11 ms·
Being ‘Indistractable’
- mapcars 7y agoTLDR: a guy can't just turn off his phone for a couple of hours and creates a whole new philosophy out of it.
- arethuza 7y agoThis made me think of "focus" from Vinge's "A Deepness in the Sky" where individuals are converted to narrow their entire life down to a particular subject area so that they can be used as components in distributed systems. Edit: One of the reasons for requiring this kind of approach is that they don't have "real" AI for reasons that would only be apparent if you have read the earlier novel.
- bitwize 7y agoLiterally, weaponized autism.
- arethuza 7y agoI seem to remember that there is a discussion at the end of the book where characters discuss whether focus is worth it as a tool for society and perhaps even something that individuals would choose willingly. I suspect if focus was available as a medical procedure there are people who would choose it - not something that you would be able to regret. Edit: Greg Egan's excellent Quarantine also has the protagonist using "neural mods" to prime him into a state where he was a more effective policeman - but at least they could be turned on/off rather than being semi-permanent like focus.
- manigandham 7y ago> “I suspect if focus was available as a medical people” What does this mean?
- xtiansimon 7y agoMust have been a slip of the tongue. Post-human.
- arethuza 7y agoApologies - I wasn't focusing enough on my comment and wrote nonsense! ;-) Fixed now.
- goatinaboat 7y agoAlastair Reynolds also has characters who are mentally hyper-specialised in order to operate certain technologies, to the extent that they are effectively a part of the machine
- bitwize 7y agoSo... accurate description of long-time Googlers?
- onion2k 7y agoWhen I'm doing something that's both interesting and challenging I can happily ignore literally everything else until I'm done. I think most people are very similar; phones and games and Slack messages are only a distraction if you're just not that into what you're supposed to be doing. If it happens a lot you might need to address that problem.
- vegardx 7y agoThis sounds similar to what people on the spectrum of autism or adhd call "hyper-focus". The problem with hyper-focus is that you rarely have control over it. It's heavily skewed towards the interesting part, not what you need to be doing or how challenging it is. You'll often see absurd levels of complexity for the sake of making it challenging, only to support working on something interesting.
- glaberficken 7y agoI was distracted by this headline. now.
- shortbunny 7y agoAs someone with attention defecit disorder, I can only applaud the further development of attention-as-a-skill, be it by introspection (e.g. meditation) or technological (e.g. parmacological) enhancement!
- playing_colours 7y agoIn my opinion, based on my personal observations, reading and listening to smart people of the past and present, the most important skill, even meta-skill, for every time and epoch is self-discipline - the ability to do things you need to do tolerating discomfort and suffering. Suffer now to thrive later. The epoch one lives in and their social position will dictate critical skills an individual requires to survive and move up - be it martial prowess, persuasion, focus. People with strong discipline can grow those skills quicker and farther. A good inspirational example for me was in David Goggins’ book “Can’t Hurt Me”, where he vividly describes his inner fight against his mind that always wants comfort now; he shares that the main reason he tortures himself with physical challenges is not to become physically strong, but to grow an armored mind, one that is prepared for real life struggles.
- gexla 7y agoSelf discipline is one of the psychology things which might not actually be a thing though. Often cited in this sort of discussion is the "marshmallow test" which has been found to be BS. Maybe there's something to willpower, but the discussion is stinky right now because of the replication issues. Same for "flow" which is another smell this article and related discussions have. I find that I can be incredibly self disciplined when I setup my environment so that I don't have to fight myself. How do I fight distractions from my phone when I'm out with friends? I don't bring my phone. And yet somehow I always manage to meet with people at the time and place we decide on. I know not everyone can do this, I'm just using it as an example. A feeling of a lack of self discipline is a symptom, much like procrastination. It's a mess of things all clumped together like a rats nest of wires. Everyone has their answer to procrastination (the book is in progress!) but beating procrastination isn't a skill because it isn't the root problem. Much like a headache could mean that you are going to die from cancer or you might just need some rest. If you feel you have procrastination problems, it's because something broke upstream and now you are blaming it on procrastination. ETA: Herding my own actions is about preparation and personal story telling. If I setup a clear path for the next day and get good sleep, then it will work. If I get a bad night of sleep and I'm unorganized, then it's going to be a disaster and I'm going to complain about procrastination. If I see a cake which looks good and I have a weak reason not to eat it, I'm going to eat the thing. If I manage to convince myself to join the cult of low-carbs, then I wouldn't be caught dead with a piece of cake. If I'm working with people who are laid back, then I become laid back. If I'm working with people who are ultra-competitive, then I become competitive. It's all about pouring the kool-aid and then convincing myself to drink it. ;)
- ohduran 7y agoAnd yet, here we are, posting comments on HN. By the way is not being able to hear your daughter screaming for attention because you're deeply focused on your phone being distracted, or not? Sounds like laser focusing to me. Which means that it's not a matter of being 'indistractable', but one of prioritising what's worth your attention. On a side note, I don't like when people make up words like 'indistractable', but that's personal taste.
