5 ms·
Tesla mentions that the mechanical components of the traditional wiper blade create a lot of friction, which requires more power to the motor that moves the arm
by userbinator 7y ago
Tesla mentions that the mechanical components of the traditional wiper blade create a lot of friction, which requires more power to the motor that moves the arm back and forth.
I thought it was the friction of the wipers themselves on the glass that takes the most power...
In any case, some research reveals that typical wiper motors are <50W, which even if that was reduced to 0, would be an insignificant fraction of the total power draw of an EV, the motor powering the car being capable of over 200kW (200000W). I doubt this is going to have much of an effect on the overall range.
- kenhwang 7y agoFor 50W, you may as well dim the infotainment display and turn off the music for more power savings.
- majewsky 7y agoThat's a worse slogan though. Compare "Now with 10% more efficient windshield wipers!" and "Now with 10% dimmer screens!"
- Scoundreller 7y agoUsually when it’s raining there isn’t much need to run the display at full brightness. It’s largely a wash.
- Brakenshire 7y agoHm, even LED TVs use something like 30W, don’t think you’d get much out of dimming a tablet sized screen. 50W for 5 hours is 250Wh, which is a mile extra range. That’s worth having.
- kenhwang 7y agoTesla's speaker system is 200/560W. So it's possible to get to 50W just from screen and speaker savings. And that's assuming constant worse case use of the wipers: high speed and full load like you're driving through a waterfall. Pulling up a spec sheet for a wiper motor, it looks like normal load is only supposed to draw ~6-10W.
- jerf 7y agoThis sort of thing is why I refer to "the noise floor" in these sorts of discussions. It's not that it's untrue that it may save a mile of range, it's just so dominated by other factors that it doesn't matter. Your human cognitive spotlight is focusing on this one fact, and it may be "true", but that doesn't make it important. It's not worth engineering effort to save amounts of power that will be casually wiped away by any number of little things. (Sometimes you can bind together several little things into one big one worth doing, but human intuition is still often broken by the factors of magnitude involved. 6 %.0002 things still don't add up to anything significant, for insurance, even if it may feel like six things ought to matter.)
- close04 7y agoOn the other hand even a 1 mile (probably less) saving over a 5 hour (~200-250mi) trip through the rain might as well be a rounding error regardless of the fuel used. Many other methods for achieving the same saving are not as flashy though. I imagine the most important way is to ensure optimal tire pressure at all times. Many people tend to ignore this even when having pressure sensors at hand which leads to a whole lot of wasted fuel. The reason wipers only received minor optimizations over the decades is because they work well, are cheap and enviably reliable. So any new wiper system design has a high bar to pass, beyond using new tech.
- 7y ago
- hadlock 7y agoSilicone wipers naturally leave behind a thin silicone film on the glass. Once this film is in place, the water serves as a pretty decent lubricant so long as it's raining.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI’ve found that a windshield at a shallow angle and RainX can negate the need for wipers at high speeds.
- BoorishBears 7y agoIt can negate the need for a roof at high speeds, which has saved me on many road trips (but be careful about driving fast in the rain)
- LoSboccacc 7y agoi wonder how high pressure air nozzles would fare in this application. have a small reservoir of water dispersant that get nebulised from the nozzle themselves every box and then and just push water around with the nozzles at low speed
- mikro2nd 7y agoMuch more significant to me is the clear vision it affords when you come up behind a large truck/semi in wet weather. Makes passing at least possible, as opposed to being stuck, unable to pass, in a cloud of dirty water for long stretches of time.
- frosted-flakes 7y agoYou can test this by putting your wipers on high when the windshield is dry, then spraying washer fluid. The speed will increase dramatically.
- simias 7y agoI think it's fairly obviously mainly a marketing move. These wipers (judging by the drawings) look cool and futuristic. If they ever implement them I'm sure that's going to be the main motivation. I can be very critical of Tesla but if there's one thing they achieved it's making electric vehicles that look cool. I don't think many teenagers saw a Prius as an aspirational vehicle but I'm pretty sure you could find Tesla posters in many a bedroom.
- Udik 7y agoThe only possible thing I see of practical value in this solution is that it might (might, not sure I understood well) reduce the amount of moving parts and gears. Essentially the entire motion would be controller electronically, no gears or motors.
- balfirevic 7y agoElectronically controlled motion by means of magnetic fields is a motor.
- close04 7y agoGiven the current reliability of classic wiper systems I don't think this is the improvement. Part of the reasons classic wipers have multiple moving parts (basically motor + rack and pinion) is that you want to guarantee they stay in sync and never overlap. You can put 2 simple motors on them for similar effect like the Tesla design. Tesla's solution focuses on design rather than better technical specs. The claim that "the electromagnetic moving block induces minimal friction" says very little considering you achieve the exact same effect with a classic wiper arm mounted on a single electric motor. You probably want more than one arm anyway.
- gist 7y ago> I think it's fairly obviously mainly a marketing move. I wonder though if it's the right marketing move and the right deployment of resources. Car manufacturers found out a long time ago that car sales are not driven by these types of improvements. Cars are purchased emotionally and to a lesser extent functionally. Obviously a Tesla is an emotional purchase since it doesn't really make sense for most buyers to burden themselves with the higher price and inconvenience of an electric car. This seems a great deal like a little icing on the cake of 'we are just a better purchase down to this type of detail'. That's separate from the GP assertion that there is little power savings. Sure it gets employees thinking of power savings (similar to when Apollo was done everything mattered down to the last detail). But the development and implementation of this is not trivial and it will take meetings and decisions and testing. What else could be done with those resources?
- phkahler 7y agoThe maximum power of the car is not relevant to range. A Tesla uses between 200 and 300 Watt-hours per mile if I recall correctly. A Watt-hour (Whr) is a one watt load used for an hour. If it takes you 5 hours to deplete your battery, a 50W load for 5 hours will use 250 Whr. You will lose 1 mile of range because of it. When doing motor control work and dyno testing, one of the challenges is measurement of mechanical power (and even electrical) because you need to measure up to -200kW but you care about differences of 10s of Watts.
- mehhh 7y agoComparatively, it takes me about 20 watt hours to 40 watt hours per mile to get around in hilly Seattle at a cruising speed of 20mph to 30mph. Heavy cargo & towing can push my power usage up to 50 watt hours per mile. Note that all numbers are based on no pedaling.
- otroqueccorre 7y agoDefinitely. In my opinion, it is a marketing strategic movement to show the innovation levels of Tesla company, but for sure, this new system is not going to change the world as we know.