6 ms·
There are a bunch of us out there that still believe in the vision. You were just too early. This needs some sort of WRT54G kinda moment, synology or ???, you n
by sitkack 7y ago
There are a bunch of us out there that still believe in the vision. You were just too early. This needs some sort of WRT54G kinda moment, synology or ???, you needed to have a last mile partner or a host (vpn in to services). I thought containers were going to take over cloud in a pervasive way and it hasn't happened yet.
I can't say thank you enough for what you have done. None of this was a failure.
- anderspitman 7y agoWe'll get there. I don't believe for a minute that kentonv doesn't still plan on being a part of that future. > This needs some sort of WRT54G kinda moment, synology or ???, you needed to have a last mile partner or a host (vpn in to services) While I love the idea of everyone running their own hardware, I've been thinking recently that physical separateness might be the least important aspect of decentralization. I think alignment of incentives is more important. What I mean is that having your apps/data on google's servers isn't necessarily a problem, but being locked into their platform and unable to easily change is. When it's simple and convenient for customers to change providers, companies are incentivized to maintain high quality products and features such as privacy guarantees.
- kentonv 7y agoI agree, but I add one thing that I've seen a lot of decentralization efforts ignore: If I decide to move servers, I need to be able to take with me not just my data, but my software (apps). Otherwise, self-hosting tends to mean accepting second-rate software, and choosing the best software means also choosing the servers provided by the same company. These should be separate decisions.
- oscargrouch 7y agoIm creating something that take this into account; you should have a embeddable/movable entity where you keep your data, api´s and apps. And i tell you its a lot of work.. Was following Sandstorm closely, and despite the fact that im going with different choices compared with Sandstorm, your project was one that i instantly recognized to be tackling in the same domain. I mean, i think your meditation and problem solving are in the right place, we just need a couple more iterations , research and efforts to get there. I will try to give it a shot too, been working on this on a couple of years over the chromium codebase, with a design that was not quite right in the beggining, that needed couple more of iteration and tought, but that in the current incarnation, i think i might have something to show. I hope i can count with your comments and criticism when i launch it, which i believe, its only a couple of months from now, as i have a great respect for your work and your vision. You helped to move the needle forward in a domain we need desperately of a solution or else all of our data and freedoms are at stake (not to mention it can even be a better technology than the current cloud-corporate centric vision that are designed to maximize corporations profit and data centralization, where we dont actually own anything, anymore). So thanks for all of your work, it was really inspiring.
- solipsism 7y agoI need to be able to take with me not just my data, but my software (apps) Can you give an example of what you're talking about here?
- oscargrouch 7y agoNot the parent, but i understand this as the paradigm that containers and VM´s use for instance. Your applications and executables are also part of the data and move together with them.
- ithkuil 7y agoYes, you can already install an application in a VM or container (or just instantiate one of the many ready to use images out there; shameless plug https://bitnami.com https://bitnami.com). But sandstorm is something else. It composes well. You can have an application that is a good document editor and another one that offers a spreadsheet that works for you, and have a unified layer that handles identity, authorization, document management (collections, sharing). Short slogans as "liberate your data" or "self host your apps" focus on the end goal without highlighting what is really stopping us from doing it: the integrated, cohesive experience many of us expect/need, especially in the enterprise environments. I recently went through an acquisition where we had to switch from gsuite to office 365. Oh my. What a mess. In the ideal world we would have had our stuff in sandstorm grains, and after the merger our new colleagues would have access to them even if we wouldn't necessarily have picked the same spreadsheet app for example. Now, for those of us that Word doesn't work well and were happy with Google Docs, well, we don't have a choice: we cannot possibly give a gsuite account to every employee in the larger company and thus we have to migrate in order to not preclude potential collaboration
- kentonv 7y agoI mean that if I think Google Sheets is the best online spreadsheet software, but I don't want to store my data on Google's servers, I should be able to run Google Sheets on some other servers. I shouldn't be forced to use some other, worse software if I choose different physical hosting. These should be independent decisions. SaaS providers basically have vertical monopolies here and I think that hurts consumers.
- gbear0 7y agoI just found out about this project from this post, and I've spent my whole night reading up on it and the ecosystem and its past. I LOVE the vision and was so excited to read about it, but then sad to realize I'm joining the party too late. It's been a roller coaster of a night. I think the most important piece of tech that Sandstorm was working on was the capability based security and the powerbox concepts (which I recognized as being similar to Android's capability apis but for the web). I don't see the decentralized data or local servers being an easy sell any time soon, but I can see the capabilities security working really well within the browser, and more importantly with existing SaaS ecosystems. If we could get a new browser API for websites to offer to register available APIs for jsonschema based type defs through a manifest file, then users could allow those APIs to be included in their local browser registry. Other pages could request (or offer) data from those APIs, and with the user's permission, the browser could do the necessary oauth handshake and use the API, passing data to/from another service in a secure way behind the scenes. As well since it would be a browser API, a webpage looking to call an API would be able to request provider info and show the appropriate in-app UI for selecting a service, which sounds like one of the problems Sandstorm had. No one would have to worry about whether they implement a dropbox api or onedrive api, the page would just have to show the 'file service' selector and call the user selected api with a file. So I'd expect every SaaS out there would jump at the chance to provide an easy access way for users to use and pay for their service. Furthermore, the browser could provide external connectors as well so I could have some native external app that registers a provider with the browser, allowing me to send my in browser data to an external native app (or vice versa). For example right click menu on a .drawio file and send to DrawIO or send to the currently opened Google Slide. Or send a contact from your fav web contact manager to the your native Skype app. Seriously I can think of so many uses for this! And it fits in perfectly with the existing file or clipboard apis as well. I hope someone sees this excited rant and can make it happen! :) I also really do hope the work that's been done in Sandstorm continues on and pushes things further for all of us. Thanks!
- icebraining 7y agoI think that idea was the concept behind WebIntents/WebActivities, which were explored by the Chrome team and by Mozilla. Efforts seem to have stalled, though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Intents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Intents