5 ms·
Of course only 21% of the public favours abolishing private insurance. There's been a huge and incredibly well-funded PR campaign to persuade them of that. htt
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Of course only 21% of the public favours abolishing private insurance. There's been a huge and incredibly well-funded PR campaign to persuade them of that.
https://theintercept.com/2018/11/20/medicare-for-all-healthcare-industry/ https://theintercept.com/2018/11/20/medicare-for-all-healthc...
Americans don't need to be irrational - they just need to be misled about the relative benefits of taxes vs the personal security and relief that could be provided by paying higher taxes.
The reality is that the private medical insurance industry in the US is the single biggest cause of personal bankruptcy, and is responsible for incredible emotional and financial suffering. It takes a lot of spin - not to mention outright dishonesty - to paint that as a good thing.
But when the industry makes as much money as it does, the costs of generating that spin are relatively cheap compared to the profits it secures.
Meanwhile in those countries groaning under the yoke of oppressive taxation, there is absolutely no popular support for moving to the "benefits" of a US system.
Because there are no benefits. And that's a straightforward, simple, unarguable fact. Not only are higher taxes absolutely worth the value they buy - guaranteed health care, with no worries about bankruptcy or "competitive" price gouging - but the total cost over a lifetime, inclusive of taxes, is vastly lower than the equivalent cost in the US system.
- enraged_camel 7y agoThe other reason only 21% of people are against abolishing private insurance is that lots of people are insured through their employer, and thus the true cost of their healthcare coverage is hidden from them. If they really knew how much it was costing them (because benefits are part of “total compensation”), they would sing a different tune.
- kodablah 7y agoAnd yet another is they don't have confidence in the public sector running it well.
- danaris 7y agoBecause for at least the past 4 decades, one major political party has been running an enormous propaganda campaign to convince the country that "public sector" == "wasteful, inefficient, ineffective, and corrupt" and "private company" == "efficient market-driven utopia". They've been so successful, they've even convinced themselves—so much so that every time actual evidence to the contrary is presented, they pretend it doesn't exist and try to make everyone else do the same.
- rayiner 7y agoThat, along with peoples’ actual experiences with their government. The NYC MTA is better funded than London’s or Paris’s transit systems, yet has on the brink of system failure. Amtrak is similarly funded (adjusted for differences in passenger volume) to European rail systems. Yet it offers decrepit equipment and unreliable service. We spend more per student on education than all but a couple of other countries (like Switzerland), but our test scores are at the bottom of the pack. American cities like Baltimore and San Francisco are full of crime, homelessness, and drug use, even though they’ve been controlled by “the other major party” for decades. It should also be noted that, with the notable exception of healthcare, most of Western Europe has followed the trend of privatization, deregulation, and reliance on market mechanisms. Macron is talking about privatizing SNCF—not even Trump is talking about privatizing Amtrak.
- enraged_camel 7y agoYou are being disingenuous. Why don't you look at government-run programs in the actual sector we are discussing? Medicare and VA healthcare programs are both well-run and immensely popular among their recipients. They aren't without problems, but looking at them objectively should dispel any notion that "the government cannot run healthcare efficiently and effectively."
- kodablah 7y ago> They aren't without problems, but looking at them objectively should dispel any notion that "the government cannot run healthcare efficiently and effectively." I think that wouldn't dispel the notion that "the government cannot regulate healthcare efficiently and effectively". Unless you expect all hospitals and doctors to be direct employees of the government, you need to look at how they regulate the sector, they won't be running it. I shouldn't have used "running" in my original comment as it implied more direct control than would be the case.
- EpicEng 7y agoYet we're not going to see a big raise because we switch over to a single payer system. It's not unreasonable for people to be skeptical of such a massive change when their current situation works fine (for them.) A change like this would be far more beneficial to the under/uninsured than those of us with existing, comprehensive plans. I'm not making an argument either way. Personally I'm for single payer, but that's largely due to the issues my mother had when she became ill.
- wahern 7y ago> Yet we're not going to see a big raise because we switch over to a single payer system. Californian legislators released a study last year about the costs of moving to single-payer healthcare in the state. In total it would be $400 billion, requiring $200 billion in new tax revenues after accounting for the existing $200 billion in federal, state, and local expenditures. Diverting existing employer and individual premium payments would still leave anywhere from a $50 billion to $150 billion gap. California's existing budget is ~$200 billion, so covering that gap would require significant new taxes. Anybody telling you that you can get single-payer for free is lying to you. That would only be possible if we could significantly reduce costs, but we don't know how to reduce costs. Any suggestion you've heard is almost certainly part of the ACA/Obamacare in some form or fashion, and the strategies aren't working as well as originally believed. But this was predicted. The ACA was always intended to be a process of experimenting with cost reducing strategies, which is why there were supposed to be panels that could rewrite the rules as new information came in. But nobody is interested in the hard work of figuring out what those solutions are; all the electorate on both sides is interested in voting for are feel-good solutions. And they'll believe whatever they need to believe in order to support their political tribe.
- sitkack 7y ago> we don't know how to reduce costs I am pretty sure administrators of health systems that are cheaper could tell us. Like just directly to our face.
- 7y ago
- rayiner 7y ago> But when the industry makes as much money as it does, the costs of generating that spin are relatively cheap compared to the profits it secures. In H1 2018, the largest 8 insurers combined made $16.6 billion in profits: https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payer/from-aetna-to-wellcare-how-top-insurers-measured-up-first-half-2018 https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payer/from-aetna-to-wellcar.... Facebook, by itself, is about on the same level, at $10 billion. Are you saying that Facebook alone somehow makes sufficient profits to convince an entire country to vote for favorable policies? Including the thousands of businesses, shelling out $1 trillion+ for private health insurance coverage?
- sieabahlpark 7y agoAre you saying that Facebook alone somehow makes sufficient profits to convince an entire country to vote for favorable policies? Including the thousands of businesses, shelling out $1 trillion+ for private health insurance coverage? Facebook owns $50b of the ad market revenue. So, yes? The company literally is built on selling ads to target demographics.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- likpok 7y agoIf Facebook has so much influence, why does nobody seem to like it very much? Both Google and Facebook combined should have even more influence. Both spend a lot of money on healthcare (for their employees). Why wouldn't they use their influence to make healthcare cheaper?
- UnpossibleJim 7y agoI mean, I don't want to lay all of the blame on the citizenry, but America also leads the world in obesity, anxiety disorders and cocaine use. I understand that correlation doesn't equal causation, but there is a correlation. Personal responsibility has to lie in there, somewhere. It isn't an "all or nothing" equation. Also, when the US gets compared to these European countries, they are, quite literally, the size of one of our states. It's a tough comparison. Sure, lines can be drawn, but people do have to take into account a difference in scope and culture. It might not be Apples and oranges, but maybe look at it like lemons and oranges?
- EpicEng 7y ago>America also leads the world in obesity I've found three sources that have us at 16 or 17 (and they all use BMI, which is ok I guess, but not great.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_body_mass_index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_body_mass... >anxiety disorders Upper middle of the pack by region. Anxiety also correlates to wealth. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/254610/WHO-MSD-MER-2017.2-eng.pdf https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/254610/WHO-... >and cocaine use #5 per the latest data I can find. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalence_of_cocaine_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalenc...
- datavirtue 7y agoThis. Combined with hospitals holding insurance companies and customers captive in each region, the influx of self inflicted chronic disease is giving them that power.