8 ms·
I find it fascinating that private prisons draw such ire while the prison guard union draws so little, when the prison guard union has all the exact same incent
by 55orolder 7y ago
I find it fascinating that private prisons draw such ire while the prison guard union draws so little, when the prison guard union has all the exact same incentives and is drastically more powerful.
California would have had legal marijuana a decade sooner except for lobbing by the union, they're a major force for mandatory minimum sentences and tougher sentencing in general.
This seems like a trivial easy-PR win for some legislators that does very little to meaningfully address the problems with criminal justice in the US. Private prisons are a tiny little piece of a much bigger problem and there's still a lot of real work to be done.
- EdwardDiego 7y ago> when the prison guard union has all the exact same incentives and is drastically more powerful. Could you please provide me some examples? I figure if California's prisons were 200% of capacity, there's no shortage of work for the prison guards anyway.
- throwawayjava 7y ago> I figure if California's prisons were 200% of capacity, there's no shortage of work for the prison guards anyway. I'm not sure how/why you figure that, or how it's at all relevant. I'm not sure how/why you figure that because "over capacity" != "will build new prisons / hire new guards". I.e., it's not at all impossible for there to be prisons that are over-capacity and also a decline in the number of prison guard jobs. It's not relevant because the entire point of unions is to counter-act the effect of supply/demand dynamics on labor (see: "there's always another scab"). Just because there's "no shortage of work for the prison guards" doesn't mean they will lobby against changes to laws that might one day create such a shortage.
- cf498 7y agoOr they could just work towards better working conditions? Unions dont really have the growth incentive private entities do. Prison guards are extremely far from running out of work, quite the opposite is true and their members also suffer under the poor working conditions of an chronically understaffed and underpaid sector. They are risking their life because politicians think overcrowding prisons isnt a problem. I mean I get the initial point, some police unions are an especially vile proponents of an expansion into a police state, its just not really about working conditions. Its political lobbying. In Germany you can see it every time more competences for the police are discussed in parliament. You have some police unions giving legit feedback if someone bothers to ask them, how those competences are a bad idea and are not needed. And then you have speakers for other police union (with a catchy union name to seem more important) where you can see they have the right party membership and are looking for a career in politics. As a result you can see them in every news report that wants to bring across a certain message.
- kamaal 7y agoI figure more people coming in also means more overtime benefits, eventually translates to better pension benefits too. Given most pensions are based on the compensations and benefits of the last years of service rendered. Then of course there could be plenty of hidden stuff like more prison crowds means some one selling food(I hear animals eat better food than inmates) to the prison likely makes more money, and hence better bribes/commissions in the chain of people involved. Eventually it comes down to profit per person. And they'd like to make it up on scale.
- smileysteve 7y ago> I figure if California's prisons were 200% of capacity, Much of the concept is that the prison's are at 200% capacity because of the perverse incentives for the state (prosecutors, police, judges) to fulfill the private contract minimums. Mandatory minimums and the 3 strike rule are suspected to be related to private prisons contracts.
- 29_29 7y agoAll good points. We can now feel good about ourselves as orthodox liberals, and not think about the price we are paying for exactly the same problem.
- avocado4 7y ago> This seems like a trivial easy-PR win for some legislators Unions are the good guys in contemporary socialist culture so I'm not sure going against them would be an easy PR win, regardless of the facts and incentives.
- thanatos_dem 7y agoSeems like the poster meant that going after private prisons was the easy PR win, and that going after the unions would be more difficult, but effective at addressing the underlying perverse incentive structure.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoWith private prisons, you can grift of off anti-private sentiment. But with prison guard unions, you just run into people's authoritarian streaks. There is a reason why Law Enforcement Officer's Bill Of Rights are sometimes expanded to include corrections officers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_Enforcement_Officers%27_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_Enforcement_Officers%27_Bi...
- philwelch 7y agoGoing after public sector unions at all is extremely difficult. The most successful attempt to do so that I'm aware of was Gov. Scott Walker's in Wisconsin. And even he didn't go after the law enforcement unions. (It might be possible to split off the police unions from the prison guard unions, but it's not clear to me that it is.) Law enforcement unions are one of the few American institutions with completely bipartisan protection. Democrats don't go after them because Democrats are pro-union. Republicans don't go after them because Republicans are pro-police. Furthermore, you really don't want to pick a fight with police unions. What happens if police officers and prison guards go on strike? It's against the law in many places, but if the police are on strike, who's going to enforce that? There is a very significant risk that you'd have to call up the National Guard just to maintain public order. And even then, how many National Guardsmen does California have? How many LEOs? And most of those National Guardsmen are not actually trained in law enforcement. In effect you would be declaring martial law. It's not worth it.
- phry 7y ago> What happens if police officers and prison guards go on strike? > When New York police officers temporarily reduced their “proactive policing” efforts on low-level offenses, major-crime reports in the city actually fell, according to a study based on New York Police Department crime statistics. > The scientists found that civilian complaints of major crimes dropped by about 3% to 6% during the slowdown. https://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-proactive-policing-crime-20170925-story.html https://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-proacti...
- mikekchar 7y agoThe article you link to actually links to the original paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-017-0211-5.epdf https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-017-0211-5.epdf It occurred to me that the result is not necessarily unexpected if it were due to under reporting (i.e. during the slowdown there was less opportunity to report major crime and therefore reports fell). The researchers discuss that in the paper. I don't have time to read the paper in detail and come to a conclusion one way or another, but I thought it might be of interest to people who might not otherwise click on an La Times link.
