3 ms·
I'm not sure if the Aeon article explains what Everett really meant, at least I still have questions. Suppose we're eternally branching, as in the example abou
by lordnacho 7y ago
I'm not sure if the Aeon article explains what Everett really meant, at least I still have questions.
Suppose we're eternally branching, as in the example about the up/down spin. If there's no way to visit other branches, how will we ever confirm this?
Second, what is the benefit of the branching interpretation? It seems to simply be a way to think about probabilities?
- scld 7y agoI'd recommend reading some of the explanations given by Sean Carroll on the subject. https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/ ....and I didn't realize that Sean Carroll actually wrote this article! Still, he does some good explanations on his podcast.
- platz 7y agoThe benefit is that instead of two rules for quantum behavior 1) the Schrodinger equation 2) the born rule , that contradict each other, you just have 1) the Schrodinger equation, which you already accepted. There is also a higher level goal that also motivates him > the quest for quantum gravity is being held back by physicists’ traditional strategy of taking a classical theory (such as Albert Einstein’s general relativity) and ‘quantising’ it. Presumably nature doesn’t work like that; it’s just quantum from the start.
- akvadrako 7y agoQuantum Immortality. Basically, if you keep splitting and you make an assumption like "My perception of the world is relative to me", then when a split causes you to die you don't really split - because you must ignore branches where you don't exist. So then your view always follows the branching path where you live and you should expect to live 1M years from now. If there is only one world you shouldn't expect that.
- excalibur 7y agoAs scld touched on, this "article" is really an excerpt from Sean Carroll's new book, Something Deeply Hidden: Quantum Worlds and the Emergence of Spacetime. https://www.amazon.com/Something-Deeply-Hidden-Emergence-Spacetime/dp/1524743011/ https://www.amazon.com/Something-Deeply-Hidden-Emergence-Spa... If you wish to read further, you may want to consider picking up a copy. Mine is waiting for me at home, I'm looking forward to it!
- jfengel 7y ago1. No, there is no way to visit other branches. 2. The benefit is that it's a very direct translation of the math into concepts. If you actually build the mathematical model, the "other worlds" are right there in the model, as the other half of a superposition. It doesn't go away. You just can't get to it. Nor can you ignore it, because it's sitting there as a term in the equation, persisting as you evolve it over time. It just becomes smaller and smaller without ever becoming zero. That's why you observe a classical universe even though it's really quantum: the odds of the other parts of a superposition having an effect are on the order of Avogadro's-number-to-1 against. Copenhagen works by just arbitrarily defining that number as zero, which is easy to work with but conceptually incomplete. MWI keeps it there in another "world", which is more in keeping with the math but unedifying because it sounds so unfalsifiable. Hope that helps. (Which is always code for "... but it probably doesn't", I'm afraid.)