9 ms·
New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and Nickel
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- layoutIfNeeded 7y agoI’ll believe it when it ships in my phone. Otherwise the usual response to battery tech news applies: k keep me posted.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoMore than likely you’ll see it in electric vehicles and utility energy storage first.
- hanniabu 7y agoAny market usage would be nice. Unfortunately what typically happens is there's an article about a huge breakthrough and then we never hear about it again.
- notatoad 7y agoand yet battery capacity keeps on increasing... "We've made a breakthrough in battery tech" is a news story. "We've increased the battery life in our phone by 5 hours" is a news story. "We've increased our profit margins by 5% by eliminating nickel from the battery in this phone" is not a news story that gets reported, but that doesn't mean the advances in battery tech aren't being used.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ori_b 7y agoThe stories that get reported are almost never in the product that gets shipped. It's like the endless stories about new types of transistor. Computers are faster, but our transistors are not made of diamond or nanotubes or DNA.
- OrgNet 7y ago> and yet battery capacity keeps on increasing... my phone was lasting about one-day-per-charge 10 years ago... it's about the same today
- memling 7y agoMight compare capacity?
- OrgNet 7y agoI would rather have the same phone that I had 10 years ago if it meant that it would last 7 days with today's batteries
- rohan_shah 7y agoI have a feature phone, ironically lasts about 7 days. Recently purchased.
- snovv_crash 7y agoHave you tried turning off your screen, data connection, wifi, gps, bluetooth and NFC? 7 days of battery life is easy...
- OrgNet 7y agoI haven't figured out how to use my phone with the screen off... what's the trick?
- rohan_shah 7y agoThe processor is atleast 100x more powerful. The display is 100x better. Speakers, cameras, sensors all have advanced. And yet your battery still lasts on one-charge-per-day. That must be surprising.
- OrgNet 7y agobut it is not 100x as useful...
- PorterDuff 7y agoIt depends on the use case of course. Low cost with no other constraints is good for utilities, medium cost with smaller size and weight for vehicles, high cost/high capacity/small-light for portable devices. Since the rest of electric cars is essentially designed, I'm looking forward to someone who really cracks the battery problem. It's a real game changer for a large part of everyday life. No wonder the car companies are thinking twice about building new ICE models, the world could change in a minute. Question: Is there a graphable Moore's Law at work for batteries?
- fortran77 7y agoSo you don't want to know about _anything_ until it's available inside phones that you can buy today? I personally like to know what may be on the horizon. It's interesting to read about it, and remember it one the day it arrives (or something else does)!
- lolive 7y agoWeb developpers had a similar habit. It eventually got a name: "the javascript fatigue".
- toast0 7y agoNot the OP, but... Strictly in phones I can buy today? Not really. Plausibly in phones (or something in a normal household) in the next 3-6 months, sure. I'm just tired of hearing about battery advances in labs that never make it out to me. Just let me know when I should be prepared to change my purchasing decisions.
- takeda 7y ago> Plausibly in phones (or something in a normal household) in the next 3-6 months, sure. I don't know, I remember reading 25 years ago about this awesome technology called OLED that instead of blocking light it actually lights up and you can even bend the display!
- CamperBob2 7y agoIt would be different if we didn't get the exact same story every week, seemingly.
- rohan_shah 7y agoYou are right, but the pace at which the battery news is coming these days (frequency), has certainly increased many fold. Can't wait to have 1Kwh under $50 if this "double the capacity" ever actually comes true though!
- eigenloss 7y agoMany Chinese suppliers are already operating at or below the $100/kWh mark.
- baybal2 7y agoThere is an already cobalt free lithium battery chemistry there LiFePO4 — been in use for more than a decade, and is a preferred one by commercial and heavy duty EVs because of superior battery life at the cost of capacity. The new chemistry mentioned has no commercial use cases unless it beats LiFePO4 in its niche or surpasses mainstream chemistries, which is a big stretch. BYD intentionally went full in onto LiFePO4 because they very well foreseen cobalt shortages.
- p1mrx 7y agoLiFePO₄ is also useful for replacing alkaline batteries in small devices, because the cell voltage (3.2V) is approximately 1.5V x 2.
- Gibbon1 7y agoOther advantage is LiFePO4 is a lot safer than cobalt based batteries. My company abandoned cobalt lithium ion batteries in our products because installers will mount our product in utility closets and then people will do things like store cardboard boxes in there.
