4 ms·
Excuse my utter ignorance. Isn't Mainframe just powerful Servers? At least I thought the term meant ( or used to ) mission critical and massively powerful. Now
by ksec 7y ago
Excuse my utter ignorance.
Isn't Mainframe just powerful Servers? At least I thought the term meant ( or used to ) mission critical and massively powerful. Nowadays I could get 2S EPYC 2 with 128 Core and 4TB of Memory. What makes a IBM Server with POWER10 any more reliable than a powerful x86 Server? After all many SuperComputer are now running on x86 as well.
Or are we now using the word Mainframe specifically for IBM products? Rather than a category of its own?
- marcosdumay 7y agoHistorically, mainframes have a different architecture from servers. Specifically, they have redundant power supplies, IO buses, memory buses and CPUs. So you can even install or remove memory or CPUs from them without turning them off. Today, servers are adding redundancy where it matters most, but they still have a different philosophy where you should think about adding or removing servers, instead of components.
- jjuhl 7y ago"So you can even install or remove memory or CPUs from them without turning them off." - I did that with IBM pSeries servers decades ago and with commodity Linux servers running on x86-64 hardware within the last couple of years. That's not reserved for mainframes.
- cat199 7y agoagree those particular technologies are not now mainframe exculsive - however mainframe grade systems allow switching / reconfiguring all components on line. E.g. plug in a new processor unit (e.g one of N processor racks plugged into the system bus), new IO unit, new disk unit, replicate all data, move all jobs, decouple the old one so that after the operation is complete 0% of the old hardware is running and 100% new, with no downtime.
- abtinf 7y agoMainframes are a category of their own and IBM is the last company in the category. Mainframes have spectacular capabilities, like running a compute on multiple CPUs in multiple data centers to ensure integrity and survivability built in so that any software can take advantage of it. They have the lowest transaction processing costs of any machine. They detect hardware issues and phone home to order repairs without user intervention. And on and on and on. Quite frankly, a lot more companies should be using IBM mainframes than trying to build a reliable infrastructure on the cloud.
- sjg007 7y agoI wonder if there are any startups out there that resell mainframe services presented and organized akin to the aws type of view.
- lanstin 7y agoFew orgs wants to pay for reliability/quality. Whether hardware or software costs. They are ok with a bunch of 99.5 or 99.9 availability systems. With no thought for high availability deployment.
- pjmlp 7y agoUnisys still hasn't given up.
- JerryL 7y agoIt's a mainframe as in the category (nowdays, only IBM and Unisys are left). You are buying a mainframe, not just a CPU and a mobo like AMD EPYC. You expect serious RAS. This mainrame comes with spare CPUs for reliability, it has redundant power supplies. It has 99.9999% availability. Additionally, they come with massive I/O subsystem with drawers of PCIe connections and various other connections.
- superflit 7y agoThe mainframe is a different beast. Can you change physically change CPU, Memory, and internal components without any stop/delay? Not only the Mainframe is Very robust it was made not to stop. I used to work on a Data Center with Sparcs, Intel, Blades servers, and Mainframe. The only time I saw the Operator with Fear was when he had to turn off the Mainframe because of electrical maintenance. The last time he did shutdown the Mainframe was 15 years ago. VMs? The mainframe has it since the '60s. IO? The mainframe is a BEAST on IO Backward Compat? IBM guarantees that your code from the '40s will run today. The whole research in mainframe is to Be a powerful beast with high availability and safety. If you may check more about it, it is a part of Tech that is very beautiful yet.
- snazz 7y ago> Backward Compat? IBM guarantees that your code from the '40s will run today. I hope this is exaggeration, because I don’t think you’ll be running Colossus “code” (from the first programmable digital electronic computer) on your z15 :) Your point still stands. They’re in a different class from x86 machines.
- njharman 7y agoThe Model T Ford and Honda Civic are both cars. It should be obvious that any modern car is massively more reliable, safer, and has capabilities the T can’t even dream of. Commodity x86 and mainframes are both computers. But are as different as T and Civic.
- D-Coder 7y ago"Car analogies are the Rolls Royces of analogies."
- floatboth 7y agoPOWER is not mainframes, z/Architecture is mainframes.