5 ms·
>A huge percentage of the Internet is the same information, repeated over and over again. This is especially apparent on film websites; they call it aggregation
by legitster 7y ago
>A huge percentage of the Internet is the same information, repeated over and over again. This is especially apparent on film websites; they call it aggregation but it’s really just a nicer way to say regurgitation.
Man, what an apt way to explain my frustration with the monoculture of the web. But it's creeping into the world of books, where fewer and fewer writers know how to research anything. I cannot tell you the number of books I have picked up lately that cite things they saw on Twitter or gleaned from a Google search.
- pembrook 7y agoIronically, even this very article has been posted on HN twice before.
- BeeBoBub 7y agoHN aggregates, it has no illusions of creating original works. Occasional high-quality reposts are a virtue of HN, and I don't think HN suffers from the same regurgitation issues as film sites. The film websites often come with analysis or reviews of films where the regurgitation lies, whereas Hacker News provides no editorialized comment on the articles, only discussion. "Echo Chambers" etc... could be merely a distributed version regurgitated content, however I think the HN community tends to self-police groupthink
- lonelappde 7y agoThe comments on HN are quite often regurgitated, especially for the political topics rehashed every week.
- hailk 7y agoComments are not the main content that HN aggregates. They facilitate discussions around the main content, which are just either links or at best a question.
- lonelappde 7y agoReposting the same thing is fine. It helps new people find the content. Regurgitating a meaninglessly mangled version of something (intentionally or not) on order to plagiarize without getting caught, is terrible pollution.
- KrishnaAnaril 7y agoI'm actually fine with that. I found the article this time, plus it helps to discuss with a new set of people.
- jccalhoun 7y agoSadly, terrible citations aren't new. More than once I have read an academic book with a good quote only to hunt down the original source and find it doesn't contain that quote at all. Sometimes it it source A taking source B's paraphrase of source C as if it was an actual quote. Clearly A never bothered to read the original source.
- ImaCake 7y agoThere is unfathomably large back catalogue of books on every topic. Maybe you should try diving into older works? I guess this is only useful advice for certain categories of books.