2 ms·
You're being skeptical for the wrong side. We humans have a long, inglorious history of inventing objective metrics that absolutely fail to be useful at predic
by timr 18y ago
You're being skeptical for the wrong side. We humans have a long, inglorious history of inventing objective metrics that absolutely fail to be useful at predicting the things we want to predict. From the IQ tests to the NHL combine, we're traditionally quite awful at inventing predictive tests of performance.
Which is to say: if you're being intellectually honest, you should be far more skeptical that a test does what it claims to do, than you should be of the opposite argument.
- ible 18y agoWe should be skeptical that any particular metric does what it claims to do, especially ones which are ad-hoc or based on intuition instead of evidence. I'm not suggesting that Gladwell is wrong about any of the examples he gave being 'mismatches', or that there are many of them, and exposing the misuse of metrics is certainly valuable. However, he seems to go further, suggesting that we can't find good predictors at all, which is a claim which I think deserves just as much skepticism. I doubt he would seriously make such a claim, and it is probably just an artifact of an early talk which won't be present in his book, but I have plenty of skepticism to go around, so I'm perfectly happy to deploy it wherever it is warranted at all.
- swombat 18y agoI don't think he implied that. He just said that many of the metrics we use are wrong. He didn't say those metrics don't exist at all.
- yummyfajitas 18y ago> From the IQ tests IQ tests actually do a pretty good job. http://iqcomparisonsite.com/occupations.aspx http://iqcomparisonsite.com/occupations.aspx
- timr 18y agoAssuming that linked chart is accurate (which I don't automatically grant), pointing out that the average IQ for a janitor is lower than the average IQ for a doctor isn't the same thing as predicting someone's success as a doctor based on their IQ. There's a lot of overlap between those ranges.
- fallentimes 18y agoNFL Combine.