- mitjak 7y agocardboard boxes. in closets?!?!
- maxerickson 7y agoThey mean that the space should be set aside for the equipment, not used for the equipment and also storage.
- zdragnar 7y agoGiven the opening reference to safety, I'd assumed the problem work cardboard boxes was fire risk.
- dmix 7y ago> Iron fluorides have more than double lithium’s capacity of traditional cobalt- or nickel-based cathodes. In addition, iron is 1/300th the cost of cobalt and 1/150th the cost of nickel. I'm curious how much the cost of cobalt/nickel is relative to the whole battery's cost. The lowered geopolitical risks and general availability could be significant regardless.
- rohan_shah 7y agoLithium itself is ~79%, Both Nickel and Cobalt are less than 4/5% each.
- starky 7y agoWhat do you mean here? Lithium is a tiny portion of a li-ion cell, about 1g in an 3600mAh 18650 cell. There is significantly more of Nickel, Manganese, and Cobalt in an NMC cell for example.
- eigenloss 7y agoThis comment is meaningless without clarifying - which chemistry is being discussed - what these percentages represent: weight, volume, or cost There is no lithium-ion battery (NMC/NCA) where Li corresponds to 79% of any of those.
- vasili111 7y agoSome information about battery parts cost: https://about.bnef.com/blog/behind-scenes-take-lithium-ion-battery-prices/ https://about.bnef.com/blog/behind-scenes-take-lithium-ion-b...
- m3kw9 7y agoMaybe one day they will eliminate the lithium needed as well
- forgotmypw 7y agoWithout JS, this page is blank. With JS, it is a clusterfuck. Text is below. New Lithium Battery Design Eliminates Costly Cobalt and Nickel A new cathode and electrolyte are the key to doing away with these increasingly scarce metals in lithium batteries. Stephen Mraz 1 | Sep 12, 2019 Lithium-ion batteries have gained in popularity over the last decade based on their higher power and small size. But their popularity is straining the world’s supply of cobalt and nickel, two metals used in lithium batteries. As a result, prices for those metals have skyrocketed. To develop alternative designs for lithium-based batteries with less reliance on those scarce metals, researchers at the Georgia Institute of Technology have been looking into new cathode and electrolytes to replace the expensive metals and traditional liquid electrolyte with lower cost transition metal fluorides and a solid polymer electrolyte. “Electrodes made from transition metal fluorides have long shown stability problems and rapid failure, leading to significant skepticism about their ability to be used in next generation batteries,” says Gleb Yushin, a professor in Georgia Tech’s School of Materials Science and Engineering. “But we’ve shown that when used with a solid polymer electrolyte, metal fluorides show remarkable stability, even at higher temperatures, which could lead to safer, lighter, and less-expensive lithium-ion batteries.” In typical lithium-ion batteries, energy is released during the transfer of lithium ions between an anode and a cathode, with the cathode typically made of lithium and transition metals such as cobalt, nickel, and manganese. Ions flow between the electrodes through a liquid electrolyte. The Georgia Tech researchers fabricated a new type of cathode from iron fluoride and a solid polymer electrolyte nanocomposite. Iron fluorides have more than double lithium’s capacity of traditional cobalt- or nickel-based cathodes. In addition, iron is 1/300th the cost of cobalt and 1/150th the cost of nickel. To produce such a cathode, the researchers inserted a solid polymer electrolyte into a prefabricated iron fluoride electrode. They then hot pressed the entire structure to increase density and eliminate voids. The polymer-based electrolyte is flexible so it can accommodate the swelling of the iron fluoride while cycling and forms a stable and flexible interphase with iron fluoride. Traditionally, the swelling and side reactions have been key problems when using iron fluoride in batteries. “Cathodes made from iron fluoride have enormous potential because of their high capacity, low material costs, and the broad availability of iron,” Yushin says. “But changes in volume during cycling, as well as parasitic side reactions with liquid electrolytes and other degradation issues, have limited their use previously. Using a solid electrolyte with elastic properties solves many of these problems.” The researchers then tested several variations of the new solid-state batteries to analyze their performance over more than 300 charging and discharging cycles at a temperature of 122⁰F. They found that the new batteries outperformed previous designs using metal fluoride even when these were kept cool at room temperatures. The researchers determined that the key to the better battery performance was the solid polymer electrolyte. In previous attempts using metal fluorides, it was believed metallic ions moved to the cathode’s surface to eventually dissolve into the liquid electrolyte, causing a capacity loss, particularly at elevated temperatures. In addition, metal fluorides catalyzed the rapid decomposition of liquid electrolytes when cells operated above 100⁰F. However, at the connection between the solid electrolyte and the cathode, the solid electrolyte remains stable, preventing the electrolyte from dissolving. “The polymer electrolyte we used was common, but many other solid electrolytes and other battery or electrode architectures, such as core-shell particle morphologies, should be able to dramatically mitigate or even fully prevent parasitic side reactions and attain stable performance characteristics,” says Kostiantyn Turcheniuk, a research scientist in Yushin’s lab. In the future, the researchers aim to develop new and improved solid electrolytes to enable fast charging and to combine solid and liquid electrolytes in new designs fully compatible with conventional cell manufacturing used in large battery factories.
