcom...
- Joakal 7y agoAsk Hew Raymond Griffiths too. Given to USA on a silver platter by Australia despite not making any profit.
- marcus_holmes 7y agoNope. The USA is extraditing Kim Dotcom from New Zealand because he (allegedly) broke US laws. Note that he did not break any NZ laws. Assange and Wikileaks is similar - Assange is an Australian citizen in the UK, but is being extradited to the US for breaking US law via a website. He is not being charged with any offences (to do with this) in either the UK or Australia. If your website blasphemes and can be reached from Saudi, then the relevant authorities there could push for you to be extradited to face charges in Saudi (if your country and Saudi have an extradition treaty). It doesn't happen, but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen.
- jascii 7y agoIs there any indication that they solicited business in Germany? And how, in practice, could they enforce that if this canadian entity has not broken any canadian law and canada as such has no impetus to enforce german law?
- johnnyfaehell 7y ago> Is there any indication that they solicited business in Germany? My understanding is making the website available to a country can be soliciting business. > And how, in practice, could they enforce that if this canadian entity has not broken any canadian law and canada as such has no impetus to enforce german law? Don't they have deals for such thing? I remember reading that a British court judgement for damages could be enforced in the US.
- jascii 7y ago> My understanding is making the website available to a country can be soliciting business. Oh dear, that would make publishing any website extremely dangerous..
- aeorgnoieang 7y agoThey could arrest their officers if they're ever in Germany (or maybe the EU).
- otterley 7y ago> And how, in practice, could they enforce that if this canadian entity has not broken any canadian law and canada as such has no impetus to enforce german law? Many countries have signed treaties that provide for enforcement process for judgments rendered in another signatory. It's in the spirit of reciprocity. If Canada wants to be able to reach a German national, Germany will insist on a reciprocal arrangement to reach a Canadian national. (I don't know whether they have such an agreement, but such agreements are common.) Contrary to what a lot of HNers may believe, judicial and procedural boundaries aren't necessarily coextensive with national borders.
- 7y ago
- StuntPope 7y agoeasyDNS here. 1) We do not advertise in Germany. 2) Our client is not German.
- jiveturkey 7y agoYou might like to update your blog post with that info. I came here with the same thought, assuming that your client was German. But it seems you are just a third party, and good luck to them.
- tzs 7y agoDo you have other clients who are in Germany? It appears that you do act as a registrar for .DE domains. At least, entering "ascascdasdcascascascasdcasdc.de" on the search on the front page at https://easydns.com/ https://easydns.com/ offers to register it for me. It's purely a guess on my part, but I'd expect that most people who purchase .DE domains are in Germany, so if you've actually sold a few .DE domains you probably have some German customers. That might not be enough to open you up to having to worry about German law...but it is enough that I would not dismiss that possibility out of hand. PS: your site seems partly broken. I first tried to check for .DE on this page: https://easydns.com/domains/register/ https://easydns.com/domains/register/ Entering "ascascdasdcascascascasdcasdc.de" on the search there does nothing for me in Firefox. I had uBlock Origin on, so turned it off. Still nothing. Then I switched to Chrome, using a profile with no relevant extensions, and still nothing. So instead I just went to the list below that lists all the TLDs you handle, and went through to find DE. That has a "Special Requirements" link, which doesn't do anything for me in either Firefox or Chrome. PPS: in Firefox's console, it shows these messages for that page that isn't working right: 'Loading failed for the <script> with source “https://matomo.int.easydns.net/piwik.js”." https://matomo.int.easydns.net/piwik.js”." at register:1:1 'unreachable code after return statement' at signup.js:15:1
- kuschku 7y agoIn fact, to be able to offer .de domains as registrar, you have to join DENIC, and .de domains can only be owned by a legal German person, and always have to have an actual German person as representative. To me this looks like German law definitely applies to them.
- bloak 7y agoI'm guessing easyDNS doesn't have "attorneys". The article does, however, mention "lawyers": "both easyDNS and our lawyers take a dim view". (Random terminological observation deleted.)
- chooseaname 7y agoAn attorney is a lawyer, though a lawyer isn't necessarily an attorney. Why are we picking nits over this?
- bloak 7y agoIt's not my intention to pick nits. I was just pointing out that easyDNS had consulted lawyers and making a random terminological observation in a parenthesis. Perhaps random terminological observations annoy people? I'll delete that part.
- nexxius13 7y agoI didn't see the observation you made, but I see that easyDNS is in Canada. For clarity, it is not the norm to refer to a lawyer as an attorney in Canada (except in a few specific circumstances).
- kevin_b_er 7y agoIts a huge problem for businesses that operate on the internet. It can magically make you subject to all laws worldwide, at once. You cannot comply with them all.
- otterley 7y agoAt least in the U.S., it does not. There's actually a reasonably decent Wikipedia article discussing the case law on the subject: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_jurisdiction_in_Internet_cases_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_jurisdiction_in_Inter...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe issue is to think that a single website and a single way of doing business is all you need on the web. But in fact companies like Amazon have customised sites, T&Cs, and procedures for every country they operate in because they have to comply with many different legal systems. But that does not mean that operating a business on the web in a single country makes you liable throughout the world. That being said, accepting a foreign customer might make you liable to the law of that customer's country.
- cesarb 7y ago> In many countries, soliciting business there makes you subject to its jurisdiction and laws, regardless of where your business is based. That line of reasoning always sounded tautological to me. "Law X from country A says that by doing Y you are under jurisdiction of country A", but for "law X from country A" to apply to you, don't you have to already be under jurisdiction of country A in the first place?
- jerf 7y agoLaw is ultimately shared consensus. We build an abstraction layer on top of that but sometimes the underlying nature can't help but shine through.
- icebraining 7y ago> for "law X from country A" to apply to you, don't you have to already be under jurisdiction of country A in the first place? No.
- walrus01 7y agoI'm sure I have something on a public httpd somewhere my company owns that is insulting to the Thai king. Better look out, I'm going to Thai prison for lese majeste!
- cat199 7y agoActually had a customer (or just angry netizen) complain about this at a hosting company. Was very satisfying to return our boilerplate about how we were in 'murica and this didn't apply.
- paulie_a 7y agoThat is why I am confused why so many websites put up warning banners about gdpr. If you don't do business in Europe it doesn't apply to you. A large chunk of the internet is USA based
- FDSGSG 7y agoJudging by their ToS, I wouldn't be so sure that easyDNS has attorneys.
- gist 7y ago> In many countries, soliciting business there makes you subject to its jurisdiction and laws, regardless of where your business is based. As a practical matter seems unlikely that this particular law firm is going to go to the mat in terms of any possible enforcement action (and that assumes it can even be done or attempted by teaming up with a firm in Canada (where easydns is from what I am reading). Very generally also I don't think it's a good idea for a company (and in particular a small company) to air publicly something like this. It leaks details on how they act and what they will do that could be used against them by another company in the future. In otherwise the publicity could end up being counterproductive.