6 ms·
Prohibition Tossed a Wet Blanket on America’s Inventors
- hprotagonist 7y agoOne of the odd echoes of this is in the nascent cannabis herb vaporizer market. (Controversies and health concerns about the oil-based pens are real but aren’t related here.) There’s a positively cambrian explosion of form factors, heater designs, heat sources, materials, control systems, etc. right now in the product space, and it’s more or less all driven by crazy people making stuff in their basement and selling it via word of mouth on reddit and instagram and web forums. No one design has won, so we’re still in that “try everything!” mode. It’s kind of fun to see.
- mschuster91 7y agoThe problem with crazy people making stuff in their basement is that, sometimes, people die from it.
- hprotagonist 7y agothe cambrian explosion stage is also the caveat emptor stage. In this instance, i'll be glad of regulatory oversight sooner rather than later.
- imgabe 7y ago"sometimes people die from it" is a characteristic of just about every human endeavor.
- alasarmas 7y agoThis recent crisis regarding adulterants/diluents for oil pens reminds me of nothing so much as "jake leg", but in that case the adulterating agent was used to mislead the authorities as to the composition of the product, not the users: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamaica_ginger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamaica_ginger
- fourstar 7y agoI’d say Pax has won this category.
- opportune 7y agoPax is positioned too high in the market to really win. And it’s still not as easy to clean as it could be
- hprotagonist 7y agoNope. Arizer and Storz and Bickel are up there and absolutely pulling their weight. The solo, volcano/mighty/crafty are certainly well known, so Pax doesn't have the lock down on brand recognition. There's a second tier of cheap-but-probably-safe that's companies like boundless or healthy rips. Then there are the fan favorites / esoteric-nerd things like dynavap or the aforementioned basemenet-makers or hobbyist/lifestyle companies. They're not going to hit mass-market volume but they've got the nerds covered. Pax is killing it with the Era (but that's for concentrates) and their parent company is Juul, so they're well positioned -- but they are not setting the trend of the market at all. They continue to make good-but-overpriced conduction-only units that are increasingly just totally eclipsed by convection/hybrid units with replaceable batteries or alternative heat sources.
- simlevesque 7y agothe Pax Era is one of the worst concentrate portable device on the market.
- hprotagonist 7y agoit's also pretty limited; they're not available in my state, for example. The partnership-with-local-concentrate-producers plan means, as far as i can tell, that the quality varies wildly.
- vokep 7y agoWhy do you say this? It isn't the most cost effective maybe, but it is convenient and the bluetooth control stuff is kinda nice.
- asdf21 7y agoImagine what drug prohibition has done...
- rexreed 7y agoTo me this seems like correlation, but I'm not convinced of causation.
- schnevets 7y agoWhenever I hear one of these articles about idea exchange and location's impact on innovation, I always wonder if indie game development is a notable exception. Indie success stories frequently suggest one lone developer (like Stardew Valley's Eric Barone) or an extremely intimate team (like Celeste's Matt Thorson). It seems like breakout hits happen in completely random cities/locations and no one area is the definitive "epicenter of game design". I highly doubt game design is some notable outlier - it's simply a union of software development and creative industries. I think the only reasonable explanations is that the vibrant community and exchange of ideas happens through the internet. If so, I think there are lessons for other entrepreneurs/industries to follow so they can be less geographically bound.
- patagurbon 7y agoGame companies often seem (to my eyes) to cluster around major CS universities, and incidentally many of these universities have vibrant arts/creative communities (especially the juggernauts like UC schools, Toronto, Vancouver, MIT, etc etc). I think if you scraped even the top 500-1000 indie games you’d see some pretty serious clustering. But there are, of course, also very large communities for gaming online, from development to consumption. Most (if not effectively all) "core-CS" innovation takes place at university research groups, corps, and conferences, a much higher barrier to entry than itch.io for instance. CS innovation really requires a large amount of experience in a very limited subfield to make progress. Game design is just less esoteric than the frontiers of CS imo.
- Retric 7y agoI suspect when adjusting for the respective population you get a reverse effect as people graduating from top CS programs tend to have significant debt reducing their willingness to take risks. On top of that they have high opportunity costs. In areas like AI that’s countered by the benefits of an elite education. But, game designers need to be generalists which is harder for schools to teach over short time frames. PS: That’s not to say CS graduates from top schools are under represented, just that they had a gap and likely left the area.
- 7y ago
- throwawayjava 7y agoMan, Econ really is the miserable science. "I started with a politically charged theory passed down from The Elders and, after 6 years of being paid to search for evidence of that theory, guess what, I found some". For starters, using patents as a proxy for innovation is dubious at best. Patents are a terrible proxy for innovation. My own experience has been the inverse: organizations/individuals that patenting shit lots of shit are consistently the least inventive. Not sure if this was true in the early 20th century, but it certainly is today.
- bjourne 7y agoThere might be some confounding variables at play... Such as counties voting in favor of prohibition could be more conservative which in turn could be caused by them having an older population. Older people are, generally, both more conservative and less inventive than younger people. That said, all the best music was made in the 60's and 70's so maybe he's onto something. :)
- youeseh 7y agoI dunno, man - I agree with you that there are way too many variables at play, but the bit about innovation.. Technology as en enabler of things. Not all tech is easily accessible on day 1 though. Industrialization for example, was capital-intensive, so not everyone could play. As for music - I'd say that, like software, as the barriers to access and entry were lowered, innovation took off (A-track / cassettes / radio etc..). As for conservatism - that can come in many flavors. We really should appreciate the amount of innovation that takes place on a farm.
- sillyquiet 7y agoThere are plenty of times in history when puritanical movements like prohibition are not driven by older, 'conservative' folks but by young radicals, so this correlation is probably pretty tenuous if it exists. Look at the Reformation in England in the 16th century for example or the rise of literal Puritanism in the following century.
- nullc 7y agoIf you spend less time drunk you're less likely get suckered into paying people to file worthless patents for your useless brainfarts. Patent filing is a really weak proxy for the creation of actually useful inventions.