- starky 7y agoIt is impressive that the article actually addressed the issue of the cathode expansion, as that was my first worry about using iron, but not one that most people would be aware of. I'd be interested to hear about the cycle life of these, the 300 cycles mentioned in the article doesn't exactly inspire confidence when something like NMC will reach 1000 cycles.
- RRRA 7y agoWhen are we getting lithium graphite batteries which are supposed to be not dense and a lot safer than LiPo? I mean, to the point you can buy one for toys, drones, cell, etc
- acd 7y agoIs it possible to recycle Lithium batteries to recover the metals in them? That should be better for the environment and the metal source does not diminish.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYes. This is done routinely for laptop and phone batteries. I googled some numbers for you: https://recyclinginternational.com/batteries/the-unknown-success-of-lithium-ion-battery-recycling/26899/ https://recyclinginternational.com/batteries/the-unknown-suc... Apparently close to 100K tonne of lithium batteries were recycled last year which amounts to about half of the volume of batteries that should have reached their end of life around that time. Not very surprising as the metal is valuable and the recycling process is fairly straightforward. Apparently, recycled lithium has some nice properties that results in slightly better batteries even. I'd expect that with car batteries, recycling will be very big business. Dumping hundreds of kilos of valuable materials in a land fill is not going to be a thing. They recycle pretty much all of the steel in cars as well.
- IndrekR 7y ago> Apparently, recycled lithium has some nice properties that results in slightly better batteries even. What are those?
- eigenloss 7y agodang, please change the link to this: https://www.greencarcongress.com/2019/09/201090911-gatech.html https://www.greencarcongress.com/2019/09/201090911-gatech.ht... Much more information and a link to the actual paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-019-0472-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41563-019-0472-7
- alkonaut 7y agoI wonder how these breakthroughs (if they eventually turn out successful and make the previous process uneconomical) affect the “gigafactories” under construction worldwide? Is a change like this going to render a factory useless if it was built for the “previous” process? Or is this something that can be retrofitted quite easily into an existing manufacturing process such as in the Tesla/Panasonic Gigafactory?
- cududa 7y agoSee the second to last paragraph of the article. Dr. Goodenough’s glass based battery is incompatible with the gigafactory, however this would be compatible-ish with existing manufacturing techniques
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tasubotadas 7y agoShould I sell my Cobalt futures then? Or is it one of those "battery-breakthroughs" that we are not going to hear again ever?
- towaway60 7y agoI've been wondering the same thing. Unfortunately it's really hard to tell.
- scythe 7y agoSo this is pretty cool, as a GT alum. Caveats are: - The article contrasts the price of iron and cobalt. It’s true, but fluoride is more expensive than iron. Still cheaper than cobalt, though! - This is a very new chemistry, which means a lot of scale-up work will have to be done before it becomes commercial. Other technologies have stalled at this phase, like nanostructured Si anodes and S cathodes. In particular, polymer electrolytes can be easy to manufacture or not. - Li-ion batteries typically perform better at higher temperatures. The tests in this article were performed at 50 C, which may not translate to practical performance in an environment which is often below 0 C. Also, 300 isn’t really that many cycles.
- ahmtokta 7y agoI have heard that these batteries are used for small and long-distance remote systematic agricultural products and machinery.