12 ms·
It's not so much that the US forgot what antitrust is for, it's that the current powers that be disagree with it, and have a tendency to pervert anything they d
by mcv 7y ago
It's not so much that the US forgot what antitrust is for, it's that the current powers that be disagree with it, and have a tendency to pervert anything they disagree with, rather than being honest about their opposition to it.
Same thing with health care and other measures that are meant to benefit the general public. Opposing things that benefit the general public doesn't win them votes, so they need to put a clever spin on their opposition to it. But ultimately, they want things that benefit rich people, particularly party donors.
- paulddraper 7y ago> It's not so much that the US forgot what antitrust is for, it's that the current powers that be disagree with it Is there really a difference between those things?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Nasrudith 7y agoAs large a difference between genuine ignorance and willful ignorance.
- mieseratte 7y agoWell, really, it's a result of selective enforcement and interpretation of law. One administration decides it doesn't care for a rule and decides not to enforce, or instead tailoring their interpretation to meet their desired outcome as to not appear asleep at the wheel. The next one comes along and decides it wishes to enforce based on another interpretation. This is a consequence of human systems, ultimately.
- rayiner 7y agoWho are the "current powers?" The current view of antitrust law has been operative since the 1980s, and has encompassed administrations on both sides of the fence. It's rooted in a large body of academic scholarship that has withstood the test of time. Your comparison to health care is telling. You make it seem like it's "rich" "party donors" who are opposed to single-payer healthcare. In reality, just 21% of the public supports abolishing private insurance (which single-payer healthcare necessarily would require): https://www.mrctv.org/blog/cnn-poll-only-21-favor-getting-rid-private-insurance-majority-oppose-giving-healthcare https://www.mrctv.org/blog/cnn-poll-only-21-favor-getting-ri.... There is a rhetorical tendency to blame American public policy on conspiracies rather than honestly attempting to figure out why people vote the way they do. In the context of healthcare, for example, isn't it possible that people (1) reasonably believe that single payer won't be a magic bullet that lowers our healthcare costs to European levels; and (2) don't want to pay the additional taxes required to pay for universal coverage, when most people who aren't on Medicare receive healthcare from their employers? There is, in fact, good evidence that those factors, rather than "rich people" and "party donors" are responsible. You'll notice that no Democrat that supports Medicare for All has offered a serious health care proposal, i.e. one that raises taxes sufficiently to pay for it. That gives you a remarkable insight into voter dynamics! Even Sanders is afraid to propose the $30 trillion in new taxes that will be required to pay for Medicare for All. (His menu would raise just $10-12 trillion, even if all options were adopted.) And while he is quite happy to propose tax rates on the wealthy *higher than those in France—51% versus 45%—he is unwilling to propose raising taxes even on people making up to $250,000 to anywhere near French levels. What does that tell you about what people want? Who is he afraid of? The rich? Or the suburban married couple making $125,000? Maybe Americans aren't irrational. Maybe they like having 50% higher disposable income compared to Germany or France. Maybe they don't want to pay a 20% VAT, the OECD average. Maybe they don't want their FICA contributions to double or triple, bringing those in line with social insurance taxes in Germany or France. Maybe they don't want 40%+ tax brackets to kick in well under $100,000, like in Germany, France, Sweden, etc. With respect to antitrust, maybe they like the rock-bottom prices enabled by the scale of companies like Wal-Mart and Amazon. Maybe they don't support carbon taxes because they like $3 gas, road trips, and SUVs? Maybe they are voting for the "powers" that give them what they want? It’s interesting to note that at the time the Microsoft antitrust decision came down, polls showed that people were opposed to breaking up Microsoft 54-35. That was the case even though a majority of people thought it was a monopoly! I don’t think people usually can articulate a specific opinion on antitrust issues, save for high profile cases like that, but people don’t vote for specific policies, they vote for an ideology. And for decades, they’ve been voting for a deregulatory ideology that features less government intervention in the economy.
