3 ms·
Capitalism is great for some things, and awful for others. Capitalism works best when there's no power differential between customers and service providers beca
by arcticbull 7y ago
Capitalism is great for some things, and awful for others. Capitalism works best when there's no power differential between customers and service providers because the goal is to maximize profit. If my choice is to pay for cancer treatment or die, you can (and do) charge me literally whatever you want in a capitalist system. If I get no choice in which prison I go to, well, I get bilked.
Basically anywhere you have no choice should be socialized or two-tier: Medicine, Prison, Army, Education.
On the other hand, nobody's forcing me to buy phones.
- ekianjo 7y ago> If my choice is to pay for cancer treatment or die, you can (and do) charge me literally whatever you want in a capitalist system. Erm, no. Because if people can't pay for it, then your drug get no sales, and you lose your investment. The problem right now is that there are several payers involved and nobody sees the real cost of things. Were you to pay directly for drugs from your own pocket without intermediaries I'd wage all drugs would be way cheaper.
- arcticbull 7y agoTell that to your $600 epipen. Seriously. Canada doesn't even have socialized drug insurance for prescriptions and it costs $100 and in the UK $38. Drugs would be, in a perfect system with no socialist intervention, priced at whatever value they provide you. If that's your life, it's very expensive. There's no room for mercy in capitalism. There's a reason Sovaldi is $84,000 and it's not because it costs a lot to make. It's the same reason as soon as they realized that you could treat cancer with Thalidomide the price rose two orders of magnitude.
- ekianjo 7y ago> Canada doesn't even have socialized drug insurance for prescriptions and it costs $100 and in the UK $38 It's kind of easy for a country to dictate drug prices when they had no hand in developing them. Now show me a country like the US that develops just as many drugs. Ah, you can't, there is none.
- tapland 7y agoDrug prices have absolutely nothing to do with where the drug is developed. AstraZeneca being Swedish never prevented Swedes from having a yearly out of pocket maximum at $120.
- Octoth0rpe 7y agoDenmark comes very close per capita, while still having shockingly lower prices. Edit: found a good source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2866602/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2866602/ Note, per capita it looks like most of the countries studied are discovering new drugs (in the study's terminology "new molecular entity") at much faster rate than the United States when adjusted for population. The money quote: " Our data suggest that the United States is important but not disproportionate in its contribution to pharmaceutical innovation. Interestingly, some countries with direct price control, profit control, or reference drug pricing appeared to innovate proportionally more than their contribution to the global GDP or prescription drug spending"
- jjeaff 7y agoDenmark is so tiny compared to the US, it hardly makes sense to compare drug discovery per cápita. If Denmark happens to release just a single extra drug one year, it totally shifts their ratio.
- tapland 7y agoExactly. Denmark has little bargaining power compared to what a larger US state would have. But they do bulk purchases and get prices thereafter.
- steephills 7y agoAccording to this article, the biggest R&D spenders in pharma are EU firms: https://www.evaluate.com/vantage/articles/data-insights/other-data/swiss-big-pharmas-top-research-spending-tables https://www.evaluate.com/vantage/articles/data-insights/othe...
- rienbdj 7y agothis is not how prices work. consumers only pay the maximum they would be willing to pay for a good when there is only one provider. when there are multiple providers prices are pushed down to the cost of production. or so the theory goes.
- arcticbull 7y ago* caveat: Assuming no power disparty between buyers and sellers. If you need something more than the seller needs your money they're free to adjust the price up no matter how many of them there are. For instance, a hurricane comes in to town. All of a sudden, every gas station is charging $50/bottle for water and $10/gal for gas, even though the market is no more or less competitive than the day before when they charged $2.50. Externalities matter. Gouging like this is illegal in the event of bad weather but it's the status quo in the event of bad health, and much of the time, you exert equal control over both. The only real difference is one tends to skew acute and the other tends to skew chronic, I guess.
- rienbdj 7y agothe provider is still not free to wait out the buyer in a competitive market because another provider can swoop in and make the deal. in you price gouging example prices are high because demand is so much higher than supply, but goods still change hands. again, this is all in theory
- arcticbull 7y agoSure I get the theory and I actually buy into it. However I’ve been on this earth long enough to know that theory doesn’t match reality a lot of the time and that’s when then the government should step in and right the scales.
