3 ms·
What a headline. Should someone talk to the author, make sure they're doing ok?
by pavel_lishin 7y ago
What a headline. Should someone talk to the author, make sure they're doing ok?
- draw_down 7y agoFeel free! I don't see the problem with it, though.
- asdfman123 7y agoThe world runs on clicks now, and you have to make headlines sound at least a little outrageous to keep up. I mean, I clicked because I thought, "Hope dies? I'm sure that's an exaggeration..."
- colechristensen 7y agoThere is a certain philosophical dissatisfaction with the standard model and it just keeps getting confirmed over and over, nobody can seem to find any significant new physics because possible discrepancies keep getting eliminated one by one. Hope dies is maybe a bit florid, but it's a bit real if you don't take it too seriously.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoYup, pretty much. Now if they could just use the standard model to explain dark matter/energy or the inconsistencies in the cosmic age evidence, or what ever the non-fundamental physics but really interesting problem is. I wonder if we figure out how to regrow a damaged heart into a healthy heart with a simple injection and 10 weeks of physical therapy if hope will die in all those cardiologists out there who no longer are able to push the boundaries in heart transplant surgery or heart substitutions. What is the effect on people who have spent their lives becoming an expert in a field or subject which now seems to be "done." I could imagine they might lose hope.
- devb 7y agoAuthors don't always have a final say on what the headline will be. Sometimes they don't have any say at all.
- Mathnerd314 7y agoThe original headline is much more positive: http://yfile.news.yorku.ca/2019/09/06/just-how-big-is-a-proton-york-scientists-help-resolve-decade-old-puzzle/ http://yfile.news.yorku.ca/2019/09/06/just-how-big-is-a-prot... I'd say the writer has a tendency to write gloomy headlines: https://www.quantamagazine.org/famous-experiment-dooms-pilot-wave-alternative-to-quantum-weirdness-20181011/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/famous-experiment-dooms-pilot...
- notfashion 7y agoIt's not a case of an "original headline": this is an entirely separate article, not a regurgitation of the press release. Wolchover is a very serious writer. It's pretty sickening to watch the (sadly predictable) HN sneering and mockery around the topic of someone's (anyone's) mental health. It's such a cruel, distorted and completely non-constructive conversation. Do you guys really not have anything more interesting to say?
- Dylan16807 7y agosneering mockery cruel distorted non-constructive You get all this from "make sure they're doing ok?".