- afarrell 7y agoWe all have multiple roles in life we’d like to play. And limited time/attention/energy. So we look back on our time and ask “was I the person I want to be in that moment?” And hear our intuition sigh “no...”. But we were. In that moment reading an article on your phone, you were the well-informed citizen living the life of the mind, which is something you aspire* to be. But you couldn’t simultaneously be the caring father. And the regret of that moment stings more sharply than the satisfaction of thinking about the article you read. One theory I have for how to be more focused: narrow or combine your set of things you aspire to. This is hard. If you aspire to be both a caring father and a moderately-skilled hobby carpenter, you might find your daughter is interested neither in woodworking or in having a treehouse. And so in any given hour, you must choose. (* assumption I’m making about you just so I can write less abstractly)
- gniv 7y ago> On a side note, I don't like when people make up words like 'indistractable', but that's personal taste. It's likely that the success of this book will rely entirely on this word. After all, Cal Newport wrote recently on the same subject, so I'm not sure what this book brings new, other than the catchy/annoying word.
- ohduran 7y agoI loved Cal Newport's book. It's insightful, and full of takeaways, drawing from years of writing about the topic on his blog. While reading it, I was constantly looking on the Internet for the references and pieces of research that he was mentioning, the kind of reading you are meant to do when you are doing research on a certain topic, and him being a researcher has that kind of style that for the interested reader is full of depth. On the other hand, you have an annoying, made up word and the work of someone whose sole purpose at work is, and I quote, "help tech companies build products to keep you clicking". Now if I skip the mumble jumble of #likes4likes that you usually find on Amazon five star reviews, I can find a 3 star review that weighs the pros and cons. Pros: He knows a lot about distraction. Which makes sense; he does that for a living. Cons: the solutions. > Make a contract with yourself, he says. Make a money contract. If you fail to keep the contract you have to set fire to a hundred dollar bill. That's it. I'm choosing Cal Newport's "Deep Work" every single time.
- gexla 7y agoGets distracted. Thinks long and hard about distraction. Has an insight on how not to get distracted. Writes a book about it. Writes a blog post to market the book. Future book reviews complain that you could have just read the blog post. Some of this seems to be a rehash of GTD. Sometimes your distractions are something which you really need to do. Write it down so that you can feel at ease forgetting about it again. Then when you are doing your GTD thing, you can take care of your list. The rest just doesn't sit easy for me. It seems like he's over-rationalizing a certain slice of life and it feels strange, like a bad aesthetic. There's work time and then there's personal time. In each case, distraction is okay, it's just that you need to herd the distractions so that you are seeing more of X distractions and less of Y. A client walking in the door may be a valuable distraction. Getting a FB notification while working may be a costly distraction. Personal time is also all about the right distractions. Interesting things are distractions. In the author's example, the child asking a question is a distraction. We can argue semantics, maybe an interesting thing which captures your attention is called something other than a distraction, but it's still the same thing. Your brain is pointed in one direction and something comes along to redirect that attention to something else. This is just more productivity porn. Schedule fun time. Look, it's fun time on my calendar. I will enjoy it. I'm having fun... for 20 minutes.
- deepGem 7y ago"Sometimes your distractions are something which you really need to do" The key is to be able to determine the validity of the distraction, without getting distracted, meaning without even diverting your mind a bit to think about the distraction. I don't think you can. You need to context switch a bit, examine what the distraction is and then switch back. Easier said than done. It leads to a trail of IFTTTs since every distraction has it's own context and lifespan. If someone has ways of accomplishing this, I'm all ears.
