3 ms·
I think you may be assuming that veins are rigid, so can create suction at the top, like a siphon, as blood flows back down the neck. If that were true, it woul
by ncmncm 7y ago
I think you may be assuming that veins are rigid, so can create suction at the top, like a siphon, as blood flows back down the neck. If that were true, it would not take much work to move blood through the neck and head. Maybe you are thinking the veins could be braced against surrounding bone structures, to be held open against such suction.
Unfortunately, that cannot work. All the capillaries in the head and brain would also need to be rigid, and strong enough to hold back that much suction. There's no way around actually doing the work to pump the blood up there, and letting it drain back down.
But that isn't a slam-dunk for extreme blood pressure. We have plenty of examples of valves in veins to help get blood back from lower extremities. A little musculature around a pair of such valves on an artery could easily develop into a secondary heart, and a series of them could eliminate much of the need for the actual heart to supply all the pressure, or for the aorta to resist it.
It is not unreasonable to expect to find novel adaptations in an extreme body plan. Supporting the idea in the absence of fossil evidence is hard, even when such a novelty would eliminate the need for such a novelty as absurdly high blood pressure. Biologists resist suggestion of soft -tissue novelties much more than suggestion of physico- mechanical absurdities because they are, after all, biologists, not engineers.
- marcosdumay 7y agoNot so much rigid, and not so much suction, in a closed circulatory system, the column of fluid that is going down pressurizes the bottom just as much as is required to send the fluid back up. Yes, that would require all capillary vases to support 1 extra atm of pressure against the air, what is a large issue. But it does not require rigidity.
- ncmncm 7y agoPoint conceded.
- marcosdumay 7y agoYour point is taken. Looks like I wasn't much clear, but 1 atm is a sure huge amount of pressure, it's not likely that an animal would have this blood pressure, it could at most get some small partial savings from high pressure.