- Frondo 7y agoI only wanted to address one thing you mentioned: polling varies widely on abolishing the private insurance system. The Kaiser Family Foundation does extensive health care polling on a continual basis, and their recent poll suggests that 37% favor single-payer where private insurance is abolished. Also, there certainly is room -- and I think even the staunchest advocate of socialized medicine acknowledges this -- for elective procedures to be covered by private insurance under a single-payer regime, so it's maybe inaccurate to say that one (single payer) necessitates the other (abolishing private insurance). Several countries I'm aware of split it up that way successfully. Lots of other interesting information here: https://www.kff.org/slideshow/public-opinion-on-single-payer-national-health-plans-and-expanding-access-to-medicare-coverage/ https://www.kff.org/slideshow/public-opinion-on-single-payer...
- rayiner 7y agoWhen people are polled about “private insurance” I don’t think they’re thinking about private insurance for elective procedures. I think the point shows that the large majority of people want, at most, a public option as an alternative to their existing private insurance. And that solution is unlikely to have much impact on costs. At the end of the day, the thing that came out of the political process (ACA plus Medicaid expansion) is probably the closest thing that has been proposed to what people are actually comfortable with.
- jcadam 7y agoI'm certainly not comfortable with the ACA. I'm old enough to remember what health insurance was like before Obama came along. The sudden and dramatic increase in premiums, deductibles, and co-insurance was effectively a massive pay cut for the entire American middle class. The government took a bad situation (the US healthcare system) and managed to make it a lot worse.
- Frondo 7y agoYes and no. Eliminating the pre-existing conditions restrictions was life-changing for me and a lot of people I know; I'd had a surgery in 2005 that, up to whenever Obamacare was passed, excluded me from buying any health insurance from a private insurer. They all declined me as having had a pre-existing condition (having been operated on). Obamacare taking that away? A good thing. The medicaid expansion was significant for several of my friends, too. Suddenly, they qualified for medicaid! Again, big improvement in their quality of life. Lots wrong with the ACA, and for my part I wish we'd had the public option, but overall I don't think it made health care worse; just changed the good and bad to affect different people.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoThe unfortunate/fortunate truth is that law must always be altered in letter or interpretation to work against those that would willingly circumvent it. What if we state that a monopoly that makes up 75% of market is worthy of being broken up? Then some wealthy business owner will gladly split their company into two companies which they both own before hitting the 75% mark. And that doesn't solve monopolies as we know it - it just hides it from public view. Enforcing the law and producing the law simply becomes a big cat and mouse game. If we were smart, we would simply state that we know someone is not following the spirit of the law and we have evidence to that effect and that should still be punishable, though maybe not to the same extent until it's been established in caselaw.
- sharemywin 7y agoDiversification of ownership and change in management. The larger an organization is the more it becomes a social institution. Over some multiple of the poverty line an individual should only be allowed to own so much of a company and industry. I own company A and lists company B as a competitor Then you can only own so much of the competition. The largest companies and institutions should have term limits on upper management, board seats, and consulting arrangements. Also, the larger it is the more shareholders it needs. And there should be only one class of stock.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoOr communism 2.0? But who am I? I haven't even read the Gulag Archipelago!
- sitkack 7y agoThere is nothing socialist or communist about the parents proposal. Capitalism needs controls, we as a civilization are clearly failing at that.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> What if we state that a monopoly that makes up 75% of market is worthy of being broken up? Then some wealthy business owner will gladly split their company into two companies which they both own before hitting the 75% mark. That's a "trust". That's explicitly what "anti-trust" is for.
- cmurf 7y agoCompetitive free markets are contrary to aristocratic ideology. Competition is expensive to the supplier, it costs them growth and profits. Of course they are in favor of mergers, conglomeration, and anti-competitive practices, and will pay dearly to promote politicians, state and federal attorneys, and judges to not apply competition law and to weaken it. If consumers aren't paying attention when they vote, they're not just acknowledging their ignorance, they're giving up their one really powerful non-violent opportunity to force competitive markets to exist.