- voxl 7y agoYour claims require evidence.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoAll claims require evidence. You need to troll all the threads equally, or just stop making people feel like crap for sharing articles.
- hedvig 7y agoDid you see this post as a good opportunity to just divert attention to anti-union ideology with your comment?
- pathseeker 7y agoA union doing a shitty thing can be pointed out without it being anti-union.
- jibal 7y agoSure, but that's not what happened here ... the comment you responded to accurately described what did happen.
- pathseeker 7y agoWell for-profit prisons have been the target of pop culture for the last couple of years (e.g. John Oliver did a segment on them, Orange is the New Black, etc). People incorrectly assumed that since they were bad that it meant the public ones were somehow better (standard good vs evil thinking that plagues political discourse in the US).
- CameronNemo 7y agoThe Union at least must disclose all of their contributions, right?
- js8 7y agoActually, in democratic capitalism, unions in private companies are always less powerful than private companies themselves. The power of unions (for a certain sector) in a given society scales proportionally to number of people involved in them. However, the power of private companies (certain sector) in a given society is proportional to revenue of that sector. Since the power of unions in monetary terms can be bounded from above by total wages in the sector, we can see that this is always less than the revenue of the sector. In other words, in capital intensive industries, unions have less relative power. The point is, the "willingness of some industry to live" is the interest of more people than just employees of that industry. It's also all the people taking a cut one way or another, that is owners, rentiers and potentially all the people involved in providing assets for the industry.
- jMyles 7y agoThe union in question is a public sector union, though, so it's not obvious how to apply your (correct, at least to my eyes) analysis.
- js8 7y agoI think for public sector, we have to look at it on the state level. Using the same analysis, in a democratic society, one vote has in theory more power than membership in a public sector unions, because with that vote you can decide more things than just wages of public employees. I suspect the American culture of "being tough on crime" isn't really about prison-employee unions, but has historical roots in the colonization of the American frontier.
- throwawayjava 7y ago> Using the same analysis, in a democratic society, one vote has in theory more power than membership in a public sector unions, because with that vote you can decide more things than just wages of public employees. ...except when you can both be a member of a union and also exercise your vote. I wasn't aware that in the USA joining a public sector union meant giving up your right to vote ;-)
- paulcole 7y ago> This seems like a trivial easy-PR win for some legislators Imagine a layperson read a news article about a complex topic in your field and instantly discovered a trivial easy win. What are the odds they’d be correct?
- johnchristopher 7y ago> California would have had legal marijuana a decade sooner except for lobbing by the union, they're a major force for mandatory minimum sentences and tougher sentencing in general. edit: Do you have any articles to recommend that would shed some lights on this matter ? Do you have some sources ? (I don't live in the US, but I find the idea that guards somehow lobby fascinating)
- cstejerean 7y agoSo this isn’t directed at you in particular but I don’t understand this “do you have any sources?” for stuff that’s one search away. If it was some obscure hard to find information published in some journal I would understand it, but this in this case https://lmgtfy.com/?q=california+prison+guards+lobby https://lmgtfy.com/?q=california+prison+guards+lobby And yet I see this constantly on almost every thread. What is it with HN and asking for sources on everything?
- johnchristopher 7y agoI totally see your point. That's why I added "I am not from the US" to signal "I don't live there, I don't know the in and out of this and I need the help of someone closer to the subject to help me grok it faster". True, I could google for it but then I am on an hunt to discern the truths and the lies and to understand why someone lies or tells the truth to whom and how it is pertinent to the original request (and there's the bubble search, of course). The thing is, I don't know - in that case - if it's obscure or not. Plus, our comments aren't born in a vacuum. Parent likely has additional information or an outlook on the subject that I wouldn't find (or more likely find but likely dismiss because of a lack of context) in a 15 minutes google search. Then, on the other hand, you actually have snipers around here who are quick to derail conversations by not participating, not giving information or sharing outlook and just shooting "Sources ?" and then never coming back to the thread. You have to trust me on that one but I assure you I don't do that. Now, asking for sources is most of time a given when someone makes extraordinary claims meant to shut an argument (eg: "X is bad 98% of time don't talk about X" when everyone was considering X safe from the get-go). edit: I should have asked something like "Do you have an article to recommend that would shed some lights on this matter ?". The "Do you have sources ?" is a bit harsh and inquisitive, my bad. edit (2): On the other hand, I clicked your link, without looking at the URL, thinking "ah cool, this person is telling me that in this case a simple google search will yield pertinent results. But all I got was a "fuck you, use google".
- ptah 7y agothe side effects of going after a union purely for this reason will need to be properly quantified before you can consider going down this road. removing private ownership of prisons is a no-brainer in comparison
- willyt 7y agoWhy would a union want more prisons? Surely the whole point of a union is to lobby for better pay and conditions for its individual members, I don't see what the incentive is for the union to create more prisons, to get more union members? Why?
- SkyBelow 7y agoMore members equal more political power. More members equal more funding. More members equal more possibility of existing members to become senior.
- sbochins 7y agoDifferent issues. People tend to dislike the fact that we charge prisoners outrageous rates for calls, etc. And I don’t remember prison guard unions being the ones principally pushing for 3 strike laws. Most of those went through when it was politically advantageous to be backing them, unlike now.