- dlphn___xyz 7y agowhy does the healthcare discussion always regress to capitalism vs socialism? everyone cites canada as the ideal model of social healthcare but forget to mention the long wait times and the fact that their population is only a fraction of the US. i think our system could use some tweaks but throwing it out altogether for a socialist program is not it.
- arcticbull 7y agoNo we cite the entire OECD except America each of which rank higher in healthcare quality by WHO standards and cost at most half as much. It’s like a poor student saying “just because I’m the bottom of my class doesn’t make me dumb” — in a way, no but in a much more relevant and important way, definitely. It shows relative to your peers you suck at the task at hand. It comes down to this debate because the pro market people offer zero solutions other than staying the course and the course is straight down. Offer something better.
- XorNot 7y agoTell me what is the wait time when you can never get treatment?
- arcticbull 7y agoThat’s just propagandist garbage. I’m alive because the Canadian system works, a few times over.
- triceratops 7y ago> the fact that their population is only a fraction of the US I don't understand why that matters. But if it does, couldn't the US implement social healthcare at the state level? Canada and California have roughly equal populations, for instance.
- mrep 7y agoThey totally could but for some reason no state does... Instead, I only see senators, representatives, and potential presidential candidates trying to force it upon the entire country. We are the united states, let individual states start the process and let it bubble up to the federal level once enough states enable it just like we are doing with marijuana laws. IMO, the federal government has been getting too large just like how they dangle interstate highway funds from states for enforcing the stupid 21 year old drinking age.
- dredmorbius 7y agoHealthcare plans routinely charge far more than patients can reasonably pay, then unload the full force of the law at them. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/uva-has-ruined-us-health-system-sues-thousands-of-patients-seizing-paychecks-and-putting-liens-on-homes/2019/09/09/5eb23306-c807-11e9-be05-f76ac4ec618c_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/uva-has-ruined-us-heal... (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20921887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20921887)
- tejtm 7y agoNot even sure how to categorize this but if you get cancer and can't pay you can have yourself put in prison for the treatment...
- crazy1van 7y ago> If my choice is to pay for cancer treatment or die, you can (and do) charge me literally whatever you want in a capitalist system One provider might charge a fortune. But then another will come along and realize he can get all this business by charging slightly less than a fortune. Then another comes along and charges slightly less. And so on until they are charging just enough to make a slight profit. That’s how a healthy market works. But if you put up tons of barriers and rules about who can provide a service and how the service must be performed, the whole competitive system breaks down.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoThat’s how a healthy market works. But if you put up tons of barriers and rules about who can provide a service and how the service must be performed Sorry, are you referring to proving that treatments have effect, doctors being licensed, something else?
- staticautomatic 7y agoNo, that's how a free market is supposed to work but no one's ever seen a free market in the wild.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mrep 7y agoMost agriculture markets are extremely competitive such that they are basically perfect competition.
- arcticbull 7y agoMight I suggest perusing the Farm Bill? The government is literally paying farmers to grow crops people wouldn’t pay for. That doesn’t sound like a very free market system... frankly I wish they’d stop.
- 7y ago
- tomp 7y ago> If my choice is to pay for cancer treatment or die In a socialized medicine system, someone else is making this choice for you. Medical costs (drugs, doctors' education and time, research costs, equipment) are unbounded, while resources are not (no matter what kind of insurance you have), so tradeoffs have to be made. ("What? My daughter is dying from an extremely rare disease and you're not having 1000 PhD researchers working on the cure?! You're spending the resources on curing breast cancer instead?!? WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!!") AFAIK (though I haven't deeply researched this topic) society-level recommendations aren't made on what is best, but on what is most cost effective (e.g. how often you should have mammography, when you should start having regular colon cancer scans) so it's perfectly reasonable, if you're rich(er), to supplement the public medical system with some extra resources of your own to improve the health outcomes of yourself and/or people close to you. In addition, that funds new research (e.g. the anti-aging craze currently happening in SV, funded mostly by rich billionaires that don't want to die... the medical system doesn't even recognize aging as a disease (so drugs can't be approved to be "anti-aging")!)
- arcticbull 7y agoIn a capitalist system someone else is making the choice for me too: VISA. I’d rather the government take a wholistic view of resource allocation than a luck based bank account balance strategy.