9 ms·
If you can deal with the variance, training people is a very good way to get cheap talent. I have no idea why it isn't very common.
by marcosdumay 7y ago
If you can deal with the variance, training people is a very good way to get cheap talent. I have no idea why it isn't very common.
- Kalium 7y agoI think the business case for it depends on training time, training costs, the odds of a person being useful after training, and how expensive it is to get someone already trained. Training a batch of people for six months who will mostly be useful after completion and are mostly likely to complete training might be a good proposition. If training time is four years, 50% of entrants complete training, and 50% of those trained are useful... the case might be weaker.
- jseliger 7y agoI believe the biggest issue is people leaving. Invest x months of training at y cost. Then the person leaves right after training for a higher-paying job. That dis-incentivizes training.
- journalctl 7y agoIt also incentivizes paying more.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoOr, increase psychological incentives by saying "raises for people who make it a year" or "signing on bonuses only for people who make it six months." Those help a lot.
- scarejunba 7y agoHow would the trained guy be cheap talent? Now he's trained and on the market as a trained worker. Are you going to ask him to pay you back for training if he quits?
- em-bee 7y agoin a proper master/apprentice system quitting early is like aborting your training, that is, you don't get a certificate for incomplete training. for a short training like welding, i don't know, but if it comes with a certificate i suppose you could withhold it if they leave early. in IT this is a real problem. it takes about half a year to make someone productive. it takes another half year or so before i start getting a return on my investment. if they leave then, i am barely breaking even. if they leave earlier, i am making a loss. a friend of mine tried this business and couldn't make it work financially.
- droithomme 7y ago> training people is a very good way to get cheap talent It's also exactly how the master-apprentice system works. It's a good system, is fair, and works. It's also vastly superior than the system where you pay to be trained by someone who is not a working master and end up learning substandard or obsolete methods.
- gnopgnip 7y agoMany industries are competitive, there is a limited pool of people to hire. If you pay a little more you get lower turnover, and you end up with more experienced and more skilled employees than your competition.