- gexla 7y agoI'm getting into personal anecdote territory which I hate because it likely only works for me, but here I go... When I'm working in front of my computer, I manage this stream by keeping a log of what I'm doing in an editor. When I step into something, I make a quick note of what I'm about to do. I may annotate it with what I DID rather than what I'm about to do. It's fully shooting from the hip. The point of it is that I can always bring it up and see the last thing my brain was on and the stream leading up to that point. I call that section "stream." I'll add other "sections" for other items I need to take down. Maybe I think of a todo, then I'll make a section for "Todo" and maybe even multiple lists for multiple projects. This document is only meant for things which collect in my head as I'm trying to do this other thing. It's not meant to be storage space for project management. The starting of a disaster day is finding myself getting bogged down in reading a pile of browser tabs in the morning during my "putter" time. In that case I'll open a blank editor tab to start the "stream" and create a section for reading. I'll jot down the items which interest me the most, bookmark those items, then clear all tabs. I'll NEVER get back to reading those things, but I took care of the problem in my head and then I get back to "streaming." It's all about one of the core GTD ideas of clearing your space and writing things down to comfort your brain. The main stream section then keeps me on task. I have also trained myself that this is the most important rule and if I don't have this document open in an editor, then I'm asking for trouble.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chesneyc 7y agoThe Pomodoro Technique has helped me a lot staying focused on my work and studies. Sure, it's not a silver bullet solution to manage distractions but it's a good starting point.
- ExtremisAndy 7y agoThis. The Pomodoro Technique has revolutionized my life. I set it for 30 minutes and tell myself "You just need to make a little progress on task X for 30 minutes... You can do it!" What very often happens, however, is that since I have focused so well during that period, I actually end up completing the task, usually with a few minutes to spare. Feels a bit ridiculous, but, at least in my case (anecdotal, for sure), just giving my brain the 'peace' in knowing that it will only have to focus deeply for 30 minutes seems to help it immensely. Human beings are so strange.
- benoliver999 7y agoI have a 30 minute egg timer I use for this, and it's pretty decent. Mainly serves as a reminder to get up and walk about.
- ptah 7y agoweird, he literally wrote the book about making websites and apps addictive through grabbing as much attention as possible. now he's got a book on how to avoid getting distracted by those sites/apps
- tonyarkles 7y agoMeh, people are allowed to change their minds about things they've done once they've seen the effects of their prior work. At the start of this post he uses that as evidence that he's qualified to write this book; I don't disagree.
- godelmachine 7y agoIs “indistractable” a proper word?
- crispyporkbites 7y agowhat's a proper word?
- godelmachine 7y agoA word recognized in the English lexicon
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lwh 7y agohyperfocused?
- commandlinefan 7y agoI'm shooting for indestructible, myself.
- jankotek 7y agoI hope not. Many people in open-space offices with smart phones have attention span of a chipmunk. That makes it possible for remote workers to compete :-)
- sytelus 7y agoI think this would be the single most important differentiator for wealth creation. The world would be divided between creators and consumers. The consumers are increasingly trained for only consuming with a singular goal of generating wealth for the creators.
- lopmotr 7y agoI'd say that title goes to intelligence, which can't be trained so people are going to consistently have either a lot or a little their whole working life. Technology is progressively taking away the ability of low IQ people to do anything productive at all and giving it to a shrinking pool of people smart enough to do the remaining not-yet-automated things.
- psychoslave 7y agoJust skimming the post, it seems to be highly convergent with what is used in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)[1], or more generally of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). The article doesn't seem to point to such a connection, but people interested with the topic might like to have a look at these well documented methodologies. Analyzes and critics of these methods and their claimed results are also widely available. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acceptance_and_commitment_therapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acceptance_and_commitment_ther...
- nice-family 7y agoWow. Completely wrong in every way. First of all, that's exactly the primary symptom of autism. Overly fixated obsessive concentration, with a pathological, neurotic unwillingness to change focus. And then, on the other hand, we've already spent the past 20 or 30 years diagnosing attention disorders as mental illness, when children refuse to engage with genuinely boring school curriculums. And what do they get for it? Prescription speed, so that they obsess and associate the school work with the drugged up motivation, and become conditioned like a trained dog to go into study mode for the stimulant rewards. So don't act like this is a new idea. And don't act like it didn't already produce back to back drug epidemics (first crystal meth, then opioids). And, worst of all, don't act like the polar extremes of this idea haven't already been clinically diagnosed as mental illness, as a means to extract good grades from children with no natural reason to enjoy the daily hell of compulsory public school.
- baxtr 7y agoRight now, I am being distracted by reading the comments to this blog post on HN...
- ukj 7y agoI am a master at being 'indistractable' - my brain-CPU does not support interrupts. P.S my manager calls me 'uncooperative'.
- abacadaba 7y ago:closes HN tab:
- huntertwo 7y agoDoes anybody feel like these kinds of posts over-rationalize life? I feel like these complex logical guides can be replaced with a simple “put your phone away while spending time with your daughter”. Life should be simpler than having to think about all this stuff so hard. Life shouldn’t be an optimization of resources problem.
- Japhy_Ryder 7y agoYeah, I completely agree. Not only these kind of posts, but 99.9% of self-help books too. The answer, in general, comes down to: get good rest, meditate, drink enough water, and get some damn work done. Coffee as needed.
- eswat 7y agoPart of the problem that I realized after hearing the author promotin this book in a podcast is that many people not only want to solve problems but also put their own spin/branding on it, even if it’s not actually much different from existing solutions. But that slight difference in the new solution being promoted taps into our brains just in the right ways that it makes existing solutions seem inferior, thus the productive porn.
- Torwald 7y ago> Part of the problem that I realized after hearing the author promotin this book in a podcast is that many people not only want to solve problems but also put their own spin/branding on it, even if it’s not actually much different from existing solutions. Yes, but they also have to do it in order to have a branding. You cannot "non-brand." Take for example Microsoft. Thy wrote a version of CP/M and called it PC-DOS. So what? Would it have been better to call it MS-CP/M?
- crispyambulance 7y agoI think many people crave an authoritative voice that tells them what they need to do. It's why the self-help industrial complex works. It can get much worse than a navel-gazing/over-thinking-it post on medium. These kinds of blog posts easily segway into books/media, then courses, then workshops, then, before one knows it thousand dollar hotel conference room shindigs where people end up with binders and get a hard sell on ever more expensive "help". Not saying the author is one of these snake-oil people at all. But it's a slippery slope from, say, Tim Ferriss to Ramit Sethi to Tony Robbins to (what's that "bitcoin genius"?) James Altucher.... and worse.
- bencoder 7y agoSee also: Cal Newport's Deep Work [0] [0] http://www.calnewport.com/books/deep-work/ http://www.calnewport.com/books/deep-work/
- m_ke 7y agoIt's ironic that the author who introduced a ton of tech people to psychologically manipulative product design with his book "Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products" is now selling the solution to the problem that he helped create. Here's how he described his last book: --- How do successful companies create products people can't put down? Why do some products capture widespread attention while others flop? What makes us engage with certain products out of sheer habit? Is there a pattern underlying how technologies hook us? Nir Eyal answers these questions (and many more) by explaining the "Hook Model" -- a four steps process embedded into the products of many successful companies to subtly encourage customer behavior. Through consecutive “hook cycles,” these products reach their ultimate goal of bringing users back over and over again, without depending on costly advertising or aggressive messaging. Hooked is based on Eyal’s years of research, consulting, and practical experience. He wrote the book he wished had been available to him as a startup founder – not abstract theory, but a how-to guide for building better products. Hooked is written for product managers, designers, marketers, startup founders, and anyone who seeks to understand how products influence our behavior. --- To top it off he's trying to growth hack his new book by putting a branded red "do not disturb" sign in the book, that he expects you to put up on your desk for all of your stressed out colleagues in your open office to see. (https://youtu.be/XVbH_TkJW9s?t=906 https://youtu.be/XVbH_TkJW9s?t=906)
- drankula3 7y agoIronic? It makes sense to me that someone who understands the mechanisms of addiction would know how to break the cycle.
- m_ke 7y agoIt's ironic in the "we'll sell you opioids and then help you treat the addiction" sense, not the "we know how to make oxycontin so we're experts in addiction treatment" sense. https://www.statnews.com/2019/01/30/purdue-pharma-oxycontin-maker-explored-addiction-treatment/ https://www.statnews.com/2019/01/30/purdue-pharma-oxycontin-... I read Hooked and Nir Eyal obviously knows what he's talking about, I'm not questioning his authority on the subject.
- 7y ago
- mosselman 7y agoOff topic to the article, because I can't read it. I blocked Medium's annoying pop-up and now there is no way for me to click somewhere to open the article. Ah well, I'll just see this as a step towards being indistractable by medium articles.
- knob 7y agoEliminate all notifications from your phone with a 1-second 'empty' .mp3 I set this empty.mp3 as my notification (android) for emails, texts, applications, etc etc. The only thing that makes a sound in my phone is phone-calls and alarms. Eliminate the "top bar" notifications too. If you want to find out about emails, open the app. To find out about instant messages, open the app. For me this has been absolutely great. I don't have social media installed (reddit, facebook, twitter, etc), so that helps. Yet the phone doesn't "suck me into it". I hope somebody finds this useful!
- atrilumen 7y agoI know it's off-topic, but fuck Medium. No, I don't want to join. From now on, I will not click links to Medium! (I'm tired of deleting their stupid cookies just to read a goddamned blog post.)